• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why equality matters: an ideal and a paradox

Explain equality as a moral and political ideal based on common humanity, trace its use in historical struggles, and describe the paradox that the ideal is widely accepted while inequality is everywhere.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the idea of equal worth and common humanity that lies behind equality as a political ideal.
  • Name the historical struggles in which equality became a rallying slogan.
  • Describe the paradox of equality and list the questions political theory asks about it.

Equality is a value written into the Indian Constitution and into the constitutions of many countries. Chapter 3 of Political Theory asks what equality means, whether it requires treating everyone the same in every situation, how inequality can be reduced, and how its political, social and economic dimensions differ. Along the way it introduces four important ideologies: socialism, Marxism, liberalism and feminism. The textbook adds that its facts and figures are there to show the nature of inequality, not to be memorised.

Equality as a moral and political ideal

Equality, the textbook says, is a powerful moral and political ideal that has guided human society for centuries. It is implicit in faiths that proclaim all human beings to be the creation of God. As a political ideal, it holds that all human beings have equal worth regardless of colour, gender, race or nationality, and so deserve equal consideration and respect because of their common humanity. This notion of a shared humanity lies behind ideas such as universal human rights and crimes against humanity.

Equality, as a political ideal, means that all human beings have equal worth and deserve equal consideration and respect because of their common humanity, whatever their colour, gender, race or nationality.

— Key definition, in our own words

Equality as a rallying slogan

Equality in modern struggles (as the textbook lists them)

  1. 18th century: French Revolution 'Liberty, Equality and Fraternity' raised against the landed feudal aristocracy and the monarchy.
  2. 20th century: anti-colonial struggles Demand for equality raised in liberation struggles in Asia and Africa.
  3. Continuing struggles Raised by groups who feel marginalised, such as women and dalits.
  4. Today A widely accepted ideal embodied in the constitutions and laws of many countries.

In the modern period, the equality of all human beings has been used against states and social institutions that uphold inequalities of rank, wealth, status or privilege.

The paradox: an accepted ideal, a visible inequality

Yet it is inequality, not equality, that is most visible around us. The textbook points to slums beside luxury housing, schools with world-class facilities beside schools lacking drinking water or toilets, and food wasted while others starve. There are glaring gaps between what the law promises and what we see.

To illustrate, the textbook gives a fact sheet on global inequality from the UNDP Human Development Report, 2005. One of its points, according to the textbook, is that the poorest 40 per cent of the world's population received only 5 per cent of global income while the richest 10 per cent controlled 54 per cent. It also shows urban-rural gaps in India from the Census of India, 2011. You do not need to memorise these figures; the table below simply shows the kind of disparity the textbook describes.

Households with selected amenities, Census of India 2011, according to the textbook (for understanding only)
Families that haveRural familiesUrban families
Electricity connection55%93%
Tap water in the house35%71%
Bathroom in the house45%87%
Television33%77%

So we face a paradox: almost everyone accepts the ideal of equality, yet almost everywhere we meet inequality of wealth, opportunity, work situations and power. Are such inequalities permanent and inevitable, reflecting differences of talent and contribution? Or are they the result of our social position and rules? Questions like these make equality one of the central themes of social and political theory.

The questions political theory asks

  1. Since we differ in many obvious ways, what does it mean to say we are equal?
  2. What are we trying to achieve: eliminating all differences of income and status? What kind of equality, and for whom?
  3. To promote equality, should we always treat everyone in exactly the same way?
  4. How should a society decide which differences of treatment or reward are acceptable?
  5. What policies would make society more egalitarian?

Worked example 1: reading a disparity table

Using the textbook's Census 2011 figures, how many times more likely was an urban family than a rural family to have tap water in the house? Working: urban 71 per cent, rural 35 per cent. 71 / 35 is about 2.0. Answer: roughly twice as likely. What it shows: the same constitutional promise of equality coexists with very different living conditions, which is the paradox described above.

Worked example 2: talent or social rules?

Two made-up students, Meera and Sohan, are equally able. Meera's school has a science laboratory; Sohan's has none. Meera scores higher in practical work. Is the gap a result of talent or of social position? Reasoning: their ability is the same; the difference in facilities explains the gap. This is an inequality produced by social circumstance, not by nature, and it is exactly the kind of question the textbook says troubles people about inequality.

Key takeaways: equality is a moral and political ideal resting on the equal worth and common humanity of all people; it underlies universal human rights. It was a rallying slogan of the French Revolution, of anti-colonial struggles and of marginalised groups. Yet inequality is everywhere, creating a paradox that makes equality a central theme of political theory, which asks what kind of equality we seek and how to achieve it.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The slogan 'Liberty, Equality and Fraternity' was used, according to the chapter, by:

    1. anti-colonial movements in Asia
    2. the French revolutionaries in the eighteenth century
    3. the women's movement in the nineteenth century
    4. Indian socialists
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says the French revolutionaries used this slogan in the eighteenth century to revolt against the landed feudal aristocracy and the monarchy.

  2. 2. As a political ideal, equality rests mainly on the idea that:

    1. everyone has the same talents
    2. everyone earns the same income
    3. all human beings have equal worth because of their common humanity
    4. everyone belongs to the same religion
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says equality invokes the idea that all human beings have equal worth regardless of colour, gender, race or nationality, and deserve equal respect because of common humanity.

  3. 3. The 'paradox' of equality described in the chapter is that:

    1. almost everyone accepts the ideal, yet inequality is found almost everywhere
    2. equality and freedom are the same
    3. nobody accepts equality
    4. inequality exists only in other countries
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says that almost everyone accepts the ideal of equality, yet almost everywhere we encounter inequality.

  4. 4. The notion of a shared humanity lies behind which ideas, according to the chapter?

    1. Private property and inheritance
    2. Monarchy and aristocracy
    3. Divine right of kings
    4. Universal human rights and 'crimes against humanity'
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says the notion of a shared humanity lies behind universal human rights and the idea of crimes against humanity.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Equality is one of the central themes of political theory. Reason (R): People have long been troubled by whether inequalities are natural and inevitable or the result of social position and rules.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says it is questions of this kind (are inequalities inevitable or produced by social rules?) that make equality one of the central themes of social and political theory. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery