• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

How the Constituent Assembly was formed and how it worked

Describe the composition of the Constituent Assembly under the Cabinet Mission plan, the key dates from its first sitting to the Constitution coming into force, and its principle of deliberation and procedures.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the Cabinet Mission plan for forming the Constituent Assembly.
  • Recall the key dates and figures given in the chapter for the Assembly's work.
  • Explain the principle of deliberation, public reason and the Assembly's procedures.

The previous lesson said a constitution draws authority from the credibility of its makers. How far does the Indian Constitution pass this test? To answer, the chapter looks at who sat in the Constituent Assembly and how it worked.

Formation under the Cabinet Mission plan

Formally, the Constitution was made by a Constituent Assembly elected for undivided India. It held its first sitting on 9 December 1946 and reassembled as the Constituent Assembly for divided India on 14 August 1947. Its members were chosen by indirect election by members of the Provincial Legislative Assemblies established under the Government of India Act, 1935. Its composition roughly followed the plan proposed by a committee of the British cabinet, the Cabinet Mission. Under this plan:

  • each Province and each Princely State or group of States was allotted seats roughly in proportion to population, in the ratio of about one seat for every ten lakh (1:10,00,000) people;
  • as a result, the Provinces under direct British rule were to elect 292 members, and the Princely States were allotted a minimum of 93 seats;
  • seats in each Province were divided among three main communities, Muslims, Sikhs and general, in proportion to their populations;
  • members of each community in the Provincial Legislative Assembly elected their own representatives by proportional representation with single transferable vote;
  • the method of choosing representatives of Princely States was to be decided by consultation.

Composition after Partition

After the Partition under the plan of 3 June 1947, members elected from territories that went to Pakistan ceased to be members, and the Assembly was reduced to 299 members. The Constitution was adopted on 26 November 1949. On 24 January 1950, 284 members were present and signed the Constitution as finally passed. It came into force on 26 January 1950. The Constitution was framed amid the terrible violence of Partition; the chapter credits the framers with learning the right lesson from it, committing the Constitution to a citizenship in which minorities would be secure and religious identity would have no bearing on citizenship rights.

Key dates given in the chapter
DateEvent
9 December 1946First sitting of the Constituent Assembly (for undivided India)
3 June 1947Plan of Partition; members from areas going to Pakistan later ceased to be members
14 August 1947Reassembled as the Constituent Assembly for divided India
26 November 1949Constitution adopted
24 January 1950284 members present sign the Constitution
26 January 1950Constitution comes into force

Was the Assembly representative?

Members were not elected by universal suffrage, yet there was a serious attempt to make the Assembly representative. Members of all religions were represented under the scheme; the Assembly also had twenty-eight members from the Scheduled Castes. The Congress held about eighty-two per cent of the seats after Partition, but the Congress itself was so diverse that it accommodated almost all shades of opinion.

The principle of deliberation

The Assembly's authority came not only from being broadly, though not perfectly, representative, but also from its procedures and the values members brought to its debates. Members deliberated with the interests of the whole nation in mind. They disagreed often, but few disagreements came from protecting their own interests; they were legitimate differences of principle. Members debated, for example:

  • whether India should have a centralised or decentralised system of government;
  • what the relations between the States and the centre should be;
  • what powers the judiciary should have;
  • whether the Constitution should protect property rights.

Only one provision passed virtually without debate: universal suffrage, meaning that all citizens reaching a certain age would be voters irrespective of religion, caste, education, gender or income. The chapter treats this as the best testament to the Assembly's democratic commitment. Members practised what the chapter calls public reason: they gave principled reasons to one another instead of simply pushing their own interests. Having to persuade others with reasons pulls a speaker away from narrow self-interest. The chapter says these debates deserve to be remembered as one of the most significant chapters in the history of constitution making, equal in importance to the French and American revolutions.

