Revision notes

Chapter 3 Election and Representation: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Elections and democracy: why the rules of elections are in the Constitution

Direct and indirect democracy

  • Direct democracy
    • Citizens decide day-to-day matters themselves
    • Ancient Greek city-states
    • Gram sabha is the closest example today
    • Impractical for crores of people
  • Indirect democracy
    • Citizens elect representatives
    • Representatives govern and make policy
    • Citizens' role in decisions is limited and indirect
    • Method of election becomes crucial
Five questions answered by the Indian Constitution, like most democratic constitutions
Basic questionWhat it is about
Who is eligible to vote?Free and fair elections
Who is eligible to contest?Free and fair elections
Who is to supervise elections?Free and fair elections
How do voters choose their representatives?Fair representation
How are votes counted and representatives elected?Fair representation

Representative democracy depends on elections, but elections are democratic only if the rules on who votes, who contests, who supervises, how people vote and how votes are counted are fair, which is why a democratic constitution fixes them in advance.

Key takeaways: direct democracy, as in Greek city-states or the gram sabha, is not possible for crores of people, so democracy usually means representative democracy, in which elections matter greatly. Non-democratic rulers also hold elections, so a democratic constitution lays down basic rules on who votes, who contests, who supervises, how people vote and how votes are counted. Different counting rules can produce different winners.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

First Past the Post and Proportional Representation

Comparison of FPTP and PR
FeatureFirst Past the PostProportional Representation
ConstituenciesCountry divided into small geographical unitsLarge areas are constituencies; the whole country may be one
Representatives per constituencyOneMore than one may be elected
Voter votes forA candidateA party
Votes and seatsA party may get more seats than its vote shareEach party gets seats in proportion to its votes
Winning candidateMay not have a majority (50 per cent + 1) of votesElected through the party's share of votes
Examples in the chapterUnited Kingdom, IndiaIsrael, Netherlands

How a seat is won under FPTP

  1. Single-member constituency One seat to fill.
  2. Voters choose a candidate Each voter marks one candidate.
  3. Count the votes Each candidate's total is counted.
  4. Highest total wins No majority needed; votes for losers win no seat.

FPTP: one seat per constituency; the candidate with the most votes wins, even without a majority, so seat shares can differ widely from vote shares. PR: voters choose parties, and each party gets seats in proportion to its votes.

Key takeaways: under FPTP each constituency elects one member, the candidate with the most votes wins without needing a majority, and seat shares can far exceed vote shares, as in 1984 according to the textbook. Under PR, voters choose parties and seats match vote shares, either with the whole country as one constituency (Israel, Netherlands) or with multi-member constituencies (Argentina, Portugal). India uses a variant of PR only for certain indirect elections.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

The single transferable vote and why India chose FPTP

Quota = (total votes polled ÷ (number of candidates to be elected + 1)) + 1

Counting by single transferable vote

  1. Count first preferences Each ballot counts for its first-ranked candidate.
  2. Declare those who reach the quota Candidates with at least the quota are elected.
  3. Eliminate the lowest If seats remain, the candidate with the fewest votes drops out.
  4. Transfer votes Those ballots move to their next preferences; count again.

Then back to step 1: Count first preferences

Why the framers chose FPTP for the Lok Sabha and Assemblies
ReasonHow FPTP achieves itWhy PR would struggle
SimplicityMark one candidate; most votes winsRanking and transfers are complex on a huge scale
AccountabilityOne known representative per constituencyList members may not belong to any locality
Stable governmentBonus seats for the largest party or coalitionSeats split by vote share may give no majority
Social cohesionGroups must combine to win a localityEach community could form its own party

Key takeaways: Rajya Sabha members are elected by MLAs through the single transferable vote, with quota = votes ÷ (seats + 1) + 1 and transfer of preferences from eliminated candidates. India chose FPTP for its simplicity, clear choice and accountability, its tendency to produce stable majorities, and its push for social groups to combine. In India, FPTP coexisted with one-party dominance and later coalitions that let smaller parties enter competition.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Reserved constituencies, universal adult franchise and the right to contest

Separate electorates and reserved constituencies

  • Separate electorates (rejected)
    • Introduced under British rule
    • Only voters of a community elect its representative
    • Divides voters by community
  • Reserved constituencies (adopted)
    • All voters of the constituency vote
    • Only candidates of the reserved group may contest
    • Representatives must appeal to all voters
Voting and contesting
QuestionAnswer in the chapter
Who can vote?Every adult citizen; voting age reduced from 21 to 18 by an amendment in 1989
Minimum age to contest Lok Sabha or Assembly25 years
A disqualification mentionedImprisonment for two or more years for an offence
Restrictions not imposedIncome, education, class or gender

Reserved constituencies: everyone votes, but only members of the reserved group may stand. Universal adult franchise: every adult citizen votes (18 since the 1989 amendment). Anyone 25 or older may contest the Lok Sabha or an Assembly, with no test of income, education, class or gender.

Key takeaways: FPTP can leave dispersed or oppressed groups unrepresented, so the Constitution reserves Lok Sabha and Assembly seats for SC and ST through reserved constituencies, where all voters vote but only members of the group contest; separate electorates were rejected. The Delimitation Commission chooses reserved seats. Every adult citizen can vote (age 18 since 1989), and anyone aged at least 25 can contest a Lok Sabha or Assembly election without any test of income, education, class or gender.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

The Election Commission and electoral reforms

The Election Commission of India

  • Basis
    • Article 324
    • Superintendence, direction and control
  • Composition
    • CEC and Election Commissioners
    • Multi-member since 1993
    • CEC presides; equal powers
  • Security of tenure
    • Fixed term
    • CEC removed only on special-majority recommendation of both Houses
  • Functions
    • Voters' list
    • Election schedule
    • Free and fair poll: postpone, re-poll, recount, code of conduct
    • Recognise parties, allot symbols

Article 324 vests the superintendence, direction and control of elections in an independent Election Commission; its multi-member body decides collectively, the CEC can be removed only through a special-majority recommendation of both Houses, and during elections it controls the officials on election duty.

Key takeaways: Article 324 gives the Election Commission superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures, President and Vice President, but not local bodies. It has been multi-member since 1993, with the CEC presiding but holding equal powers. The CEC enjoys security of tenure through removal only by special majority. The Commission prepares rolls, schedules elections, ensures free and fair polls and recognises parties, and controls officials during elections. Reforms are debated, but their success depends on the spirit of democratic competition and vigilant citizens.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery