Direct and indirect democracy
-
Direct democracy
- Citizens decide day-to-day matters themselves
- Ancient Greek city-states
- Gram sabha is the closest example today
- Impractical for crores of people
-
Indirect democracy
- Citizens elect representatives
- Representatives govern and make policy
- Citizens' role in decisions is limited and indirect
- Method of election becomes crucial
| Basic question | What it is about |
|---|---|
| Who is eligible to vote? | Free and fair elections |
| Who is eligible to contest? | Free and fair elections |
| Who is to supervise elections? | Free and fair elections |
| How do voters choose their representatives? | Fair representation |
| How are votes counted and representatives elected? | Fair representation |
Representative democracy depends on elections, but elections are democratic only if the rules on who votes, who contests, who supervises, how people vote and how votes are counted are fair, which is why a democratic constitution fixes them in advance.
Key takeaways: direct democracy, as in Greek city-states or the gram sabha, is not possible for crores of people, so democracy usually means representative democracy, in which elections matter greatly. Non-democratic rulers also hold elections, so a democratic constitution lays down basic rules on who votes, who contests, who supervises, how people vote and how votes are counted. Different counting rules can produce different winners.