• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Discretionary powers of the President and the Vice President

Explain the situations in which the President can use discretion, including the right to be informed, returning advice, the suspensive and pocket veto and choosing a Prime Minister, why India needs a President, and the role of the Vice President.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Identify the three situations in which the President can act with discretion.
  • Explain the President's veto, including the 'pocket veto', with the textbook's example.
  • Explain why a parliamentary system needs a President and describe the Vice President's election, removal and role.

If the President must follow ministerial advice, does the President have no discretion at all? The chapter says that would be an incorrect assessment.

A right to be informed

Constitutionally, the President has a right to be informed of all important matters and deliberations of the Council of Ministers, and the Prime Minister is obliged to furnish any information the President calls for. Presidents often write to the Prime Minister expressing views on matters facing the country.

Three situations of discretion

  1. Returning advice for reconsideration. If the President thinks advice has flaws or legal gaps, or is not in the country's best interest, he or she can send it back. The Council may send the same advice again, which then binds, but the request naturally carries weight.
  2. Veto over Bills. Every Bill passed by Parliament goes to the President for assent. Except for a Money Bill, the President can withhold assent and send the Bill back for reconsideration. This veto is limited: if Parliament passes the same Bill again, the President must assent. But the Constitution sets no time limit for sending a Bill back, so the President can keep it pending indefinitely; this informal power is sometimes called a 'pocket veto'.
  3. Choosing the Prime Minister when no one has a clear majority. Normally the leader with majority support in the Lok Sabha is appointed and no discretion arises. But if, after an election, no leader has a clear majority and two or three leaders claim majority support, the President must judge who really has the support of the majority or can actually form and run the government.

The pocket veto in practice

The chapter's example: in 1986, Parliament passed the Indian Post Office (Amendment) Bill, widely criticised for seeking to curtail press freedom. The President of the time took no decision on it. After his term ended, his successor sent it back to Parliament for reconsideration. By then a new government, elected in 1989 and backed by a different coalition, chose not to bring the Bill back. So the postponement of assent meant the Bill never became law.

Political conditions and presidential discretion

The chapter notes that political changes since 1989 considerably increased the importance of the office. In the four Lok Sabha elections from 1989 to 1998, no single party or coalition won a majority, which required presidential intervention to constitute governments or to decide on a request for dissolution by a Prime Minister who could not prove a majority. After the 1998 election, according to the textbook, the President asked the leader of the largest alliance to furnish letters of support from the parties concerned and advised him to win a vote of confidence within ten days of being sworn in. The lesson: presidential discretion is related to political conditions; there is more scope for it when governments are unstable and coalitions hold power.

Discretion of the President

  • Right to be informed
    • PM must furnish information the President calls for
  • Return advice
    • Once, for reconsideration
    • Reconsidered advice binds
  • Veto over Bills
    • Return non-Money Bills once
    • No time limit: pocket veto
  • Appoint PM in a hung House
    • Judge who can command a majority
    • Greater when coalitions rule

Why do we need a President?

If the President is mostly a formal and ceremonial head, why have one? In a parliamentary system the Council of Ministers depends on majority support and may be removed at any time, after which a new one must be formed. This requires a head of state with a fixed term, who can appoint the Prime Minister and who symbolically represents the whole country. When no party has a clear majority, the President also has the responsibility of choosing a Prime Minister.

The Vice President

The Vice President is elected for five years by a method similar to the President's, except that members of State legislatures are not part of the electoral college. The Vice President can be removed by a resolution of the Rajya Sabha passed by a majority and agreed to by the Lok Sabha. The Vice President is the ex-officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha and takes over as President when there is a vacancy due to death, resignation, removal by impeachment or otherwise, acting only until a new President is elected. The chapter's example: a Vice President acted as President after the death of a President in office until a new one was elected.

President and Vice President compared
FeaturePresidentVice President
TermFive yearsFive years
ElectorsElected MPs and elected MLAsMembers of Parliament only (State legislators excluded)
RemovalImpeachment by Parliament with special majority for violating the ConstitutionResolution of the Rajya Sabha by majority, agreed to by the Lok Sabha
Other roleFormal head of stateEx-officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha; acts as President during a vacancy

The President's discretion: return advice once, withhold assent to non-Money Bills (with no time limit, the 'pocket veto'), and choose a Prime Minister when no one clearly commands a majority. Discretion grows when coalitions and unstable governments make politics uncertain.

Worked example 1: a Bill sent back

In a made-up case, Parliament passes a Bill on data collection. The President returns it for reconsideration. (a) Parliament passes it again without change. (b) Parliament never takes it up again. Reasoning: in (a), the President must give assent, because the veto over a returned Bill is limited. In (b), the Bill does not become law. Had the President simply kept it pending without deciding, that informal power would be the 'pocket veto'. A Money Bill could not be returned at all.

Worked example 2: a hung Lok Sabha

After a made-up election in a House of 500 members, Party A has 230 seats and Party B 200, while 251 are needed for a majority. Both leaders claim support from smaller parties. Reasoning: no one has a clear majority, so the President must use discretion: for example, by asking for letters of support from the parties concerned and by requiring the appointed leader to win a vote of confidence within a set time. Being the largest party alone does not settle the matter; the test is who can command a majority.

Worked example 3: President's rule request

The Prime Minister advises imposing President's rule in a State, and the President thinks the power should be used sparingly. Which course is open? Reasoning: the President cannot dismiss the Prime Minister for this, nor publicly attack the government. The President can discuss the matter, ask the Council to reconsider, and if the advice is repeated, must sign. This reflects Article 74(1).

Key takeaways: the President has a right to be informed and can act with discretion when returning advice, when withholding assent to non-Money Bills (including the pocket veto, as in the 1986 Post Office Bill case), and when choosing a Prime Minister in a hung House. Discretion grows in times of coalition. A fixed-term head of state is needed to appoint governments and represent the nation. The Vice President, elected by MPs, chairs the Rajya Sabha and acts as President during a vacancy.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which kind of Bill can the President NOT send back to Parliament for reconsideration?

    1. A Bill on education
    2. A Money Bill
    3. A Bill amending a criminal law
    4. A Bill on railways
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The President can withhold assent and return Bills other than Money Bills. A Money Bill cannot be returned for reconsideration.

  2. 2. Why is the President's power to keep a Bill pending sometimes called a 'pocket veto'?

    1. Because the Constitution sets no time limit for the President to return a Bill
    2. Because the President carries Bills in a pocket
    3. Because Parliament cannot pass the Bill again
    4. Because it applies only to Money Bills
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Constitution specifies no time limit within which the President must return a Bill, so the President can keep it pending indefinitely; this informal power is called the pocket veto.

  3. 3. According to the chapter, when is there greater scope for presidential discretion?

    1. When one party has a huge majority
    2. When the Supreme Court is on vacation
    3. When governments are unstable and coalitions occupy power
    4. Only during wars
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says presidential discretion depends on political conditions: there is more scope for assertiveness when governments are not stable and coalitions hold power.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): India needs a President even though the President usually acts on ministerial advice. Reason (R): In a parliamentary system the Council of Ministers may be removed at any time, so a head of state with a fixed term is needed to appoint the Prime Minister and represent the country.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because governments can fall, a fixed-term head of state provides continuity, appoints the Prime Minister and symbolically represents the nation.

  5. 5. Who are the electors in the election of the Vice President, according to the chapter?

    1. All adult citizens
    2. Elected MPs and MLAs
    3. State legislators only
    4. Members of Parliament, without the members of State legislatures
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Vice President's election is similar to the President's, except that members of State legislatures are not part of the electoral college.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery