• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

First Past the Post and Proportional Representation

Explain how the First Past the Post system works and why it can give a party far more seats than votes, describe the Proportional Representation system and its two variants, and compare the two systems.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the three features of the FPTP system and why a winner need not have a majority.
  • Describe the PR system as used in Israel and its two variants.
  • Compare FPTP and PR on constituency size, what the voter votes for and the link between votes and seats.

The choice of electoral system can transform the result of an election. The chapter's dramatic example comes from India's own history.

A historic example: the 1984 Lok Sabha election

In the Lok Sabha election of 1984, the Congress party won 415 of the 543 seats, more than 80 per cent, a victory the textbook says no party had ever achieved in the Lok Sabha. Does that mean four out of five voters voted for it? No. According to the table in the textbook, it received about 48 per cent of the votes. Another party in the same table got 7.4 per cent of the votes but less than one per cent of the seats. How can less than half the votes produce more than four-fifths of the seats? The answer lies in the method of election.

First Past the Post (FPTP)

Under India's system for the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies:

  1. The country is divided into constituencies (543 for the Lok Sabha, according to the textbook).
  2. Each constituency elects one representative.
  3. The candidate who secures the highest number of votes in that constituency is declared elected.

The winner only needs more votes than every other candidate, not a majority. Like a runner who crosses the winning post first, the candidate ahead of the others wins. So it is called the First Past the Post system, or the plurality system. This is the method prescribed by the Constitution for these elections.

When there are several candidates, the winner often gets much less than 50 per cent of the votes. The votes cast for all the losing candidates are 'wasted' in the sense that they win those parties no seats. In an extreme case, a party that gets only 25 per cent in every constituency, while every rival gets less, could win every seat. In 1984, the winning party won many constituencies with less than 50 per cent of the votes, so its share of seats far exceeded its share of votes.

Proportional Representation (PR)

Israel follows a very different system. After the votes are counted, each party gets a share of seats in parliament in proportion to its share of votes, and fills its quota from a preference list of nominees declared before the election. Voters vote for a party, not a candidate. According to the textbook, elections to Israel's legislature, the Knesset, take place every four years, and a party needs a minimum vote share (3.25 per cent, according to the textbook) to get any seats. Because even small parties win seats, PR often leads to multi-party coalition governments.

PR has two variations. In countries like Israel and the Netherlands, the whole country is treated as one constituency, and seats are allocated according to national vote shares. In others, like Argentina and Portugal, the country is divided into multi-member constituencies; each party lists candidates for each constituency, and seats there are shared by party votes, so representatives from one constituency can belong to different parties. In both variants voters choose a party, not a candidate. India uses a third, complex variation of PR on a limited scale for indirect elections: the President, Vice President, Rajya Sabha and Vidhan Parishads.

Comparison of FPTP and PR
FeatureFirst Past the PostProportional Representation
ConstituenciesCountry divided into small geographical unitsLarge areas are constituencies; the whole country may be one
Representatives per constituencyOneMore than one may be elected
Voter votes forA candidateA party
Votes and seatsA party may get more seats than its vote shareEach party gets seats in proportion to its votes
Winning candidateMay not have a majority (50 per cent + 1) of votesElected through the party's share of votes
Examples in the chapterUnited Kingdom, IndiaIsrael, Netherlands

How a seat is won under FPTP

  1. Single-member constituency One seat to fill.
  2. Voters choose a candidate Each voter marks one candidate.
  3. Count the votes Each candidate's total is counted.
  4. Highest total wins No majority needed; votes for losers win no seat.

FPTP: one seat per constituency; the candidate with the most votes wins, even without a majority, so seat shares can differ widely from vote shares. PR: voters choose parties, and each party gets seats in proportion to its votes.

Worked example 1: winning with a minority of votes

In a made-up constituency, 1,00,000 valid votes are cast: candidate P gets 36,000, Q gets 31,000, R gets 21,000 and S gets 12,000. Working: check the total: 36,000 + 31,000 + 21,000 + 12,000 = 1,00,000. P has the most votes and wins under FPTP. P's share = 36,000 ÷ 1,00,000 = 36 per cent. Votes for the losers = 1,00,000 − 36,000 = 64,000, that is 64 per cent of votes that elect nobody.

Worked example 2: the same votes under PR

A made-up country has a 200-seat legislature and uses national PR. Party A wins 40 per cent of votes, B 30 per cent, C 20 per cent and D 10 per cent. Working: A gets 40 per cent of 200 = 80 seats; B gets 30 per cent of 200 = 60; C gets 20 per cent of 200 = 40; D gets 10 per cent of 200 = 20. Total = 80 + 60 + 40 + 20 = 200. No party has a majority (101 seats), so a coalition is needed. Under FPTP with the same national votes, A might have won far more than 80 seats if it led in most constituencies.

Worked example 3: who is my representative?

A voter in a national PR system asks which member represents her town. Reasoning: under national PR there is no single member tied to her locality; members are elected from party lists for the whole country. Under FPTP she would have one identifiable representative for her constituency whom she could hold accountable. This difference matters for the next lesson.

Key takeaways: under FPTP each constituency elects one member, the candidate with the most votes wins without needing a majority, and seat shares can far exceed vote shares, as in 1984 according to the textbook. Under PR, voters choose parties and seats match vote shares, either with the whole country as one constituency (Israel, Netherlands) or with multi-member constituencies (Argentina, Portugal). India uses a variant of PR only for certain indirect elections.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Under the First Past the Post system, who is declared the winner in a constituency?

    1. The candidate who secures more than 50 per cent of the votes
    2. The candidate who has more votes than any other candidate in the constituency
    3. The candidate whose party wins the most votes nationally
    4. The candidate who secures the largest number of postal ballots
    Show answer

    Answer: B. In FPTP the candidate with more votes than every other candidate wins; a majority (more than 50 per cent) is not required, and national party totals do not decide a constituency.

  2. 2. In a made-up constituency, A gets 42 per cent, B 33 per cent and C 25 per cent of the votes. Under FPTP, what share of the votes is cast for candidates who win no seat?

    1. 25 per cent
    2. 33 per cent
    3. 42 per cent
    4. 58 per cent
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A wins with 42 per cent. Votes for the losers are 33 + 25 = 58 per cent, which win no seat.

  3. 3. In which system does the voter vote for a party rather than for a candidate?

    1. Proportional Representation
    2. First Past the Post
    3. Plurality system
    4. Both FPTP and plurality
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Under PR, as in Israel, voters vote for a party, and each party fills its seats from a list declared before the election. FPTP, also called the plurality system, is a vote for a candidate.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Under FPTP, a party may win a much larger share of seats than its share of votes. Reason (R): Under FPTP, the winning candidate in a constituency need not secure a majority of votes, and votes for losing candidates win no seats.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because many winners get under 50 per cent and votes for losers are 'wasted', a party leading in many constituencies can win far more seats than its vote share.

  5. 5. Which pair correctly matches a PR variant to examples given in the chapter?

    1. Whole country as one constituency: Argentina and Portugal
    2. Multi-member constituencies: Israel and the Netherlands
    3. Whole country as one constituency: Israel and the Netherlands
    4. Single-member constituencies: Israel
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says Israel and the Netherlands treat the whole country as one constituency, while Argentina and Portugal use multi-member constituencies.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery