• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Promoting equality: formal equality, differential treatment and affirmative action

Explain the steps to promote equality, from ending formal privileges to differential treatment and affirmative action, set out the arguments for and against reservations as the textbook presents them, and distinguish treating people identically from treating them as equals.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain formal equality and how the Indian Constitution establishes it.
  • Explain why differential treatment can enhance equality, and describe affirmative action and the arguments for and against reservations as the textbook presents them.
  • Distinguish treating everyone identically from treating everyone as equal, with the cautions the textbook adds.

Knowing what equality means, we must ask how to promote it. The textbook moves through three approaches: establishing formal equality, achieving equality through differential treatment, and affirmative action. It notes that the last has been the subject of much debate, and presents the arguments on each side. We follow it closely and take no side ourselves.

Step 1: establishing formal equality

The first step is to end formal systems of inequality and privilege. Around the world, inequalities have been protected by customs and legal systems that barred some sections from certain opportunities and rewards. The textbook's examples: the poor were denied the vote in many countries; women were barred from many professions; the caste system in India confined 'lower' castes to manual labour; in many countries only people from some families could hold high positions. Equality requires that the government and law stop protecting such systems.

This is what the Indian Constitution does. It prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth, and it abolishes untouchability. Most modern constitutions accept equality as identical treatment by law for all citizens regardless of caste, race, religion or gender.

Step 2: equality through differential treatment

Formal equality, or equality before law, is necessary but not sufficient. Sometimes people must be treated differently so that they can enjoy equal rights. The textbook's examples: ramps in public buildings so that disabled people have an equal chance to enter; special protection for women working night shifts at call centres while travelling, so their equal right to work is protected. These are not infringements of equality but enhancements of it.

Step 3: affirmative action

Affirmative action rests on the idea that formal equality by law is not enough to remove deeply rooted inequalities; more positive measures are needed. Most such policies aim to correct the cumulative effect of past inequalities. They take many forms, from preferential spending on facilities for disadvantaged communities (scholarships, hostels) to special consideration in admissions and jobs. India has used a policy of quotas or reserved seats in education and jobs for deprived groups, which the textbook says has been the subject of considerable debate.

The reservations debate, as the textbook presents it

  • Arguments in support
    • Some groups suffered prejudice, exclusion and segregation
    • They cannot be expected at once to compete on equal terms
    • Special help is needed to create an egalitarian, just society
    • Meant to be temporary, until they can compete equally
  • Arguments of critics
    • Treating people differently cannot lead to greater equality
    • Quotas arbitrarily deny others their right to equal treatment
    • A form of reverse discrimination
    • Distinctions by caste or colour may reinforce prejudice; aim to abolish social distinctions

The textbook then draws a distinction between equality as a guiding principle of state policy and the equal rights of individuals. Individuals have a right to equal consideration for admission and public employment, but competition should be fair. A first-generation learner whose parents were not literate faces very different circumstances from someone born into an educated family; members of excluded groups, whether dalits, women or others, need some special help, and the state must devise policies to give them a fair chance.

The textbook observes that in education and health care India has done less for its deprived population than is due: poor children in rural areas or urban slums may have little chance of attending school, schools differ greatly in facilities, and the expense of coaching and fees can keep them out of professional courses. Most theorists, it says, agree on the goal of equal opportunity; what they contest is the policy to reach it: reserved seats, or special facilities to develop talent from an early age? Should the deprived be identified by economic criteria or by social inequalities arising from caste? Ultimately, policies must be justified by their success in making society more egalitarian and fair.

Identical treatment versus treating as equals

The textbook distinguishes treating everyone in an identical manner from treating everyone as equal. The latter may sometimes need differential treatment, but the primary aim must be to promote equality, and such treatment requires justification and careful reflection. Because differential treatment was part of the caste system and of apartheid, liberals are usually wary of departing from identical treatment.

The women's movement illustrates the point. In the nineteenth century women demanded the same rights as men: to vote, to receive university degrees and to work. Entering the job market, they found they needed special facilities such as maternity leave and crèches to exercise those rights. Sometimes they had to be treated differently to enjoy the same rights. The textbook adds a caution: differential treatment must not create new structures of dominance, or become a way for dominant groups to reassert privileges. It is justified only as a means to a just and egalitarian society.

Promoting equality step by step

  1. Formal equality End legal privileges; no discrimination by religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth.
  2. Differential treatment Ramps, safe transport, maternity leave so people enjoy equal rights.
  3. Affirmative action Positive measures to correct the cumulative effect of past inequality.
  4. Test of every policy Does it make society more egalitarian and fair, without new dominance?

Treating people as equals may sometimes require treating them differently, but differential treatment needs justification and is valid only as a means to a more just and equal society.

— Key idea, in our own words

Worked example 1: is special treatment justified?

A made-up school spends money on special equipment for two visually challenged students. Test: does the differential treatment help a set of people enjoy the same right as others (here, the right to learn)? Yes: without the equipment they cannot study on equal terms. Conclusion: like ramps, this enhances equality. Compare a request to build a court for one talented player: this develops an exceptional talent rather than removing a disadvantage, so it would need a different justification.

Worked example 2: matching concepts

Match: (a) affirmative action, (b) equality of opportunity, (c) equal rights, with (i) every adult citizen may vote, (ii) a bank offers senior citizens a higher interest rate, (iii) every child should get free education. Reasoning: voting for all adults is an equal right, so (c)-(i). Free education for every child gives all a fair start, so (b)-(iii). A special benefit for a particular group is a form of preferential treatment, so (a)-(ii). This exercise, from the chapter, checks the difference between the three ideas.

Key takeaways: the first step to equality is ending formal privileges; the Indian Constitution prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth and abolishes untouchability. Formal equality is necessary but not sufficient: differential treatment such as ramps can enhance equality. Affirmative action, including reservations in India, aims to correct past inequality and is debated, with arguments on both sides. Treating people as equals may require differential treatment, which must be justified and must not create new dominance.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the chapter, the Indian Constitution prohibits discrimination on grounds of:

    1. religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth
    2. income and occupation only
    3. age and height
    4. educational qualifications
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter states that the Constitution prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth, and abolishes untouchability.

  2. 2. Special ramps for disabled people in public buildings are described in the chapter as:

    1. an infringement of equality
    2. reverse discrimination
    3. an enhancement of equality through differential treatment
    4. a form of formal inequality
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says such measures should not be seen as infringements of equality but as enhancements, since they let people enjoy an equal right.

  3. 3. Which is an argument made by critics of reservations, as the chapter presents it?

    1. Reservations correct the cumulative effect of past inequality
    2. Deprived groups cannot immediately compete on equal terms
    3. Special help is meant to be temporary
    4. Reservations are a form of reverse discrimination that may reinforce caste prejudice
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says critics contend that reservations arbitrarily deny others equal treatment, are a form of reverse discrimination, and may reinforce caste and racial prejudices. The other options are arguments in support.

  4. 4. Case: Women who won the right to work found they could not compete for jobs without maternity leave and crèches. This, according to the chapter, shows that:

    1. women should not work
    2. sometimes people need to be treated differently in order to enjoy the same rights
    3. formal equality is always sufficient
    4. identical treatment is always fair
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter uses the women's movement to show that women sometimes needed different treatment, such as maternity leave and crèches, to enjoy the same rights as men.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Liberals are usually very wary of deviations from the norm of identical treatment. Reason (R): Differential treatment for different communities was part and parcel of the caste system and practices like apartheid.

    1. A is false, but R is true
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says that since differential treatment was part of the caste system and apartheid, liberals are usually very wary of departing from identical treatment. R explains A.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Equality

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery