• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Inheritance of the nationalist movement, the Objectives Resolution and borrowed provisions

Explain how the nationalist movement shaped the Constitution, list the main points of the Objectives Resolution, and match provisions adapted from other constitutions to their sources.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why the nationalist movement provided a background consensus for the Constitution.
  • List the main points of the Objectives Resolution moved by Nehru in 1946.
  • Match borrowed provisions to the British, US, Irish, French and Canadian constitutions and explain why borrowing was not imitation.

No constitution is simply the product of the assembly that writes it. A body as diverse as India's Constituent Assembly could not have worked without broad agreement, built in advance, on the main principles the Constitution should contain. This lesson looks at where that agreement came from and how the Assembly designed the institutions.

Inheritance of the nationalist movement

The principles were forged during the long struggle for freedom. For decades before the Constitution, the nationalist movement had debated what form of government India should have, what values it should uphold and what inequalities it must overcome. The Constituent Assembly gave concrete shape and form to principles inherited from that movement. In this sense the Constitution is not merely a maze of rules and procedures but a moral commitment to establish a government that will fulfil the promises the nationalist movement made to the people.

The Objectives Resolution

The chapter calls the Objectives Resolution, moved by Jawaharlal Nehru in 1946, perhaps the best summary of the principles the nationalist movement brought to the Assembly. It defined the aims of the Assembly. Based on it, the Constitution gave institutional expression to fundamental commitments: equality, liberty, democracy, sovereignty and a cosmopolitan identity. Its main points, in summary:

  1. India is an independent, sovereign republic.
  2. India shall be a Union of the former British Indian territories, the Indian States, and other parts willing to join the Union.
  3. The territories of the Union shall be autonomous units exercising all powers of government except those assigned to or vested in the Union.
  4. All power and authority of sovereign, independent India and its constitution flow from the people.
  5. All people shall be guaranteed social, economic and political justice; equality of status, of opportunity and before law; and fundamental freedoms of speech, expression, belief, faith, worship, vocation, association and action, subject to law and public morality.
  6. Adequate safeguards shall be provided for minorities, backward and tribal areas, and depressed and other backward classes.
  7. The territorial integrity of the Republic and its sovereign rights on land, sea and air shall be maintained according to justice and the law of civilised nations.
  8. India shall make a full and willing contribution to world peace and the welfare of mankind.

Institutional arrangements

The third factor in effectiveness, balanced institutions, was also worked out with care. The basic principle was that government must be democratic and committed to the welfare of the people. The Assembly spent much time balancing the executive, legislature and judiciary. This led to the adoption of the parliamentary form and the federal arrangement, which distribute power between the legislature and the executive on one side and between the States and the central government on the other.

Learning from other constitutions

The framers were not averse to learning from other countries' experiments. The chapter treats their ability to use any useful argument or historical example as a testament to their wide learning. But borrowing was not slavish imitation: each provision had to be defended as suited to Indian problems and aspirations. Dr B.R. Ambedkar argued in the Assembly, in substance, that a constitution framed so late in history could hardly contain entirely new things; what was new were the variations made to remove faults and to fit the document to the country's needs.

Provisions adapted from constitutions of different countries
Source constitutionProvisions adapted (as listed in the chapter)
BritishFirst past the post; parliamentary form of government; the idea of the rule of law; the institution of the Speaker and her or his role; law-making procedure
United StatesCharter of fundamental rights; power of judicial review and independence of the judiciary
IrishDirective Principles of State Policy
FrenchPrinciples of liberty, equality and fraternity
CanadianA quasi-federal form of government (a federal system with a strong central government); the idea of residual powers

Where some provisions came from

  • British
    • First past the post
    • Parliamentary form
    • Rule of law
    • Speaker
    • Law-making procedure
  • United States
    • Fundamental rights
    • Judicial review
    • Independent judiciary
  • Irish
    • Directive Principles
  • French
    • Liberty, equality, fraternity
  • Canadian
    • Quasi-federal government
    • Residual powers

Liberty, equality and fraternity together

In his speech of 25 November 1949, Ambedkar argued that political democracy cannot last unless social democracy, a way of life recognising liberty, equality and fraternity, lies at its base. In his view the three cannot be separated: liberty without equality lets a few dominate the many, equality without liberty kills individual initiative, and without fraternity neither liberty nor equality becomes a natural part of life. This is a summary in our own words, not his exact text.

