• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Socialism, Marxism and liberalism on equality

Compare how Marxists and socialists and how liberals explain inequality and propose to reduce it, and explain Rammanohar Lohia's idea of the seven revolutions (Sapta Kranti).

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State Marx's explanation of entrenched inequality and the socialist response.
  • State the liberal view that fair competition is the most just and efficient way to distribute rewards.
  • Explain Lohia's five inequalities and seven revolutions, and compare socialist and liberal views.

Why does inequality persist, and what should be done about it? The textbook presents two important ideologies of our time, Marxism (and socialism) and liberalism, which give different answers. As always in this course, we present each view as the textbook does, without judging between them; the textbook itself notes that these views are debated worldwide.

Marx, Marxists and socialists

Karl Marx, an important nineteenth-century thinker, argued that the root cause of entrenched inequality was private ownership of important economic resources such as oil, land or forests, and of other forms of property. Such ownership not only made the class of owners wealthy; it also gave them political power, which lets them influence state policies and laws and could threaten democratic government. Marxists and socialists believe that economic inequality supports other social inequalities such as differences of rank or privilege. So, they argue, tackling inequality requires going beyond equal opportunities and ensuring public control over essential resources and forms of property. The textbook remarks that such views may be debatable but raise important issues.

The textbook describes socialism as a set of political ideas that emerged in response to the inequalities present in, and reproduced by, the industrial capitalist economy. Its main concern is to minimise existing inequality and distribute resources justly. Socialists are not entirely opposed to the market, but favour government regulation, planning and control over key areas such as education and health care.

Lohia's seven revolutions

The Indian socialist thinker Rammanohar Lohia identified five inequalities to be fought simultaneously: between man and woman; based on skin colour; based on caste; the colonial rule of some countries over others; and economic inequality. In his time, the textbook explains, many socialists held that class inequality was the only one worth fighting and that others would end automatically once economic inequality ended. Lohia argued that each inequality had independent roots and had to be fought separately and simultaneously. He spoke of five revolutions, and added two more: a revolution for civil liberties against unjust encroachment on private life, and a revolution for non-violence, giving up weapons in favour of Satyagraha. These seven made up the Sapta Kranti, his ideal of socialism.

Lohia's Sapta Kranti (seven revolutions)

  • Five inequalities to fight together
    • Man and woman
    • Skin colour
    • Caste
    • Colonial rule of some countries over others
    • Economic inequality
  • Two further revolutions
    • Civil liberties against unjust encroachment on private life
    • Non-violence: renouncing weapons for Satyagraha

The liberal view

An opposing view comes from liberal theories. Liberals uphold competition as the most efficient and fair way of distributing resources and rewards. They accept that the state may need to intervene to ensure a minimum standard of living and equal opportunities, but believe this alone cannot bring equality and justice. Competition among people in free and fair conditions is, for them, the most just and efficient way to distribute rewards; as long as competition is open and free, inequalities are unlikely to become entrenched and people will be rewarded for talent and effort.

For liberals, competition is also the fairest way to select candidates for jobs or admissions. The textbook's example: entry to professional courses in India is highly competitive, and the government and courts have from time to time regulated institutions and entrance tests so that everyone gets a fair chance. Some will still not be admitted, but this is considered a fair way to distribute limited seats.

Unlike socialists, liberals do not believe that political, economic and social inequalities are necessarily linked. They hold that each sphere's inequality should be tackled in its own way: democracy may provide political equality, while different strategies deal with social and economic inequality. The problem for liberals is not inequality as such, but unjust and entrenched inequalities that prevent individuals from developing their capabilities.

Marxist/socialist and liberal views (as the textbook presents them)

  • Marxists and socialists
    • Root cause: private ownership of key resources
    • Economic inequality supports other inequalities
    • Go beyond equal opportunity: public control of essential resources
    • Favour regulation and planning in areas like education and health
  • Liberals
    • Fair, open competition is the most just and efficient distributor
    • State ensures minimum standards and equal opportunity
    • Spheres of inequality are not necessarily linked; tackle each separately
    • Concern is unjust and entrenched inequality, not inequality as such

Marxists and socialists see private ownership of key resources as the root of entrenched inequality and seek public control; liberals see fair and open competition as the most just way to distribute rewards, and target only unjust, entrenched inequalities.

— Summary in our own words

Worked example 1: whose argument is it?

Identify the ideology behind each made-up statement. (a) 'Because a few families own the mines, they also control the newspapers and influence the government.' (b) 'Let every student sit the same fair entrance test; seats go to those who score best.' (c) 'Ending caste discrimination will not happen automatically if incomes rise; it must be fought on its own.' Answers: (a) Marxist reasoning: ownership of resources gives political power. (b) liberal reasoning: fair competition as the just distributor. (c) Lohia's view: each inequality has independent roots.

Worked example 2: are the spheres linked?

In a made-up country, everyone can vote, but most legislators come from wealthy families. Socialist reading: economic inequality is spilling into political power, so the spheres are linked and economic inequality must be tackled at its root. Liberal reading: political equality exists through the vote; the problem should be addressed by its own strategies, such as fair rules on election spending and wider access to education. The example shows how the two ideologies analyse the same fact differently.

Key takeaways: Marx saw private ownership of key resources as the root of entrenched inequality, giving owners political power; Marxists and socialists seek public control over essential resources, and socialism favours regulation of areas like education and health. Lohia argued that five inequalities, plus the struggles for civil liberties and non-violence, must be fought simultaneously: the Sapta Kranti. Liberals favour fair competition, treat the spheres of inequality separately, and target unjust, entrenched inequality.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to Marx, as the chapter presents him, the root cause of entrenched inequality was:

    1. differences in natural talent
    2. lack of competition
    3. private ownership of important economic resources
    4. the right to vote
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says Marx argued that the root cause of entrenched inequality was private ownership of important economic resources such as oil, land or forests, and other forms of property.

  2. 2. Lohia's Sapta Kranti refers to:

    1. seven revolutions he saw as the ideal of socialism
    2. seven Five-Year Plans
    3. seven fundamental rights
    4. seven states of India
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says Lohia's five revolutions against inequalities, plus revolutions for civil liberties and for non-violence, made up the seven revolutions or Sapta Kranti, his ideal of socialism.

  3. 3. For liberals, the most just and efficient way of distributing rewards in society is:

    1. public ownership of all property
    2. competition between people in free and fair conditions
    3. distribution by birth
    4. equal income for everyone regardless of effort
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says liberals uphold competition in free and fair conditions as the most just and efficient way of distributing rewards.

  4. 4. Which statement correctly contrasts liberals with socialists, according to the chapter?

    1. Liberals believe political, economic and social inequalities are necessarily linked
    2. Socialists reject all markets completely
    3. Liberals oppose any state role in ensuring a minimum standard of living
    4. Liberals do not believe the three kinds of inequality are necessarily linked, and would tackle each separately
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says that, unlike socialists, liberals do not believe political, economic and social inequalities are necessarily linked, and maintain that each should be tackled appropriately.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Lohia argued that inequalities of gender, colour and caste must be fought separately and simultaneously. Reason (R): Lohia believed that each of these inequalities had independent roots and would not end automatically when economic inequality ended.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says Lohia rejected the view that other inequalities would end automatically with economic inequality, arguing they had independent roots. That is why he called for fighting them separately and simultaneously.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery