Revision notes

Chapter 3 Equality: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Why equality matters: an ideal and a paradox

Equality, as a political ideal, means that all human beings have equal worth and deserve equal consideration and respect because of their common humanity, whatever their colour, gender, race or nationality.

— Key definition, in our own words

Equality in modern struggles (as the textbook lists them)

  1. 18th century: French Revolution 'Liberty, Equality and Fraternity' raised against the landed feudal aristocracy and the monarchy.
  2. 20th century: anti-colonial struggles Demand for equality raised in liberation struggles in Asia and Africa.
  3. Continuing struggles Raised by groups who feel marginalised, such as women and dalits.
  4. Today A widely accepted ideal embodied in the constitutions and laws of many countries.
Households with selected amenities, Census of India 2011, according to the textbook (for understanding only)
Families that haveRural familiesUrban families
Electricity connection55%93%
Tap water in the house35%71%
Bathroom in the house45%87%
Television33%77%

Key takeaways: equality is a moral and political ideal resting on the equal worth and common humanity of all people; it underlies universal human rights. It was a rallying slogan of the French Revolution, of anti-colonial struggles and of marginalised groups. Yet inequality is everywhere, creating a paradox that makes equality a central theme of political theory, which asks what kind of equality we seek and how to achieve it.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

What is equality? Opportunities, natural and social inequalities

Equality does not require removing all differences between people. It requires that the treatment people receive and the opportunities they enjoy are not decided in advance by birth or social circumstance.

— Key idea, in our own words

A distinction made in political theory

  • Natural inequalities
    • Arise from different capabilities and talents people are born with
    • Generally assumed to be unalterable
  • Socially produced inequalities
    • Arise from unequal opportunity or exploitation of some groups by others
    • Created by society's values, e.g. rewarding intellectual over manual work, or treating people differently by race, colour, gender or caste

Which inequalities concern advocates of equality?

  • From one's own choices
    • e.g. choosing a less paid career one prefers
    • Generally acceptable
  • From circumstances of birth
    • Family, caste, race, gender, place of birth
    • To be minimised and eliminated

Key takeaways: equal respect does not mean identical treatment; some differences from division of work are acceptable, but treatment fixed by birth is not. Equality of opportunities means equal rights and access to basic goods like education, health care and housing. The natural/social distinction is useful but unclear, because prejudice can pose as nature and 'natural' differences can be altered. Many theorists now separate inequalities of choice from those of circumstance, and target the latter.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Three dimensions of equality and the feminist view

Three dimensions of equality

  • Political equality
    • Equal citizenship
    • Right to vote, freedom of expression, movement, association and belief
    • Legal rights guaranteed by constitution and laws
  • Social equality
    • Equality of opportunities
    • Minimum conditions of life for all
    • Removing discriminatory customs
  • Economic equality
    • Reducing gaps in wealth, property and income
    • Equal opportunities to improve one's position
    • Avoiding entrenched inequality

Legal equality is the first step; social equality adds fair opportunities and minimum conditions of life; economic equality reduces gaps of wealth and income. Inequalities that persist over generations are the most dangerous.

— Summary in our own words

The feminist distinction

  • Sex
    • Biological difference between men and women
    • Example: only women can become pregnant and bear children
  • Gender
    • The different roles society assigns to men and women
    • Example: the expectation that only women look after children, which biology does not require

Key takeaways: political equality gives equal citizenship and legal rights but is not sufficient; social equality adds fair opportunities and minimum conditions of life, and requires tackling discriminatory customs; economic equality concerns gaps in wealth and income, where entrenched inequality is most dangerous. Feminism traces gender inequality to patriarchy, separates sex from gender, and challenges the public/private division and women's double burden.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Socialism, Marxism and liberalism on equality

Lohia's Sapta Kranti (seven revolutions)

  • Five inequalities to fight together
    • Man and woman
    • Skin colour
    • Caste
    • Colonial rule of some countries over others
    • Economic inequality
  • Two further revolutions
    • Civil liberties against unjust encroachment on private life
    • Non-violence: renouncing weapons for Satyagraha

Marxist/socialist and liberal views (as the textbook presents them)

  • Marxists and socialists
    • Root cause: private ownership of key resources
    • Economic inequality supports other inequalities
    • Go beyond equal opportunity: public control of essential resources
    • Favour regulation and planning in areas like education and health
  • Liberals
    • Fair, open competition is the most just and efficient distributor
    • State ensures minimum standards and equal opportunity
    • Spheres of inequality are not necessarily linked; tackle each separately
    • Concern is unjust and entrenched inequality, not inequality as such

Marxists and socialists see private ownership of key resources as the root of entrenched inequality and seek public control; liberals see fair and open competition as the most just way to distribute rewards, and target only unjust, entrenched inequalities.

— Summary in our own words

Key takeaways: Marx saw private ownership of key resources as the root of entrenched inequality, giving owners political power; Marxists and socialists seek public control over essential resources, and socialism favours regulation of areas like education and health. Lohia argued that five inequalities, plus the struggles for civil liberties and non-violence, must be fought simultaneously: the Sapta Kranti. Liberals favour fair competition, treat the spheres of inequality separately, and target unjust, entrenched inequality.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Promoting equality: formal equality, differential treatment and affirmative action

The reservations debate, as the textbook presents it

  • Arguments in support
    • Some groups suffered prejudice, exclusion and segregation
    • They cannot be expected at once to compete on equal terms
    • Special help is needed to create an egalitarian, just society
    • Meant to be temporary, until they can compete equally
  • Arguments of critics
    • Treating people differently cannot lead to greater equality
    • Quotas arbitrarily deny others their right to equal treatment
    • A form of reverse discrimination
    • Distinctions by caste or colour may reinforce prejudice; aim to abolish social distinctions

Promoting equality step by step

  1. Formal equality End legal privileges; no discrimination by religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth.
  2. Differential treatment Ramps, safe transport, maternity leave so people enjoy equal rights.
  3. Affirmative action Positive measures to correct the cumulative effect of past inequality.
  4. Test of every policy Does it make society more egalitarian and fair, without new dominance?

Treating people as equals may sometimes require treating them differently, but differential treatment needs justification and is valid only as a means to a more just and equal society.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: the first step to equality is ending formal privileges; the Indian Constitution prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth and abolishes untouchability. Formal equality is necessary but not sufficient: differential treatment such as ramps can enhance equality. Affirmative action, including reservations in India, aims to correct past inequality and is debated, with arguments on both sides. Treating people as equals may require differential treatment, which must be justified and must not create new dominance.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery