• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

What is equality? Opportunities, natural and social inequalities

Explain why equal respect need not mean identical treatment, define equality of opportunities, and evaluate the distinction between natural and socially produced inequalities and the alternative distinction based on choice and circumstance.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why treating people with equal respect does not always mean treating them identically.
  • Define equality of opportunities and say which inequalities make a society unjust.
  • Distinguish natural from socially produced inequalities, explain the problems with this distinction, and state the alternative many theorists now use.

Signs that once separated people by race, such as separate drinking fountains or rest rooms marked for 'white' and 'coloured', strike most of us as plainly wrong. They violate our intuitive sense that all human beings deserve the same respect and consideration because of their common humanity. But does equality then require treating everyone identically? The textbook says no, and this lesson explains why.

Equal respect is not identical treatment

No society treats all its members in exactly the same way under all conditions. Society needs a division of work and functions, and people often have different status and rewards because of it. Some differences seem acceptable: we usually do not feel that giving a prime minister or an army general special rank goes against equality, provided their privileges are not misused. Other inequalities seem unjust: a child born in a slum who is denied nutritious food or good education through no fault of his or her own.

So which distinctions are acceptable? When people are treated differently just because of the religion, race, caste or gender they are born into, we regard it as unacceptable. But people pursue different goals, and not all succeed equally: some become fine musicians or famous scientists, others are known for hard work. As long as each can develop the best in themselves, equality is not undermined. The textbook concludes that equality does not mean eliminating all differences; it means the treatment we receive and the opportunities we enjoy must not be predetermined by birth or social circumstance.

Equality does not require removing all differences between people. It requires that the treatment people receive and the opportunities they enjoy are not decided in advance by birth or social circumstance.

— Key idea, in our own words

Equality of opportunities

Equality implies that all people are entitled to the same rights and opportunities to develop their skills and talents and pursue their goals. People will still differ in choices, talents and success; only some become ace cricketers or successful lawyers, and that alone does not make a society unequal. In the textbook's words, what matters is not the lack of equality of status, wealth or privilege, but inequalities in people's access to basic goods such as education, health care and safe housing. These make a society unequal and unjust.

Natural and socially produced inequalities

A distinction made in political theory

  • Natural inequalities
    • Arise from different capabilities and talents people are born with
    • Generally assumed to be unalterable
  • Socially produced inequalities
    • Arise from unequal opportunity or exploitation of some groups by others
    • Created by society's values, e.g. rewarding intellectual over manual work, or treating people differently by race, colour, gender or caste

This distinction can help separate acceptable from unfair inequalities, but the textbook warns that it is not always clear. Two problems arise:

  1. Social prejudice disguised as nature. Long-standing unequal treatment can come to look 'natural'. Women were for long called 'the weaker sex', thought timid and less intelligent, and this was used to justify denying them equal rights. Colonial masters described black people in Africa as less intelligent and suited to manual work, sports and music, and used this belief to justify institutions like slavery. All these assessments are now questioned and seen as distinctions created by differences of power, not inborn characteristics.
  2. 'Natural' differences can be altered. Advances in medicine and technology help many disabled people function effectively: computers help blind people, wheelchairs and artificial limbs help with physical disability. The textbook mentions the physicist Stephen Hawking, who could hardly move or speak yet made major contributions to science. Most people today would think it unjust to deny disabled people help or fair reward on the ground that they are 'naturally' less capable.

Because of these complexities, the natural/social distinction is hard to use as a standard for judging laws and policies. So many theorists today distinguish instead between inequalities arising from our own choices and inequalities arising from the family or circumstances into which a person is born. It is the latter that advocates of equality wish to minimise and eliminate.

Which inequalities concern advocates of equality?

  • From one's own choices
    • e.g. choosing a less paid career one prefers
    • Generally acceptable
  • From circumstances of birth
    • Family, caste, race, gender, place of birth
    • To be minimised and eliminated

Worked example 1: acceptable or unacceptable difference?

Judge each case: (a) a made-up hospital gives its chief surgeon a larger office; (b) a made-up club refuses membership to people of one caste. Reasoning: (a) follows from a division of functions and is acceptable if the privilege is not misused. (b) treats people differently because of the caste they were born into, which the textbook calls an unacceptable form of inequality. Answer: (a) acceptable, (b) unacceptable.

Worked example 2: choice or circumstance?

Two made-up adults earn very different incomes. Asha chose to work part-time to pursue painting. Ravi could not finish school because his family needed him to work as a child. Reasoning: Asha's lower income arises from her own choice. Ravi's arises from the circumstances of his birth. On the choice/circumstance distinction, it is Ravi's situation that advocates of equality would seek to remedy, for example through education opportunities for adults.

Key takeaways: equal respect does not mean identical treatment; some differences from division of work are acceptable, but treatment fixed by birth is not. Equality of opportunities means equal rights and access to basic goods like education, health care and housing. The natural/social distinction is useful but unclear, because prejudice can pose as nature and 'natural' differences can be altered. Many theorists now separate inequalities of choice from those of circumstance, and target the latter.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the chapter, the commitment to equality implies that:

    1. all forms of difference must be eliminated
    2. everyone must earn the same
    3. the treatment we receive and our opportunities must not be predetermined by birth or social circumstance
    4. no one may hold an official rank
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says the ideal of equality does not mean eliminating all differences; it means treatment and opportunities must not be predetermined by birth or social circumstance.

  2. 2. Which inequalities, according to the chapter, make for an unequal and unjust society?

    1. Inequalities in access to basic goods such as education, health care and safe housing
    2. Differences in success between cricketers
    3. Differences in musical talent
    4. Special rank given to army generals
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says it is not differences of status or wealth that matter most but inequalities in access to basic goods like education, health care and safe housing.

  3. 3. Natural inequalities, as the chapter defines them, are those that:

    1. are created by society's values
    2. result from exploitation of some groups
    3. result from caste rules
    4. emerge from people's different capabilities and talents
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says natural inequalities emerge as a result of people's different capabilities and talents, while socially produced ones come from unequal opportunity or exploitation.

  4. 4. Case: For centuries a group was described as 'naturally' suited only to manual work, and this was used to deny it education. Today this view is questioned. According to the chapter, such distinctions are better understood as:

    1. truly natural inequalities
    2. distinctions made by society as a result of differences of power
    3. inequalities arising from free choice
    4. differences that technology cannot change
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says assessments such as women being the weaker sex or colonised people being less intelligent are now seen as distinctions made by society because of differences of power, not inborn characteristics.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Many theorists today prefer to distinguish between inequalities from choice and those from circumstances of birth. Reason (R): The natural/socially produced distinction is not always clear, since prejudice can appear natural and some natural differences can be altered.

    1. A is true, but R is false
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is false, but R is true
    4. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says that, given these complexities, the natural/social distinction is hard to use as a standard, and for this reason many theorists use the choice/circumstance distinction instead. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery