• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Reserved constituencies, universal adult franchise and the right to contest

Distinguish separate electorates from reserved constituencies, explain how the Delimitation Commission decides reserved seats, and describe universal adult franchise and the conditions for contesting elections.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why FPTP can leave smaller social groups unrepresented and how reserved constituencies help.
  • Distinguish reserved constituencies from separate electorates and describe the Delimitation Commission's method.
  • State the voting age change of 1989, the minimum age for contesting, and why the right to contest is open to all.

FPTP rewards whoever wins the most votes in each constituency. In a society with a history of caste-based discrimination, that can mean dominant groups win everywhere while oppressed groups stay unrepresented. The framers were aware of this and searched for a way to give fair and just representation to such groups.

Separate electorates versus reserved constituencies

Before independence, the British government introduced separate electorates: to elect a representative of a particular community, only voters of that community could vote. Many members of the Constituent Assembly feared this would not suit India's purposes. The chapter quotes Tajamul Husain, who argued in the Assembly that separate electorates had done great harm and that his community wished to merge with the nation, and Jaipal Singh, who spoke for the Adivasis, asking for reserved seats in legislatures, not separate electorates, so that Adivasis could join the mainstream instead of being kept apart. The Assembly adopted reserved constituencies: all voters in the constituency may vote, but candidates must belong to the community or section for which the seat is reserved.

Separate electorates and reserved constituencies

  • Separate electorates (rejected)
    • Introduced under British rule
    • Only voters of a community elect its representative
    • Divides voters by community
  • Reserved constituencies (adopted)
    • All voters of the constituency vote
    • Only candidates of the reserved group may contest
    • Representatives must appeal to all voters

Reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes

Some groups are spread across the country; in any one constituency they are too few to decide the result, but nationally they are sizeable. The Constitution therefore reserves seats in the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, in proportion to their share in the population. The provision was made initially for ten years and has been extended by successive amendments (up to 2030, according to the textbook); Parliament can decide to extend it again. The textbook gives the number of reserved Lok Sabha seats as on 26 January 2019 as 84 for Scheduled Castes and 47 for Scheduled Tribes.

Who decides which constituencies are reserved?

An independent body, the Delimitation Commission, appointed by the President and working with the Election Commission, draws constituency boundaries across the country. A quota of reserved constituencies is fixed for each State according to the proportion of SC or ST population there. After drawing boundaries, the Commission looks at each constituency's population:

  • For Scheduled Tribes: constituencies with the highest proportion of ST population are reserved.
  • For Scheduled Castes: it picks constituencies with a higher proportion of SC population but also spreads them across different regions of the State, because the SC population is generally spread fairly evenly.
  • Reserved constituencies can be rotated each time delimitation is carried out.

The Constitution makes no similar reservation for other disadvantaged groups. Because very few women were elected, there was a long demand for reserving one-third of seats for women. Reservation for women already exists in rural and urban local bodies; according to the textbook, a similar provision for the Lok Sabha and Vidhan Sabhas has been made through the Women's Reservation Act, 2023.

Universal adult franchise

The true test of an election system is its ability to ensure a free and fair process. The Constitution answers two basic questions in line with democratic practice: who can vote and who can contest. Democratic elections require that all adult citizens can vote: universal adult franchise. In many countries citizens, and especially women, won this right only late and after struggle; one of the framers' important decisions was to guarantee it to every adult Indian. Until 1989, an adult meant a citizen above 21; an amendment in 1989 reduced the voting age to 18. Many people thought, and some still think, that the vote should depend on education, but the framers firmly believed in the ability and worth of all adult citizens as equals. Universal franchise is consistent with the principles of equality and non-discrimination.

Right to contest

All citizens have the right to stand for election, subject to some conditions. To contest a Lok Sabha or Assembly election, a candidate must be at least 25 years old. There is also a legal provision disqualifying a person who has been imprisoned for two or more years for an offence. But there are no restrictions of income, education, class or gender on contesting, so the system is open to all citizens.

Voting and contesting
QuestionAnswer in the chapter
Who can vote?Every adult citizen; voting age reduced from 21 to 18 by an amendment in 1989
Minimum age to contest Lok Sabha or Assembly25 years
A disqualification mentionedImprisonment for two or more years for an offence
Restrictions not imposedIncome, education, class or gender

Reserved constituencies: everyone votes, but only members of the reserved group may stand. Universal adult franchise: every adult citizen votes (18 since the 1989 amendment). Anyone 25 or older may contest the Lok Sabha or an Assembly, with no test of income, education, class or gender.

Worked example 1: separate or reserved?

In a made-up constituency of 2,00,000 voters, 30,000 belong to a particular community. Under arrangement 1, only those 30,000 vote to elect the community's representative. Under arrangement 2, all 2,00,000 vote, but only members of that community may stand. Answer: arrangement 1 is a separate electorate; arrangement 2 is a reserved constituency. Under arrangement 2 a candidate must win support from all communities, which the framers believed would unite rather than divide voters.

Worked example 2: picking reserved seats

A made-up State gets one ST and two SC reserved seats out of six constituencies. ST share: C1 5%, C2 40%, C3 2%, C4 8%, C5 1%, C6 3%. SC share: C1 22% (north), C2 15% (north), C3 24% (north), C4 19% (south), C5 18% (south), C6 12% (south). Working: the ST seat goes to the constituency with the highest ST share: C2 (40%). For SC seats the Commission prefers high SC shares but spreads them across regions: the highest in the north is C3 (24%) and in the south C4 (19%), so C3 and C4 are reserved, not C1 and C3, which would both be in the north.

Worked example 3: can she contest?

A made-up citizen is 23, a graduate and wealthy. Another is 30, has no formal schooling and is poor. Reasoning: the first cannot yet contest a Lok Sabha or Assembly election because the minimum age is 25. The second can contest, since there is no requirement of income or education.

Key takeaways: FPTP can leave dispersed or oppressed groups unrepresented, so the Constitution reserves Lok Sabha and Assembly seats for SC and ST through reserved constituencies, where all voters vote but only members of the group contest; separate electorates were rejected. The Delimitation Commission chooses reserved seats. Every adult citizen can vote (age 18 since 1989), and anyone aged at least 25 can contest a Lok Sabha or Assembly election without any test of income, education, class or gender.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is the main difference between a reserved constituency and a separate electorate?

    1. In a reserved constituency only members of a community vote; in a separate electorate everyone votes
    2. In a reserved constituency all voters vote but only candidates of the reserved group contest; in a separate electorate only voters of the community vote
    3. There is no difference
    4. Separate electorates were adopted by the Constitution
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Under separate electorates, only voters of a community elect its representative; under reserved constituencies, all voters vote, but the candidates must belong to the group for which the seat is reserved. The Constituent Assembly rejected separate electorates.

  2. 2. Which body decides which constituencies are reserved for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes?

    1. The Delimitation Commission
    2. The Supreme Court
    3. The Rajya Sabha
    4. The National Human Rights Commission
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Delimitation Commission, appointed by the President and working with the Election Commission, draws constituency boundaries and decides which constituencies are reserved.

  3. 3. Why does the Delimitation Commission spread Scheduled Caste reserved constituencies across different regions of a State?

    1. Because Scheduled Castes live only in cities
    2. Because the Constitution forbids reservation in rural areas
    3. Because the Scheduled Caste population is generally spread evenly throughout the country
    4. Because Scheduled Tribe seats must be in the same region
    Show answer

    Answer: C. For SC seats the Commission chooses constituencies with higher SC proportions but spreads them across regions, because the SC population is generally spread fairly evenly.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Until 1989, the voting age in India was 21 years. Reason (R): A constitutional amendment in 1989 reduced the voting age to 18 years.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: 21 was the voting age only until 1989 because the amendment that year lowered it to 18.

  5. 5. Which of the following is a restriction on the right to contest elections mentioned in the chapter?

    1. A minimum educational qualification
    2. A minimum level of income
    3. Being a man
    4. A minimum age of 25 years for the Lok Sabha or an Assembly
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter mentions a minimum age of 25 for Lok Sabha and Assembly elections and disqualification after imprisonment of two or more years, but no restriction of income, education, class or gender.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery