- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
The authority of a constitution: what makes it effective
Define a constitution, explain why some constitutions stay on paper, and analyse the three factors the chapter links to effectiveness: mode of promulgation, substantive provisions and balanced institutional design.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain what a constitution is, including the case of the United Kingdom.
- Analyse the mode of promulgation, substantive provisions and balanced institutional design as factors of effectiveness.
- Explain why a constitution must be neither too rigid nor too flexible.
Many countries have constitutions that exist only on paper. Why do some constitutions shape the real lives of people while others are ignored or overthrown? The chapter now turns from what a constitution does to three further questions: what is a constitution, how effective is it, and is it just?
What is a constitution?
In most countries the constitution is a compact document made up of a number of articles about the state: how it is constituted and what norms it must follow. Some countries, such as the United Kingdom, have no single document called the Constitution. Instead, a series of documents and decisions together are referred to as the constitution. So the chapter defines a constitution broadly: it is the document or set of documents that seeks to perform the functions studied in the previous lessons.
Factor 1: mode of promulgation
Mode of promulgation means how a constitution comes into being: who drafted it and how much authority they had. Constitutions drafted by military leaders, or by unpopular leaders who cannot carry people with them, often remain defunct. The most successful constitutions, the chapter says, such as those of India, South Africa and the United States, were created in the aftermath of popular national movements.
India's Constitution was formally created by a Constituent Assembly between December 1946 and November 1949, but it drew on a long nationalist movement that had brought different sections of society together. It drew legitimacy from the credibility of its makers, who could negotiate with and command respect across society and who convinced people it was not a tool to increase their personal power. Some countries hold a referendum, in which all people vote on the constitution. India's Constitution was never put to a referendum, yet it carried great public authority because it had the backing of popular leaders, and the people adopted it as their own by abiding by its provisions.
Case box: constitution making in Nepal
The chapter uses Nepal to show that constitution making is not always smooth. Since 1948 Nepal had five constitutions, in 1948, 1951, 1959, 1962 and 1990, all 'granted' by the King. The 1990 constitution allowed multi-party competition, but the King kept final powers in many respects. The central dispute was the role of the monarchy: some groups wanted a republic, others a limited monarchy. The King took over all powers in October 2002; after popular agitation a government acceptable to the agitating parties stripped him of almost all powers. In 2008 Nepal became a democratic republic after abolishing the monarchy, and it adopted a new constitution in 2015. The lesson for us: a constitution granted from above, without popular participation, struggles to command lasting authority.
Factor 2: substantive provisions
A successful constitution gives everyone in society some reason to go along with its provisions. A constitution that let permanent majorities oppress minorities, that systematically privileged some members at the cost of others, or that entrenched the power of small groups, would lose allegiance; a group that feels its identity is being stifled has no reason to obey it. No constitution achieves perfect justice, but it must convince people that it offers a framework for pursuing basic justice. The more a constitution preserves the freedom and equality of all its members, the more likely it is to succeed.
Factor 3: balanced institutional design
Constitutions are often subverted not by the people but by small groups wishing to enlarge their own power. Well-crafted constitutions fragment power so that no single institution acquires a monopoly. The Indian Constitution horizontally divides power among the legislature, executive and judiciary, and independent bodies such as the Election Commission. If one institution tries to subvert the Constitution, the others can check it. The chapter credits this system of checks and balances for part of the Indian Constitution's success.
A second aspect of good design is balance between stability and change. A constitution that is too rigid is likely to break under the weight of change; one that is too flexible gives people no security, predictability or identity. By allowing changes but placing limits on them, the Indian Constitution is described as a living document (studied in Chapter 9), and no single group can on its own subvert it.
