- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
The single transferable vote and why India chose FPTP
Calculate the winning quota in a Rajya Sabha election by the single transferable vote, and explain the reasons for India's choice of the FPTP system and how its working has affected the party system.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Apply the quota formula of the single transferable vote and describe how preferences are transferred.
- Give the four reasons the chapter offers for India adopting FPTP.
- Describe how the experience of FPTP in India differs from the usual two-party outcome.
India uses PR only for some indirect elections, through a method called the single transferable vote. Understanding it shows why the framers thought PR too complicated for general elections in a country as large as India.
PR in Rajya Sabha elections: the single transferable vote
Every State has a specific quota of seats in the Rajya Sabha. Its members are elected by the State Legislative Assembly: the voters are the MLAs of that State. Each voter ranks the candidates in order of preference. To win, a candidate needs a minimum quota of votes, given by the formula:
Quota = (total votes polled ÷ (number of candidates to be elected + 1)) + 1
Counting begins with first-preference votes. If, after counting all first preferences, not enough candidates reach the quota, the candidate with the fewest first-preference votes is eliminated, and his or her votes are transferred to the candidates marked as second preference on those ballots. The process continues until the required number of candidates are elected. The chapter's example: if 4 members are to be elected by 200 MLAs, the quota is 200 ÷ (4 + 1) + 1 = 40 + 1 = 41 votes.
Counting by single transferable vote
- Count first preferences Each ballot counts for its first-ranked candidate.
- Declare those who reach the quota Candidates with at least the quota are elected.
- Eliminate the lowest If seats remain, the candidate with the fewest votes drops out.
- Transfer votes Those ballots move to their next preferences; count again.
Then back to step 1: Count first preferences
Why did India adopt FPTP?
The chapter gives four reasons:
- Simplicity. STV is complicated; it may work in a small country but would be difficult in a sub-continental country like India. FPTP is easy to understand even for voters with no specialised knowledge of politics.
- Clear choice and accountability. Voters simply endorse a candidate or party, and they choose between specific candidates, not just party lists. Under list-based PR no single representative is responsible for one locality; under FPTP voters know who their own representative is and can hold him or her accountable.
- Stable government. The parliamentary system requires the executive to have a majority in the legislature. PR may not produce a clear majority. FPTP generally gives the largest party or coalition some bonus seats, more than its vote share, which helps form a stable government.
- Bringing social groups together. FPTP encourages voters from different social groups to come together to win in a locality. In a diverse country, PR might encourage each community to form its own nation-wide party.
How FPTP has worked in India
The chapter says experience has confirmed the framers' expectations: FPTP has been simple and familiar to voters, has helped larger parties win clear majorities at the centre and in States, and has discouraged parties that draw votes from only one caste or community. Normally FPTP produces a two-party system, in which two major competitors alternate in power and new or third parties find it hard to break in. India's experience is slightly different. After independence, FPTP coexisted with one-party dominance alongside many smaller parties. After 1989, India saw multi-party coalitions, while in many States a two-party competition gradually emerged. The distinctive feature, the chapter says, is that the rise of coalitions has let new and smaller parties enter electoral competition despite FPTP.
| Reason | How FPTP achieves it | Why PR would struggle |
|---|---|---|
| Simplicity | Mark one candidate; most votes wins | Ranking and transfers are complex on a huge scale |
| Accountability | One known representative per constituency | List members may not belong to any locality |
| Stable government | Bonus seats for the largest party or coalition | Seats split by vote share may give no majority |
| Social cohesion | Groups must combine to win a locality | Each community could form its own party |
Worked example 1: computing the quota
In a made-up State, 180 MLAs vote to elect 3 Rajya Sabha members. Working: quota = 180 ÷ (3 + 1) + 1 = 45 + 1 = 46 votes. Check: at most three candidates can each reach 46, because 3 × 46 = 138, which is within 180, but four candidates would need 4 × 46 = 184, more than 180. So the quota guarantees that no more than the required number can be elected.
Worked example 2: a transfer
Continue the made-up election with 180 votes and quota 46. First preferences: W 50, X 47, Y 40, Z 43. Working: total = 50 + 47 + 40 + 43 = 180. W (50) and X (47) reach 46 and are elected. One seat remains; Y has the fewest first preferences (40) and is eliminated. Suppose 30 of Y's ballots list Z as next preference and the other 10 list W or X, who are already elected. Z now has 43 + 30 = 73 votes, above 46, so Z wins the third seat. (A full count would also transfer the surplus votes of W and X; the example keeps the steps simple.)
Worked example 3: which system suits the wish?
A conference drafting a made-up constitution lists wishes. (a) 'People should know exactly who represents them.' (b) 'Small linguistic minorities spread across the country must get fair representation.' (c) 'There should be no gap between votes and seats.' (d) 'People should be able to elect a good candidate even if they dislike the party.' Answers: (a) FPTP; (b) PR; (c) PR; (d) FPTP.
Key takeaways: Rajya Sabha members are elected by MLAs through the single transferable vote, with quota = votes ÷ (seats + 1) + 1 and transfer of preferences from eliminated candidates. India chose FPTP for its simplicity, clear choice and accountability, its tendency to produce stable majorities, and its push for social groups to combine. In India, FPTP coexisted with one-party dominance and later coalitions that let smaller parties enter competition.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who are the voters in the election of Rajya Sabha members from a State?
- All adult citizens of the State
- The members of the Lok Sabha from that State
- The members of the State Legislative Assembly (MLAs)
- The members of the panchayats
Show answer
Answer: C. Rajya Sabha members are elected by the State Legislative Assembly; the voters are the MLAs of that State, who rank candidates by preference.
-
2. If 5 Rajya Sabha members are to be elected by 240 MLAs, what is the quota needed to win?
- 40
- 41
- 48
- 49
Show answer
Answer: B. Quota = 240 ÷ (5 + 1) + 1 = 40 + 1 = 41 votes.
-
3. Which of the following is NOT a reason given in the chapter for India adopting FPTP?
- It is simple for ordinary voters to understand
- It helps produce a stable government in a parliamentary system
- Voters know their own representative and can hold him or her accountable
- It guarantees that every party gets seats exactly equal to its vote share
Show answer
Answer: D. Matching seats to vote shares is the feature of PR, not FPTP. The chapter's reasons for FPTP are simplicity, clear choice and accountability, stable government and encouraging social groups to combine.
-
4. Assertion (A): The framers felt that PR might not be suitable for giving a stable government in a parliamentary system. Reason (R): A parliamentary system requires the executive to have a majority in the legislature, and PR may not produce a clear majority.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because PR divides seats by vote share, it may produce no clear majority, which a parliamentary executive needs.
-
5. According to the chapter, what is the distinguishing feature of India's party system under FPTP?
- A strict two-party system from 1952 onwards
- The rise of coalitions has allowed new and smaller parties to enter electoral competition despite FPTP
- Only one party has ever won elections
- FPTP has eliminated all regional parties
Show answer
Answer: B. FPTP normally produces two-party systems, but in India coalitions since 1989 have enabled new and smaller parties to compete, which the chapter calls the distinguishing feature.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.