• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Three dimensions of equality and the feminist view

Explain political, social and economic equality, why each is needed for a just society, why entrenched inequalities are dangerous, and how feminism explains gender inequality through patriarchy and the sex/gender distinction.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain political, social and economic equality and how they relate.
  • Explain why entrenched inequalities are especially dangerous for a society.
  • Explain the feminist ideas of patriarchy, sex and gender, the public/private division and the double burden.

Once we know which differences are unacceptable, we can ask which dimensions of equality a society should pursue. The textbook says that thinkers and ideologies have highlighted three main dimensions: political, social and economic. Only by addressing all three can a society move towards being more just and equal.

Three dimensions of equality

  • Political equality
    • Equal citizenship
    • Right to vote, freedom of expression, movement, association and belief
    • Legal rights guaranteed by constitution and laws
  • Social equality
    • Equality of opportunities
    • Minimum conditions of life for all
    • Removing discriminatory customs
  • Economic equality
    • Reducing gaps in wealth, property and income
    • Equal opportunities to improve one's position
    • Avoiding entrenched inequality

Political equality

In democratic societies, political equality normally means equal citizenship for all members of the state. Equal citizenship brings basic rights such as the right to vote, freedom of expression, movement and association, and freedom of belief, which help citizens develop themselves and take part in the affairs of the state. These are legal rights guaranteed by the constitution and laws. But considerable inequality can exist even where all citizens have equal rights, because of differences in resources and opportunities in the social and economic spheres. Hence the demand for equal opportunities, or a level playing field. Political and legal equality may not be enough by itself, but it is an important component of a just society.

Social equality

Equality before the law is an important first step, but it needs to be supplemented by equality of opportunities. Legal equality removes hurdles that exclude people from a voice in government; social equality requires that people of all groups have a fair and equal chance to compete for social goods. This means minimising the effects of social and economic inequality and guaranteeing minimum conditions of life: adequate health care, good education, adequate nourishment and a minimum wage, among others. Without these, people cannot compete on equal terms, and a huge pool of potential talent is wasted.

In India, the textbook notes, a special problem comes not only from a lack of facilities but from customs in some regions or groups: women may not have equal inheritance rights in some groups, may face social prohibitions on some activities, or may be discouraged from higher education. The state has a significant role: policies to prevent discrimination or harassment of women in public places and employment, incentives to open education and professions to women. Social groups and individuals also have a role in raising awareness and supporting those who wish to exercise their rights.

Economic equality

At the simplest level, economic inequality exists when there are significant differences in wealth, property or income between individuals or classes. It can be measured by the relative difference between the richest and poorest groups, or by estimating the number of people below the poverty line. Absolute equality of wealth or income has probably never existed in any society. Most democracies try to provide equal opportunities, so that those with talent and determination can improve their condition; inequality may remain, but people can improve their position with enough effort.

The textbook warns that entrenched inequalities, which remain largely untouched over generations, are more dangerous. If some classes hold wealth and the power that comes with it for generations while others stay poor, society becomes divided between them; over time this can produce resentment and violence, and the power of the wealthy may make reform difficult.

Legal equality is the first step; social equality adds fair opportunities and minimum conditions of life; economic equality reduces gaps of wealth and income. Inequalities that persist over generations are the most dangerous.

— Summary in our own words

Feminism

The textbook defines feminism as a political doctrine of equal rights for women and men. Feminists, men and women alike, believe that many inequalities between men and women are neither natural nor necessary and can be changed so that both can lead free and equal lives. According to feminists, gender inequality results from patriarchy: a social, economic and cultural system that values men more than women and gives men power over women. Patriarchy assumes that men and women differ by nature and that this justifies their unequal positions.

The feminist distinction

  • Sex
    • Biological difference between men and women
    • Example: only women can become pregnant and bear children
  • Gender
    • The different roles society assigns to men and women
    • Example: the expectation that only women look after children, which biology does not require

Feminists thus show that much inequality between men and women is produced by society, not by nature. Patriarchy also creates a division of labour: women are expected to handle 'private' and 'domestic' matters, men the 'public' domain. Feminists question this: most women everywhere work outside the home in some form, yet remain solely responsible for housework, a double burden, while having little or no say in public decisions. Feminists argue that this public/private distinction and all forms of gender inequality can and should be eliminated.

Worked example 1: which dimension is at stake?

Classify: (a) a made-up country denies the vote to people without property; (b) in a made-up village, girls are discouraged by custom from attending college; (c) in a made-up town, a few families have owned most of the land for generations while others remain landless labourers. Answers: (a) political equality (equal citizenship and the vote); (b) social equality (custom blocking equal opportunity); (c) economic equality, and specifically an entrenched inequality, which the textbook calls more dangerous.

Worked example 2: applying the sex/gender distinction

A made-up family says, 'Our daughter should give up her job after marriage because women are naturally homemakers.' Applying feminism: nothing in biology (sex) requires a woman to be a homemaker; this is a social role (gender). The claim presents a gender role as a natural difference, which is exactly the patriarchal assumption feminists question.

Key takeaways: political equality gives equal citizenship and legal rights but is not sufficient; social equality adds fair opportunities and minimum conditions of life, and requires tackling discriminatory customs; economic equality concerns gaps in wealth and income, where entrenched inequality is most dangerous. Feminism traces gender inequality to patriarchy, separates sex from gender, and challenges the public/private division and women's double burden.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of the following belongs to political equality as described in the chapter?

    1. Equal citizenship with rights such as the right to vote
    2. Equal income for all
    3. Free crèches at every workplace
    4. Equal inheritance in all customs
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says political equality in democracies normally includes equal citizenship, which brings basic rights such as the vote and freedoms of expression, movement, association and belief.

  2. 2. According to the chapter, one way of measuring economic inequality is to:

    1. count the number of political parties
    2. measure the relative difference between the richest and poorest groups
    3. count the number of schools
    4. compare the heights of people
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter suggests measuring the relative difference between the richest and poorest groups, or estimating the number of people below the poverty line.

  3. 3. Why does the chapter call entrenched inequalities more dangerous?

    1. They are easy to reform
    2. They exist only in villages
    3. Over generations they divide society into classes, breeding resentment and violence, and the power of the wealthy makes reform difficult
    4. They affect only the rich
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says inequalities untouched over generations divide society; this can give rise to resentment and violence, and the power of wealthy classes makes it difficult to reform such a society.

  4. 4. According to feminists, as the chapter explains, inequality between men and women is mainly the result of:

    1. biology alone
    2. patriarchy, a system that values men more than women and gives men power over women
    3. economic growth
    4. the right to vote
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says that according to feminists, gender inequality is the result of patriarchy, a social, economic and cultural system that values men more and gives them power over women.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Political equality by itself may not be enough to build a just society. Reason (R): Considerable inequality can exist even in countries that grant equal rights to all citizens, because of differences in social and economic resources and opportunities.

    1. A is false, but R is true
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    4. A is true, but R is false
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says inequality persists despite equal legal rights because of differences in resources and opportunities, which is why political equality alone is not sufficient. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery