- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Limiting government, enabling it, and expressing a people's identity
Explain the third, fourth and fifth functions of a constitution: limits on government power, an enabling framework for a just society, and the expression of a people's political and moral identity.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain how fundamental rights limit what any government may impose on citizens.
- Describe how constitutions such as India's, South Africa's and Indonesia's enable governments to pursue social goals.
- Explain in what ways a constitution expresses the fundamental identity of a people.
Knowing who decides is not enough. A government that came to power by the correct procedure might still pass laws that are plainly unjust. This lesson covers the remaining functions the chapter assigns to a constitution: it limits government, it enables government to do good, and it gives a people its identity.
Limitations on the powers of government
Imagine that a properly constituted authority banned you from practising your religion, forbade clothes of a certain colour, said that members of one caste or religion must always serve others and own no property, allowed arbitrary arrests, or permitted only people of one skin colour to draw water from wells. Even though such laws were passed by a government formed through proper procedures, you would rightly see them as unjust. So the third function of a constitution is to set limits on what a government can impose on its citizens. These limits are fundamental: government may never trespass them.
The most common way of limiting government is to list certain fundamental rights that citizens possess and that no government may violate. Their exact content and interpretation differ from one constitution to another, but most protect a basic cluster:
- protection from arbitrary arrest, that is, being arrested without reason;
- freedom of speech;
- freedom of conscience;
- freedom of association;
- freedom to carry on a trade or business.
In practice these rights can be limited during a national emergency, and the constitution itself specifies the circumstances in which they may be withdrawn.
Third function of a constitution: to set limits on what a government can impose on its citizens, usually by guaranteeing fundamental rights that no government may violate.
Aspirations and goals of a society
Most older constitutions did only two things: allocate decision-making power and limit government. Many twentieth-century constitutions went further, and the chapter calls the Indian Constitution the finest example. They provide an enabling framework so that government can take positive measures. A society with deeply entrenched inequalities needs more than limits on government; it needs a government empowered to overcome inequality and deprivation.
India aspires to be free of caste discrimination, so its government must be empowered to take the steps needed for that goal. South Africa, with its long history of racial discrimination, needed a constitution that enabled government to end it. The framers of the Indian Constitution believed every person should have what is needed for a life of minimal dignity and social self-respect, such as minimum material well-being and education. The chapter notes that such enabling provisions are supported by the Preamble, appear in the section on Fundamental Rights, and that the Directive Principles of State Policy also direct government to fulfil certain aspirations of the people. Some of these welfare measures are legally enforceable.
| Constitution | Responsibilities given to government (as described in the chapter) |
|---|---|
| South Africa | Promote conservation of nature; protect persons or groups facing unfair discrimination; progressively ensure adequate housing, health care and similar needs |
| Indonesia | Establish and conduct a national education system; look after poor and destitute children |
| India | Take positive welfare measures to end caste discrimination and secure a life of minimal dignity; Directive Principles guide government towards the people's aspirations |
Fourth function of a constitution: to enable the government to fulfil the aspirations of a society and create conditions for a just society.
Fundamental identity of a people
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, a constitution expresses the fundamental identity of a people. The chapter explains this in three steps:
- Political identity. People have many identities before any constitution exists, but they become a collective political people by agreeing on basic norms about how they will be governed and who will be governed.
- Moral identity. Constitutional norms are the overarching framework within which individuals pursue their own goals. The constitution sets authoritative limits on what one may do and defines values one may not trespass.
- Shared values. Many basic political and moral values are now shared across constitutional traditions: most modern constitutions create a government that is democratic in some respects and claim to protect basic rights.
Constitutions still differ in how they embody national identity. The chapter's example: German identity was constituted by being ethnically German, and its constitution expressed that, whereas the Indian Constitution does not make ethnic identity a criterion for citizenship. Nations also differ in how they define the relationship between their regions and the central government, and this relationship too forms part of national identity.
Five functions of a constitution
-
Coordination and assurance
- Basic rules known to all
- Rules enforceable
-
Who decides
- Allocates power
- Constitutes government
-
Limits on government
- Fundamental rights
- Withdrawal only in specified emergencies
-
Enabling a just society
- Positive welfare measures
- Directive Principles
-
Fundamental identity
- Political identity
- Moral identity
- Conception of nationhood
Worked example 1: classify the provision
Match each provision to a function. (a) 'The government cannot order any citizen to follow or not follow a religion.' (b) 'The government must try to reduce inequalities of income and wealth.' (c) 'The President has the power to appoint the Prime Minister.' (d) 'Citizenship is not limited to people of any race, caste or religion.' Working: (a) restrains government, so it is a limitation on government power. (b) asks government to act positively, so it is an enabling provision for a just society. (c) says who holds a power, so it specifies decision-making authority. (d) states who belongs to the political community, so it expresses fundamental identity.
Worked example 2: limit or enable?
A made-up country's constitution says: 'No person shall be detained without being told the grounds' and 'The State shall work to provide every child with free schooling.' Reasoning: the first sentence tells government what it may not do, so it limits power. The second tells government what it should do, so it enables government to pursue a social goal. A modern constitution such as India's contains both kinds of provision.
Key takeaways: a constitution limits government, mainly through fundamental rights, which may be restricted only in circumstances the constitution itself specifies. Many twentieth-century constitutions, with India's as the finest example in the chapter's view, also enable government to take positive steps towards a just society. A constitution expresses a people's political and moral identity, and its conception of nationhood; India's does not make ethnicity a basis of citizenship.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of the following is the most common way in which constitutions limit the power of government?
- By making the head of state hereditary
- By specifying fundamental rights that no government may violate
- By banning political parties
- By holding elections every year
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says the most common way of limiting government is to specify fundamental rights that citizens possess and that no government can violate.
-
2. According to the chapter, what did many twentieth-century constitutions add to the older functions of allocating power and limiting government?
- An enabling framework for government to take positive measures towards society's goals
- A ban on all amendments
- Rule by a single party
- Abolition of the judiciary
Show answer
Answer: A. Older constitutions mostly allocated power and set limits. Many twentieth-century constitutions, with India's as the chapter's finest example, also enable government to pursue the aspirations and goals of society.
-
3. Which country's constitution, as described in the chapter, requires the government to establish and conduct a national education system and look after poor and destitute children?
- South Africa
- Germany
- Indonesia
- The United Kingdom
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter gives Indonesia as the example of a constitution that enjoins government to run a national education system and care for poor and destitute children. South Africa's example concerns nature, discrimination, housing and health care.
-
4. Assertion (A): The Indian Constitution does not make ethnic identity a criterion for citizenship. Reason (R): Every constitution in the world defines national identity in exactly the same way.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: C. The assertion is true, as the chapter says. The reason is false: the chapter stresses that constitutions differ in how they embody national identity, contrasting Germany's ethnic conception with India's.
-
5. Read the provision: 'The government must try to reduce inequalities in income and wealth.' Which function of a constitution does it mainly perform?
- Specifying who decides
- Coordination and assurance
- Limiting the power of government
- Enabling the government to fulfil the aspirations of society
Show answer
Answer: D. The provision asks the government to take positive action towards a more equal society. That is the enabling function, not a limit on government or an allocation of power.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.