Procedures

The Assembly had eight major committees on different subjects, usually chaired by Jawaharlal Nehru, Rajendra Prasad, Sardar Patel or B.R. Ambedkar. These leaders did not agree on many things: Ambedkar had been a bitter critic of the Congress and Gandhi for not doing enough for the Scheduled Castes, and Patel and Nehru disagreed on many issues. Yet they worked together. Each committee drafted particular provisions, which the whole Assembly then debated. An attempt was usually made to reach consensus, on the belief that provisions agreed by all would not harm any particular interest; some provisions were put to a vote. Every argument, query or concern was answered carefully in writing. The Assembly met for 166 days, spread over two years and eleven months, and its sessions were open to the press and the public. Dr Rajendra Prasad was the President of the Assembly and Dr B.R. Ambedkar the Chairman of its Drafting Committee.

How a provision moved through the Assembly

  1. Committee drafts One of the major committees drafts particular provisions.
  2. Assembly debates The whole Assembly scrutinises and debates each clause.
  3. Concerns answered Every argument, query or concern is responded to in writing.
  4. Consensus or vote Consensus is sought; some provisions are put to a vote.
  5. Provision adopted The agreed text becomes part of the Constitution.

The Constituent Assembly drew authority from being broadly representative and, above all, from deliberation: members argued from principle for the good of the whole nation, gave reasons to one another, and worked openly through committees and full debate.

Worked example 1: counting seats under the plan

Under the Cabinet Mission plan, the Provinces were to elect 292 members and the Princely States had a minimum of 93 seats. What was the planned minimum total? Working: 292 + 93 = 385. After Partition the Assembly was reduced to 299 members, and 284 of them signed on 24 January 1950. The difference between members and signatories is 299 − 284 = 15.

Worked example 2: was the Assembly undemocratic?

A student argues: 'The Constituent Assembly did not represent Indians because it was not elected by all citizens.' Evaluation using the chapter: the premise is true: members were indirectly elected by provincial assemblies. But the conclusion does not follow fully. The scheme gave seats to all religions and to Scheduled Castes; the dominant party itself held a wide range of opinions; members deliberated for the whole nation; and the people later accepted the Constitution by abiding by it. So the Assembly was broadly, though not perfectly, representative.

Key takeaways: the Assembly first sat on 9 December 1946, was formed by indirect election under the Cabinet Mission plan (292 provincial members and a minimum of 93 from Princely States, PR by single transferable vote), and after Partition had 299 members. The Constitution was adopted on 26 November 1949, signed by 284 members on 24 January 1950 and came into force on 26 January 1950. Its authority came from broad representation, public reason, eight major committees, open sessions and 166 days of debate over two years and eleven months.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. By whom were the members of the Constituent Assembly chosen?

    1. Directly by all adult citizens
    2. By the members of the Provincial Legislative Assemblies, through indirect election
    3. By the British Parliament
    4. By the Princely rulers alone
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter states that members were chosen by indirect election by members of the Provincial Legislative Assemblies set up under the Government of India Act, 1935.

  2. 2. Under the Cabinet Mission plan, seats in each Province were divided among which three main communities?

    1. Hindus, Muslims and Christians
    2. Muslims, Sikhs and general
    3. Sikhs, Christians and Parsis
    4. Muslims, Sikhs and Scheduled Castes
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Seats in each Province were distributed among three main communities, Muslims, Sikhs and general, in proportion to their populations.

  3. 3. Which provision, according to the chapter, was passed by the Constituent Assembly virtually without any debate?

    1. Protection of property rights
    2. Relations between the States and the centre
    3. The powers of the judiciary
    4. Universal suffrage
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Almost every issue was debated, but universal suffrage, the right of all citizens of a certain age to vote irrespective of religion, caste, education, gender or income, was introduced virtually without debate, which shows the Assembly's democratic commitment.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): The Constituent Assembly's authority came partly from the procedures it followed. Reason (R): Its members gave principled reasons to each other, and its sessions were open to the press and the public.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and the reason explains the assertion. The chapter says the Assembly's authority came from its procedures and values: public reason, debate on every clause, written replies to concerns, and open sessions.

  5. 5. How many members of the Constituent Assembly were present and signed the Constitution on 24 January 1950, according to the chapter?

    1. 284
    2. 299
    3. 292
    4. 389
    Show answer

    Answer: A. After Partition the Assembly had 299 members; 284 were actually present on 24 January 1950 and signed the Constitution as finally passed.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery