- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
The permanent executive: the bureaucracy
Explain the role of the bureaucracy, the principles of political control and neutrality, how civil servants are recruited through public service commissions, central control over IAS and IPS officers, and the concerns about bureaucratic accountability.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the role of the civil service and the principles of political control and political neutrality.
- Describe the structure of the Indian bureaucracy and how recruitment by public service commissions ensures merit and representation.
- Explain why IAS and IPS officers strengthen central control and discuss problems of bureaucratic accountability.
Who implements the decisions of ministers? The executive includes, besides the Prime Minister and ministers, a large organisation called the bureaucracy or administrative machinery. To distinguish it from the military, it is called the civil service. Trained, skilled permanent employees assist ministers in formulating policies and implementing them.
Political control and political neutrality
In a democracy, elected representatives and ministers are in charge of government, and the administration works under their control and supervision. In a parliamentary system the legislature also controls the administration: officers cannot act against the policies adopted by the legislature. It is the ministers' responsibility to keep political control over the administration. India has built a professional administrative machinery that is also politically accountable.
The bureaucracy is expected to be politically neutral: it takes no political position on policy matters. In a democracy a party may lose an election, and the new government may want new policies in place of the old ones. The administrative machinery must then faithfully and efficiently help draft and implement the new policies.
Political executive and bureaucracy
-
Ministers (political executive)
- Elected; change with elections
- Decide policy
- Answerable to the legislature
- Keep political control over the administration
-
Civil servants (permanent executive)
- Recruited on merit; permanent
- Help draft and implement policy
- Politically neutral
- Serve any elected government faithfully
Structure and recruitment
The Indian bureaucracy is enormously complex. It consists of the All India Services, State services, employees of local governments, and technical and managerial staff of public sector undertakings. The framers wanted a non-partisan, professional bureaucracy whose members are selected impartially on merit. So the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) conducts recruitment of civil servants for the Government of India, and State Public Service Commissions do so for the States. Members of the Public Service Commissions are appointed for a fixed term, and their removal or suspension requires a thorough enquiry by a judge of the Supreme Court.
Efficiency and merit are the norms, but the Constitution also makes sure all sections of society, including weaker sections, can join the bureaucracy. It provides reservation in jobs for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes; reservations have later also been provided for women, Other Backward Classes and Economically Weaker Sections, according to the textbook. These provisions make the bureaucracy more representative, so that social inequality does not block recruitment.
IAS and IPS: central control over State administration
Officers selected by the UPSC for the Indian Administrative Service (IAS) and Indian Police Service (IPS) form the backbone of higher-level administration in the States. The district collector, the most important government officer at the district level, is normally an IAS officer, governed by service conditions laid down by the central government. An IAS or IPS officer is assigned to a State and works under its supervision, but is appointed by the central government, can return to central service, and only the central government can take disciplinary action against him or her. So the key administrative officers of the States are under central supervision and control, a feature that, as the federalism chapter explains, strengthens the centre. The rest of State administration is run by officers recruited through State Public Service Commissions.
| Service | Recruited by | Where they work | Who can discipline them |
|---|---|---|---|
| All India Services (IAS, IPS) | UPSC | Allotted to a State; may go on deputation to the centre | Central government |
| Central services | UPSC | Central government offices anywhere in India | Central government |
| State civil services | State Public Service Commission | Within the State that recruited them | State government |
Problems of the bureaucracy
The bureaucracy is the instrument through which welfare policies must reach people, yet it is often so powerful that people fear approaching an officer, and many experience it as insensitive to ordinary citizens. The chapter identifies a dilemma: only control by the democratically elected government can tackle some of these problems, but too much political interference turns the bureaucracy into a tool of politicians. Many feel there is no provision protecting civil servants from political interference in performing their duties, and not enough to ensure accountability to citizens. The chapter hopes measures such as the Right to Information can make the bureaucracy more responsive and accountable.
Conclusion of the chapter
The modern executive is very powerful, more so than the other organs, which creates a greater need for democratic control. With foresight, the framers placed the executive under regular supervision by choosing a parliamentary executive. Periodic elections, constitutional limits on power and democratic politics have kept the executive from becoming unresponsive.
The bureaucracy is permanent, recruited on merit by public service commissions, politically neutral, and under the political control of ministers answerable to the legislature. IAS and IPS officers serve States but are appointed and disciplined by the centre.
Worked example 1: match the service
Match the description to the service. (i) Works only within the State that recruited it. (ii) Works in central government offices anywhere in the country. (iii) Works in the State to which allotted and may be sent to the centre. (iv) Works in Indian missions abroad. Answers: (i) State civil services; (ii) central services; (iii) All India Services; (iv) the Indian Foreign Service.
Worked example 2: a new government, a new policy
A made-up State elects a new government that replaces the previous government's scheme with a different one. A senior officer personally preferred the old scheme. Reasoning: political neutrality requires the officer to help draft and carry out the new policy faithfully and efficiently; refusing would put the officer's preference above the elected government's mandate. The officer may give frank professional advice while the policy is being formed.
Worked example 3: who acts against a collector?
A made-up State government is unhappy with the conduct of a district collector who belongs to the IAS. Reasoning: the officer works under the State's supervision, so the State can transfer him within the State, but only the central government can take disciplinary action against an IAS officer. This illustrates how All India Services strengthen central control.
Key takeaways: the civil service is the permanent executive that helps ministers frame and implement policy. It works under political control and must be politically neutral. Recruitment is on merit through the UPSC and State Public Service Commissions, whose members have security of tenure, with reservations to make the service representative. IAS and IPS officers give the centre control over key State officers. Concerns remain about insensitivity, political interference and accountability, which measures such as the Right to Information aim to address.
Check your understanding
-
1. What does the political neutrality of the bureaucracy mean?
- Civil servants cannot vote
- The bureaucracy does not take any political position on policy matters and serves any elected government faithfully
- Civil servants decide policy without ministers
- The bureaucracy belongs to the ruling party
Show answer
Answer: B. Political neutrality means civil servants take no political position on policy and faithfully help draft and implement the policies of whichever government is elected.
-
2. Which body conducts recruitment of civil servants for the Government of India?
- The Election Commission
- The Finance Commission
- The Union Public Service Commission
- The National Human Rights Commission
Show answer
Answer: C. The UPSC conducts recruitment for the Government of India; State Public Service Commissions do this for the States.
-
3. Who can take disciplinary action against an IAS officer working in a State?
- Only the central government
- Only the State government
- The district panchayat
- The State Public Service Commission
Show answer
Answer: A. IAS and IPS officers are appointed by the central government, and only it can take disciplinary action against them, which places key State officers under central control.
-
4. Assertion (A): Too much political interference can be harmful for the bureaucracy. Reason (R): Excessive interference turns the bureaucracy into an instrument in the hands of politicians.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the chapter warns that while elected control is needed, too much interference makes the bureaucracy a politicians' tool.
-
5. Which measure does the chapter mention as one that may make the bureaucracy more responsive and accountable?
- Abolition of public service commissions
- Ending all reservations in jobs
- Electing all district collectors
- The Right to Information
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter expresses the expectation that measures like the Right to Information may make the bureaucracy more responsive and accountable to citizens.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.