Rigid, flexible and balanced constitutions
-
Too rigid
- Hard to change at all
- Likely to break under the weight of change
-
Too flexible
- Changes easily and often
- Gives no security, predictability or identity
-
Balanced (the chapter's view of India)
- Core values preserved
- Provisions can adapt within limits
- Described as a living document
| Question to ask | Factor it tests | Where the book answers it |
|---|---|---|
| Were the people who enacted the constitution credible? | Mode of promulgation | The rest of this chapter |
| Is power intelligently organised so that no group can easily subvert it? | Balanced institutional design | Chapters on the institutions |
| Does it give everyone a reason to go along with it, and is it the locus of people's hopes? | Substantive provisions and justice | Most of the book, and the last chapter on philosophy |
A constitution is effective when credible people make it, when its provisions give everyone a reason to accept it by preserving freedom and equality, and when it divides power wisely and balances stability with the ability to change.
Worked example 1: a constitution drafted by an army council
In a made-up country, an army council writes a constitution in secret and announces it on the radio. Two years later it is widely ignored. Analysis: the mode of promulgation was weak: its authors lacked popular credibility and did not carry people with them. Compare India, where a Constituent Assembly of widely respected leaders drew on a national movement, so people accepted the document by living by it, even without a referendum.
Worked example 2: the permanent majority
A made-up constitution says that only members of the largest language group may hold public office. Analysis: its substantive provisions fail the test of giving everyone a reason to go along with it. Smaller groups would feel their identity stifled and would have no reason to respect the document, so allegiance would weaken.
Worked example 3: one office with every power
A made-up constitution lets the head of government make laws, appoint and remove all judges at will, and run elections. Analysis: power is concentrated, not fragmented. There is no other institution to check a transgression, so a small group around the leader could easily subvert the constitution. The Indian design spreads power among legislature, executive, judiciary and bodies like the Election Commission to prevent this.
Key takeaways: a constitution is the document or set of documents that performs the functions of a constitution; the UK has no single such document. Effectiveness depends on the mode of promulgation, on substantive provisions that give everyone a reason to accept it, and on balanced institutional design with checks and balances and the right mix of rigidity and flexibility. India's Constitution was not put to a referendum but gained authority from credible makers and from people abiding by it.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which country is given in the chapter as an example of a state that does not have one single document called the Constitution?
- India
- The United States
- The United Kingdom
- South Africa
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says that the United Kingdom has a series of documents and decisions that together are referred to as its constitution, rather than one single document.
-
2. What does 'mode of promulgation' refer to?
- How a constitution comes into being: who drafted it and with how much authority
- The number of articles in a constitution
- The language in which a constitution is printed
- The procedure for electing the President
Show answer
Answer: A. Mode of promulgation is about how a constitution comes into being: who crafted it and how much authority they had. Constitutions drafted by unpopular or military leaders often remain defunct.
-
3. Read the case: Since 1948 a country had five constitutions, each 'granted' by its King, and a long struggle followed over the role of the monarchy until it became a democratic republic in 2008. Which country does the chapter describe, and what does it illustrate?
- Japan; the role of an occupying army
- Iraq; ethnic conflict over a new constitution
- Nepal; the difficulty of constitution making when constitutions are granted from above
- South Africa; ending racial discrimination
Show answer
Answer: C. This is the chapter's box on Nepal: constitutions of 1948, 1951, 1959, 1962 and 1990 were granted by the King; the monarchy was abolished in 2008 and a new constitution adopted in 2015. It shows how hard constitution making is without popular authority.
-
4. Assertion (A): A constitution that is too flexible is likely to succeed because it can adapt to every change. Reason (R): A constitution that is too flexible gives people no security, predictability or identity.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: D. The assertion is false: the chapter says successful constitutions balance preserving core values with adapting to change; too much flexibility is a weakness. The reason is true and is exactly why excessive flexibility is a problem.
-
5. The Indian Constitution horizontally fragments power across the legislature, executive, judiciary and independent bodies such as the Election Commission. According to the chapter, what is the main purpose of this?
- To make government faster
- To reduce the cost of administration
- To give all power to the judiciary
- To ensure that if one institution tries to subvert the Constitution, others can check it
Show answer
Answer: D. Fragmenting power means no single institution gains a monopoly of power, so others can check any transgression. The chapter credits this system of checks and balances with part of the Constitution's success.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.