• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why a society needs a constitution: coordination, assurance and who decides

Explain the first two functions of a constitution: giving a diverse group basic rules it can rely on, and specifying who has the power to make decisions and how government is constituted.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why a diverse group needs basic rules that are publicly known and enforceable.
  • State the first two functions of a constitution in the textbook's words and in your own.
  • Distinguish monarchical, one-party and democratic answers to the question 'who gets to decide?'

Before we study elections, Parliament, the President or the courts, we need to understand where all these institutions come from. In India, the whole structure of government and the principles that bind its institutions together have their origin in one document: the Constitution of India. This first lesson asks a simple but deep question: why does any society need a constitution at all?

A thought experiment: a large, diverse group

Imagine you belong to a large group whose members differ in almost every way. They follow different religions or none, do different jobs, have different abilities, tastes and incomes, and belong to different age groups. They will disagree on many questions: how much property a person may own, whether every child must go to school, whether to spend more on security or on parks, whether some members may be treated worse than others. Yet the members depend on one another and must live together. What allows such a group to live together peacefully?

The textbook's answer is that the group needs some basic rules. Without them, every member would feel insecure, because nobody would know what others might do or who could claim rights over what. Two conditions make such rules useful:

  • Publicly promulgated and known to all. Rules that only a few people know cannot coordinate the behaviour of everyone. Publicity gives a minimal degree of coordination.
  • Enforceable. Knowing the rules is not enough. If you have no assurance that others will obey, you have no reason to obey either. Legal enforceability, with punishment for breaking the rules, gives everyone that assurance.

First function of a constitution: to provide a set of basic rules that allow minimal coordination among the members of a society, and the assurance that these rules will be followed because they are enforceable.

Who gets to decide?

Suppose the group agrees that it needs rules. A harder question follows at once: whose rules? You may prefer rule X and your neighbour rule Y, and each of you thinks your own rule is best. So before deciding what the rules should be, a society must decide who gets to decide. A constitution is described in the chapter as a body of fundamental principles according to which a state is constituted or governed, and answering this question is one of its most basic jobs.

A constitution therefore specifies the basic allocation of power in a society. History offers several answers:

Different answers to the question 'who gets to decide?'
Type of constitutionWho decidesExample given in the chapter
MonarchicalA monarch (king or queen)Monarchies in general
One-partyA single political partyThe old Soviet Union
DemocraticBroadly speaking, the peopleIndia and other democracies

Even the democratic answer opens further questions. Must everyone agree before something becomes law? Should people vote directly on every matter, as citizens of ancient Greek city-states did? Or should they elect representatives? If so, how are representatives to be chosen and how many should there be? A constitution settles these questions too.

The Indian Constitution, for example, specifies that in most instances Parliament decides laws and policies, and it also lays down how Parliament itself is organised. This shows something important: before you can identify the law of a society, you must identify who has the authority to enact it. If Parliament has authority to make laws, some higher law must have given it that authority in the first place. That higher law is the constitution: it is the authority that constitutes government.

Second function of a constitution: to specify who has the power to make decisions in a society, and so to decide how the government will be constituted.

From a diverse group to a constituted government

  1. Diverse group Members differ in religion, work, income, age and opinions, yet depend on each other.
  2. Need for basic rules Rules must be publicly known (coordination) and enforceable (assurance).
  3. Who decides? The constitution allocates power: a monarch, a party, or the people.
  4. How do people decide? Directly or through elected representatives organised in a particular way.
  5. Government constituted An institution such as Parliament gets authority to make laws.

Worked example 1: a housing society without rules

A made-up housing society of 300 families has no written rules. One family parks in the common garden; another plays loud music at night; a third refuses to pay for the watchman. Analysis: each problem arises because nobody knows what is allowed (no coordination) and nobody expects others to obey any rule (no assurance). If the society writes down basic rules, displays them where all can read them and attaches penalties, families can predict each other's behaviour. That is the first function of a constitution, on a small scale.

Worked example 2: whose rule wins?

In the same made-up society, half the families want the garden turned into a parking area and half want it kept green. Arguing about the garden itself goes nowhere. Analysis: the deadlock is broken only by an earlier agreement on procedure: for instance, that an elected committee decides such matters, or that every family votes and the majority wins. Agreeing on who decides and how comes before agreeing on what is decided. This is the second function of a constitution.

Worked example 3: tracing authority back

A student asks: 'Why must I obey a law passed by Parliament?' Reasoning: the law is valid because Parliament made it; Parliament can make laws because the Constitution gives it that power and lays down how it is formed. So the chain of authority runs from the law, to Parliament, to the Constitution. This is why the textbook treats the constitution as the authority that constitutes government.

Key takeaways: a diverse society can live together only if it has basic rules that are publicly known and enforceable, giving coordination and assurance. Before deciding what the rules are, a society must decide who gets to decide; a constitution allocates this power and specifies how government is constituted. In India, Parliament makes most laws because the Constitution grants and organises that power.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the chapter, why must the basic rules of a group be enforceable and not merely known?

    1. Because enforcement makes the rules easier to read
    2. Because without assurance that others will obey, nobody has a reason to obey
    3. Because only enforceable rules can be written down
    4. Because enforcement removes all disagreements
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Knowing the rules gives coordination, but people obey only if they are assured others will too. Legal enforceability, backed by punishment, provides that assurance. Enforcement does not remove disagreement, and it has nothing to do with readability.

  2. 2. Which statement best describes the second function of a constitution?

    1. It lists the duties of every citizen
    2. It guarantees that good people come to power
    3. It specifies who has the power to make decisions and how government is constituted
    4. It fixes the prices of essential goods
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The second function is to specify the basic allocation of power: who gets to decide what the laws will be, and how the government is constituted. A constitution cannot guarantee that good people come to power.

  3. 3. In the chapter's example of the old Soviet Union, who was given the power to decide?

    1. The people directly
    2. A monarch
    3. Elected judges
    4. One single party
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter contrasts a monarchical constitution (a monarch decides), the old Soviet Union (one single party decides) and democratic constitutions (broadly, the people decide).

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Before identifying the law of a society, one must identify who has the authority to enact it. Reason (R): A law is valid only if some higher law, the constitution, has given the law-maker authority to make it.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true. The reason explains the assertion: Parliament's laws count as law because the Constitution bestows law-making authority on Parliament, so we first need to know who has that authority.

  5. 5. Read the case: In a made-up village, a committee announces new rules but tells only its own members, so other villagers keep breaking them unknowingly. Which requirement of basic rules is missing?

    1. The rules are not publicly promulgated and known to all
    2. The rules are too strict
    3. The rules were not made by a monarch
    4. The rules do not mention property
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Rules give coordination only if they are publicly made known to every member. Here the villagers cannot follow rules they have never been told, so publicity is missing.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery