• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Election Commission and electoral reforms

Explain Article 324 and the composition, tenure, removal and functions of the Election Commission of India, its control over officials during elections, the main proposals for electoral reform and the chapter's assessment of India's election system.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the constitutional basis, composition and security of tenure of the Election Commission.
  • List the functions of the Election Commission and explain its control over the administration during elections.
  • Discuss the electoral reforms proposed in the chapter and its five indicators of success.

Rules alone cannot ensure free and fair elections; an impartial umpire is needed. The most important step India took was to create an independent Election Commission to supervise and conduct elections. Many countries lack any independent mechanism of this kind.

Article 324

Article 324 provides for an independent Election Commission for the 'superintendence, direction and control' of the electoral rolls and the conduct of elections to Parliament, the State Legislatures, and the offices of President and Vice President. These words give the Commission a decisive role in virtually everything to do with these elections, and the Supreme Court has agreed with this reading. A Chief Electoral Officer in every State assists the Commission. The Commission is not responsible for local body elections: State Election Commissions conduct those, independently, in their own sphere.

Single-member or multi-member?

The Commission can be single-member or multi-member. Until 1989 it had one member. Just before the 1989 general elections two Election Commissioners were appointed, but the Commission reverted to a single member soon after. In 1993 two Election Commissioners were again appointed and it has remained multi-member since. At first there were sharp differences between the Chief Election Commissioner and the other Commissioners over their powers, settled by the Supreme Court. Now there is general agreement that a multi-member body is better because power is shared and there is greater accountability. The Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) presides but has no more powers than the other Commissioners; they take decisions together as a collective body.

Appointment, tenure and removal

According to the textbook, the CEC and Election Commissioners are appointed by the President on the advice of the Council of Ministers. The textbook notes the fear that a ruling party could appoint a partisan person, and that many suggested making consultation with the Leader of the Opposition and the Chief Justice of India necessary. The textbook describes their tenure as six years or until the age of 65, whichever is earlier. The CEC can be removed before the end of the term by the President only if both Houses of Parliament recommend it with a special majority, so that a ruling party cannot remove a CEC who refuses to favour it. Election Commissioners can be removed by the President.

A special majority means two conditions at once: (i) a two-thirds majority of those present and voting, and (ii) a simple majority of the total membership of the House.

Functions of the Election Commission

  • Supervises the preparation of an up-to-date voters' list, free of errors such as missing names of registered voters or names of ineligible or non-existent persons.
  • Determines the timing of elections and prepares the election schedule: notification, dates for filing nominations, scrutiny, withdrawal, polling, counting and results.
  • Takes decisions to ensure a free and fair poll: it can postpone or cancel an election in the whole country, a State or a constituency if the atmosphere is vitiated; implements the model code of conduct for parties and candidates; orders re-polls; orders recounts if counting was not fair.
  • Grants recognition to political parties and allots symbols.

The Commission has little staff of its own and conducts elections through the government's administrative machinery. But once the election process begins, it has full control over officers on election duty: it can transfer them, stop their transfers and act against them for failing to be non-partisan. The chapter observes that the Commission has become more independent and assertive over time, not because its powers increased, but because it began to use more effectively the powers it always had. Every improvement in institutions does not need legal or constitutional change.

The Election Commission of India

  • Basis
    • Article 324
    • Superintendence, direction and control
  • Composition
    • CEC and Election Commissioners
    • Multi-member since 1993
    • CEC presides; equal powers
  • Security of tenure
    • Fixed term
    • CEC removed only on special-majority recommendation of both Houses
  • Functions
    • Voters' list
    • Election schedule
    • Free and fair poll: postpone, re-poll, recount, code of conduct
    • Recognise parties, allot symbols

Electoral reforms

No election system is perfect. The Election Commission, parties, independent groups and scholars have proposed reforms, including:

  1. Change from FPTP to some variant of PR so that seats match votes as far as possible.
  2. Special provision to ensure that at least one-third of those elected to Parliament and Assemblies are women.
  3. Stricter control of money in elections, with election expenses paid by the government from a special fund.
  4. Barring candidates with any criminal case from contesting, even if their appeal is pending.
  5. A complete ban on caste and religious appeals in campaigns.
  6. A law to regulate political parties so that they work transparently and democratically.

There is no consensus on these suggestions, and even with consensus, laws can do only so much. Free and fair elections need candidates, parties and officials to respect the spirit of democratic competition, citizens to be vigilant and active, and political institutions and voluntary organisations to act as watchdogs.

How successful has India's election system been?

The chapter's conclusion lists five indicators: voters have chosen representatives freely and changed governments peacefully at State and national level; voters have taken keen interest and the number of candidates and parties has risen; the system has been accommodative and inclusive, with representatives from many social sections, though the number of women legislators has not increased satisfactorily; malpractices and rigging, though attempted, rarely affect outcomes; and elections have become part of democratic life, so no one can imagine a government formed without elections or ignoring their verdict.

Article 324 vests the superintendence, direction and control of elections in an independent Election Commission; its multi-member body decides collectively, the CEC can be removed only through a special-majority recommendation of both Houses, and during elections it controls the officials on election duty.

Worked example 1: is it a special majority?

A made-up House has a total membership of 60. On voting day, 45 members are present and vote, and 31 vote in favour. Working: condition (i): two-thirds of 45 present and voting = 30, and 31 is at least 30, so it is met. Condition (ii): a simple majority of the total membership of 60 means more than 30, that is at least 31; 31 meets it. Both are satisfied, so the motion passes by special majority. If only 30 had voted in favour, condition (i) would hold but condition (ii) would fail.

Worked example 2: which power is being used?

Name the power in each made-up case. (a) Violence makes polling in a constituency impossible, and the Commission defers the election there. (b) Ballot boxes in one booth are found tampered with, and polling is held again there. (c) A district officer on election duty openly campaigns for a candidate and is moved. Answers: (a) power to postpone an election where the atmosphere is vitiated; (b) power to order a re-poll; (c) control over officers on election duty, including transfer and disciplinary action.

Worked example 3: who conducts this election?

Which body conducts (a) an election to a municipal corporation, (b) a Rajya Sabha election, (c) the election of the Vice President? Answers: (a) the State Election Commission, because local bodies are outside the Election Commission of India's role; (b) and (c) the Election Commission of India under Article 324.

Key takeaways: Article 324 gives the Election Commission superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures, President and Vice President, but not local bodies. It has been multi-member since 1993, with the CEC presiding but holding equal powers. The CEC enjoys security of tenure through removal only by special majority. The Commission prepares rolls, schedules elections, ensures free and fair polls and recognises parties, and controls officials during elections. Reforms are debated, but their success depends on the spirit of democratic competition and vigilant citizens.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which Article of the Constitution provides for the Election Commission?

    1. Article 21
    2. Article 324
    3. Article 32
    4. Article 16
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 324 vests the superintendence, direction and control of electoral rolls and elections in the Election Commission. Article 21 is life and liberty, Article 32 constitutional remedies, Article 16 equality in public employment.

  2. 2. Which of the following is NOT a function of the Election Commission of India?

    1. Preparing the electoral rolls
    2. Implementing the model code of conduct
    3. Supervising panchayat and municipal elections
    4. Allotting symbols to political parties
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Local body elections are conducted by State Election Commissions, which work independently of the Election Commission of India. The other tasks are among the ECI's functions.

  3. 3. According to the chapter, why is the Election Commission more independent and assertive now than in its early decades?

    1. Its constitutional powers were greatly increased by amendments
    2. It became part of the judiciary
    3. It now has a very large staff of its own
    4. It started using more effectively the powers it always had
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter stresses that the change is not because its powers or protection increased, but because it began to use its existing constitutional powers more effectively.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): The Chief Election Commissioner cannot be removed by the ruling party simply because he or she refuses to favour it. Reason (R): The CEC can be removed by the President only if both Houses of Parliament recommend it by a special majority.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the special-majority requirement in both Houses protects the CEC from removal by a simple ruling majority.

  5. 5. A made-up House has 90 members in total. 63 are present and voting, and 46 vote for a motion. Is it passed by special majority?

    1. Yes, both conditions are met
    2. No, it fails the two-thirds condition
    3. No, it fails the total-membership condition
    4. No, because a special majority needs every member present
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Condition (i): two-thirds of 63 present and voting = 42, and 46 is more than 42. Condition (ii): a simple majority of the total membership of 90 means at least 46 (more than half of 90), and 46 meets it. Both conditions are met, so the motion passes.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery