Revision notes

Chapter 1 Constitution: Why and How?: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Why a society needs a constitution: coordination, assurance and who decides

First function of a constitution: to provide a set of basic rules that allow minimal coordination among the members of a society, and the assurance that these rules will be followed because they are enforceable.

Different answers to the question 'who gets to decide?'
Type of constitutionWho decidesExample given in the chapter
MonarchicalA monarch (king or queen)Monarchies in general
One-partyA single political partyThe old Soviet Union
DemocraticBroadly speaking, the peopleIndia and other democracies

Second function of a constitution: to specify who has the power to make decisions in a society, and so to decide how the government will be constituted.

From a diverse group to a constituted government

  1. Diverse group Members differ in religion, work, income, age and opinions, yet depend on each other.
  2. Need for basic rules Rules must be publicly known (coordination) and enforceable (assurance).
  3. Who decides? The constitution allocates power: a monarch, a party, or the people.
  4. How do people decide? Directly or through elected representatives organised in a particular way.
  5. Government constituted An institution such as Parliament gets authority to make laws.

Key takeaways: a diverse society can live together only if it has basic rules that are publicly known and enforceable, giving coordination and assurance. Before deciding what the rules are, a society must decide who gets to decide; a constitution allocates this power and specifies how government is constituted. In India, Parliament makes most laws because the Constitution grants and organises that power.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Limiting government, enabling it, and expressing a people's identity

Third function of a constitution: to set limits on what a government can impose on its citizens, usually by guaranteeing fundamental rights that no government may violate.

Enabling provisions in three constitutions
ConstitutionResponsibilities given to government (as described in the chapter)
South AfricaPromote conservation of nature; protect persons or groups facing unfair discrimination; progressively ensure adequate housing, health care and similar needs
IndonesiaEstablish and conduct a national education system; look after poor and destitute children
IndiaTake positive welfare measures to end caste discrimination and secure a life of minimal dignity; Directive Principles guide government towards the people's aspirations

Fourth function of a constitution: to enable the government to fulfil the aspirations of a society and create conditions for a just society.

Five functions of a constitution

  • Coordination and assurance
    • Basic rules known to all
    • Rules enforceable
  • Who decides
    • Allocates power
    • Constitutes government
  • Limits on government
    • Fundamental rights
    • Withdrawal only in specified emergencies
  • Enabling a just society
    • Positive welfare measures
    • Directive Principles
  • Fundamental identity
    • Political identity
    • Moral identity
    • Conception of nationhood

Key takeaways: a constitution limits government, mainly through fundamental rights, which may be restricted only in circumstances the constitution itself specifies. Many twentieth-century constitutions, with India's as the finest example in the chapter's view, also enable government to take positive steps towards a just society. A constitution expresses a people's political and moral identity, and its conception of nationhood; India's does not make ethnicity a basis of citizenship.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

The authority of a constitution: what makes it effective

Rigid, flexible and balanced constitutions

  • Too rigid
    • Hard to change at all
    • Likely to break under the weight of change
  • Too flexible
    • Changes easily and often
    • Gives no security, predictability or identity
  • Balanced (the chapter's view of India)
    • Core values preserved
    • Provisions can adapt within limits
    • Described as a living document
Three questions for judging a constitution's authority
Question to askFactor it testsWhere the book answers it
Were the people who enacted the constitution credible?Mode of promulgationThe rest of this chapter
Is power intelligently organised so that no group can easily subvert it?Balanced institutional designChapters on the institutions
Does it give everyone a reason to go along with it, and is it the locus of people's hopes?Substantive provisions and justiceMost of the book, and the last chapter on philosophy

A constitution is effective when credible people make it, when its provisions give everyone a reason to accept it by preserving freedom and equality, and when it divides power wisely and balances stability with the ability to change.

Key takeaways: a constitution is the document or set of documents that performs the functions of a constitution; the UK has no single such document. Effectiveness depends on the mode of promulgation, on substantive provisions that give everyone a reason to accept it, and on balanced institutional design with checks and balances and the right mix of rigidity and flexibility. India's Constitution was not put to a referendum but gained authority from credible makers and from people abiding by it.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

How the Constituent Assembly was formed and how it worked

Key dates given in the chapter
DateEvent
9 December 1946First sitting of the Constituent Assembly (for undivided India)
3 June 1947Plan of Partition; members from areas going to Pakistan later ceased to be members
14 August 1947Reassembled as the Constituent Assembly for divided India
26 November 1949Constitution adopted
24 January 1950284 members present sign the Constitution
26 January 1950Constitution comes into force

How a provision moved through the Assembly

  1. Committee drafts One of the major committees drafts particular provisions.
  2. Assembly debates The whole Assembly scrutinises and debates each clause.
  3. Concerns answered Every argument, query or concern is responded to in writing.
  4. Consensus or vote Consensus is sought; some provisions are put to a vote.
  5. Provision adopted The agreed text becomes part of the Constitution.

The Constituent Assembly drew authority from being broadly representative and, above all, from deliberation: members argued from principle for the good of the whole nation, gave reasons to one another, and worked openly through committees and full debate.

Key takeaways: the Assembly first sat on 9 December 1946, was formed by indirect election under the Cabinet Mission plan (292 provincial members and a minimum of 93 from Princely States, PR by single transferable vote), and after Partition had 299 members. The Constitution was adopted on 26 November 1949, signed by 284 members on 24 January 1950 and came into force on 26 January 1950. Its authority came from broad representation, public reason, eight major committees, open sessions and 166 days of debate over two years and eleven months.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Inheritance of the nationalist movement, the Objectives Resolution and borrowed provisions

Provisions adapted from constitutions of different countries
Source constitutionProvisions adapted (as listed in the chapter)
BritishFirst past the post; parliamentary form of government; the idea of the rule of law; the institution of the Speaker and her or his role; law-making procedure
United StatesCharter of fundamental rights; power of judicial review and independence of the judiciary
IrishDirective Principles of State Policy
FrenchPrinciples of liberty, equality and fraternity
CanadianA quasi-federal form of government (a federal system with a strong central government); the idea of residual powers

Where some provisions came from

  • British
    • First past the post
    • Parliamentary form
    • Rule of law
    • Speaker
    • Law-making procedure
  • United States
    • Fundamental rights
    • Judicial review
    • Independent judiciary
  • Irish
    • Directive Principles
  • French
    • Liberty, equality, fraternity
  • Canadian
    • Quasi-federal government
    • Residual powers

The Constitution gave institutional form to principles inherited from the freedom struggle and summed up in the Objectives Resolution; it borrowed widely, but every borrowed provision was adapted to Indian problems and aspirations.

Key takeaways: a background consensus forged in the freedom struggle made the Assembly's work possible, and the Objectives Resolution moved by Nehru in 1946 summed up its values. The Constitution gave form to equality, liberty, democracy, sovereignty and a cosmopolitan identity, adopted the parliamentary form and a federal arrangement, and borrowed from British, US, Irish, French and Canadian constitutions, adapting each provision to Indian needs. The chapter concludes that this careful balance is one reason the Constitution has become a living reality.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery