- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Elections and democracy: why the rules of elections are in the Constitution
Distinguish direct and indirect democracy, explain why elections alone do not make a country democratic, and identify the basic rules about elections that a democratic constitution lays down.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish direct democracy from indirect (representative) democracy with examples.
- Explain why not every election is democratic.
- List the five basic questions about elections that a constitution answers and group them into free-and-fair and fair-representation questions.
Think of a game of chess in which one player suddenly lets the knight move straight, or a cricket match with no umpire. A game needs agreed rules and an impartial umpire, fixed before play starts, and changing the rules changes the result. Elections are similar. There are different systems of conducting elections, and the result depends on the system chosen; elections also need impartial machinery. Because these decisions must be made before the electoral contest begins, they cannot be left to whichever government is in power. That is why a democratic country writes them into its constitution.
Can there be democracy without elections?
A direct democracy is one in which citizens themselves take part in day-to-day decision-making and in running the government. The ancient Greek city-states are the classic example, and many people consider local governments, especially gram sabhas, the closest present-day examples. But direct democracy cannot work when decisions involve lakhs and crores of people. So rule by the people usually means rule by the people's representatives: an indirect or representative democracy.
In representative democracy, citizens choose representatives who then govern and administer the country. The method used to choose them is an election. Citizens take part in major decisions only indirectly, through their representatives. Since elected representatives take all the major decisions, the method by which they are elected becomes very important. This is why elections have become the most visible symbol of the democratic process.
Direct and indirect democracy
-
Direct democracy
- Citizens decide day-to-day matters themselves
- Ancient Greek city-states
- Gram sabha is the closest example today
- Impractical for crores of people
-
Indirect democracy
- Citizens elect representatives
- Representatives govern and make policy
- Citizens' role in decisions is limited and indirect
- Method of election becomes crucial
Can there be elections without democracy?
Yes. Many non-democratic countries also hold elections. Non-democratic rulers are keen to appear democratic, and they hold elections in ways that do not threaten their power. So holding elections is not enough: what matters is whether the elections are democratic. The constitution of a democratic country lays down basic rules to ensure this, leaving the details to laws passed by the legislature.
The basic rules a constitution lays down
| Basic question | What it is about |
|---|---|
| Who is eligible to vote? | Free and fair elections |
| Who is eligible to contest? | Free and fair elections |
| Who is to supervise elections? | Free and fair elections |
| How do voters choose their representatives? | Fair representation |
| How are votes counted and representatives elected? | Fair representation |
The first three questions ensure that elections are free and fair and can thus be called democratic. The last two concern fair representation. This chapter studies both: the method of election (how votes become seats) and the machinery that keeps elections free and fair, followed by debates on electoral reform.
Why the method of counting matters
We are so used to our system that we assume there is only one way: people vote and the candidate with the most votes wins. In fact, there are very different ways in which people can express choices and in which their preferences can be counted. These different 'rules of the game' can change who wins. Some rules favour bigger parties, some help smaller ones; some favour the majority community, others protect minorities. The next lesson shows this with a dramatic example.
Representative democracy depends on elections, but elections are democratic only if the rules on who votes, who contests, who supervises, how people vote and how votes are counted are fair, which is why a democratic constitution fixes them in advance.
Worked example 1: which is closest to direct democracy?
Options: a family discussion, election of a class monitor, a party choosing its candidate, decisions of the gram sabha, a media opinion poll. Reasoning: direct democracy means members of a political community take public decisions themselves. Electing a monitor is representation; a party's choice and an opinion poll are not public decisions by all citizens; a family is not a political community. In a gram sabha, all adult residents of a village meet and decide, so the gram sabha is the closest.
Worked example 2: a rigged 'election'
In a made-up country, the ruler's officials prepare the voters' list, only the ruler's party may field candidates and the ruler's ministry counts the votes. Analysis: an election is held, but the answers to 'who may contest' and 'who supervises' are unfair, so the election is not democratic. A democratic constitution would allow all citizens to contest and give supervision to an independent body.
Worked example 3: why not leave the rules to Parliament?
A student asks why the method of election is written into the Constitution instead of being decided by Parliament before each election. Reasoning: the party in power would be tempted to choose rules that help it win, like a team rewriting the rules in the middle of a match. Fixing the basic rules in the Constitution puts them beyond the reach of any single government.
Key takeaways: direct democracy, as in Greek city-states or the gram sabha, is not possible for crores of people, so democracy usually means representative democracy, in which elections matter greatly. Non-democratic rulers also hold elections, so a democratic constitution lays down basic rules on who votes, who contests, who supervises, how people vote and how votes are counted. Different counting rules can produce different winners.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of the following is considered the closest example of direct democracy in India today?
- The Lok Sabha
- The gram sabha
- The Rajya Sabha
- The Council of Ministers
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says many consider local governments, especially gram sabhas, the closest examples of direct democracy, because villagers take decisions themselves.
-
2. Why does rule by the people usually mean rule by people's representatives?
- Because citizens do not want to take part in politics
- Because direct democracy cannot work when decisions involve lakhs and crores of people
- Because the Constitution bans direct democracy
- Because only educated people can make laws
Show answer
Answer: B. Direct participation in every decision is impossible on the scale of lakhs and crores of people, so citizens elect representatives who govern on their behalf.
-
3. Which of the following basic questions about elections is concerned with fair representation rather than with free and fair elections?
- Who is eligible to vote?
- Who is to supervise elections?
- How are votes counted and representatives elected?
- Who is eligible to contest?
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter groups 'how voters choose' and 'how votes are counted and representatives elected' as questions of fair representation; the first three questions concern free and fair elections.
-
4. Assertion (A): Holding elections does not by itself make a country democratic. Reason (R): Many non-democratic rulers hold elections in a way that does not threaten their rule.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: since non-democratic rulers also hold elections designed to keep them in power, elections alone cannot prove a country is democratic.
-
5. Why are the basic decisions about elections written into the constitution instead of being left to the government of the day?
- Because constitutions are easier to read than laws
- Because the courts write all election rules
- Because elections are held only once in a generation
- Because the rules and the umpire must be agreed before the contest and cannot be left to any one government
Show answer
Answer: D. Like the rules and the umpire of a game, election rules must be settled before the contest starts; a government in power could otherwise bend them to its own advantage.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.