The Constitution gave institutional form to principles inherited from the freedom struggle and summed up in the Objectives Resolution; it borrowed widely, but every borrowed provision was adapted to Indian problems and aspirations.

Worked example 1: identify the source

Name the source of each feature: (a) Directive Principles of State Policy; (b) judicial review; (c) residual powers; (d) the Speaker's role. Working: (a) Irish Constitution; (b) United States Constitution, along with independence of the judiciary; (c) Canadian Constitution, along with the quasi-federal form; (d) British Constitution, along with the parliamentary form and law-making procedure.

Worked example 2: was it a borrowed constitution?

A student claims: 'There is little originality in our Constitution because so much was borrowed.' Evaluation: the framers did borrow from several constitutions. But each provision was debated and justified as suited to India, and many were changed to remove faults and fit Indian needs. The Constitution also rests on principles that came from India's own nationalist movement, summed up in the Objectives Resolution. So the claim is incorrect: borrowing was selective adaptation, not copying. The chapter even notes that India's Constitution in turn became an example for others, most notably South Africa.

Worked example 3: from resolution to Constitution

Which commitment of the Constitution matches the Objectives Resolution's point that 'all power and authority flow from the people'? Reasoning: this point expresses popular sovereignty, which the Constitution gives form to through democracy: elected representatives and universal adult suffrage. The point about safeguards for minorities and backward classes matches the commitment to equality.

Key takeaways: a background consensus forged in the freedom struggle made the Assembly's work possible, and the Objectives Resolution moved by Nehru in 1946 summed up its values. The Constitution gave form to equality, liberty, democracy, sovereignty and a cosmopolitan identity, adopted the parliamentary form and a federal arrangement, and borrowed from British, US, Irish, French and Canadian constitutions, adapting each provision to Indian needs. The chapter concludes that this careful balance is one reason the Constitution has become a living reality.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who moved the Objectives Resolution in the Constituent Assembly?

    1. Dr Rajendra Prasad
    2. Sardar Patel
    3. Jawaharlal Nehru
    4. Dr B.R. Ambedkar
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter states that the Objectives Resolution, which defined the aims of the Assembly, was moved by Jawaharlal Nehru in 1946.

  2. 2. From which constitution did the framers adapt the Directive Principles of State Policy?

    1. Irish
    2. French
    3. Canadian
    4. United States
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter's table lists the Directive Principles of State Policy under the Irish Constitution.

  3. 3. The idea of a quasi-federal form of government, a federal system with a strong central government, was adapted from the constitution of:

    1. Britain
    2. Canada
    3. France
    4. Ireland
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Canadian Constitution is the source given for a quasi-federal form of government and for the idea of residual powers.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): The framers of the Indian Constitution borrowed provisions from several other constitutions. Reason (R): Each borrowed provision had to be defended as suited to Indian problems and aspirations, so borrowing was not slavish imitation.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Both statements are true, as the chapter says. But R does not explain why the framers borrowed; it explains how they borrowed (by adapting). The reason they borrowed was to learn from the experiments and experience of other countries.

  5. 5. Which of the following is NOT one of the main points of the Objectives Resolution?

    1. India is an independent, sovereign republic
    2. All power and authority flow from the people
    3. Adequate safeguards for minorities and backward classes
    4. India shall have a single official religion
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Objectives Resolution declared India a sovereign republic, located all power in the people, and promised freedoms of belief, faith and worship and safeguards for minorities. A single official religion contradicts these freedoms and is not part of it.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery