• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

What an executive is and the types of executive

Define the executive, distinguish the political executive from the permanent executive, and compare presidential, parliamentary and semi-presidential systems with the examples given in the chapter.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define the executive and state its main functions.
  • Distinguish the political executive from the permanent executive.
  • Compare presidential, parliamentary and semi-presidential executives and classify countries correctly.

The legislature, the executive and the judiciary are the three organs of government. Together they maintain law and order and look after people's welfare, and the Constitution makes them work in coordination and balance. In a parliamentary system the executive and legislature are interdependent: the legislature controls the executive, and the executive in turn influences the legislature. This chapter studies the executive organ.

What is an executive?

In any organisation, someone must take decisions and someone must carry them out. A school, a bank or a company has a body at the top that takes policy decisions and supervises routine administration. The word executive means a body of persons that looks after the implementation of rules and regulations in practice. In government, the organ that primarily looks after implementation and administration is the executive. It is responsible for implementing the laws and policies adopted by the legislature, and it is often involved in framing policy too.

The executive is not only presidents, prime ministers and ministers. It also includes the administrative machinery of civil servants. The chapter distinguishes two parts:

Political and permanent executive
Part of the executiveWho it includesRole
Political executiveHeads of government and their ministersOverall responsibility for government policy; elected and changes with elections
Permanent executiveCivil servants (the bureaucracy)Day-to-day administration; continues when governments change

Different types of executive

Countries organise their executives differently. Both India and the USA have presidents, but their powers are very different; both India and France have prime ministers, with different roles. The chapter describes three main types.

Presidential system. The president is both head of state and head of government. The office is very powerful in theory and in practice. Examples: the United States, Brazil and most nations of Latin America.

Parliamentary system. The prime minister is head of government. Most such systems have a president or monarch as the nominal head of state, whose role is mainly ceremonial, while the prime minister and cabinet wield effective power. Examples: Germany, Italy, Japan, the United Kingdom and Portugal. In Germany the president is the ceremonial head and the chancellor heads the government; Japan has an emperor as head of state; Canada is a parliamentary democracy and a constitutional monarchy with the monarch as formal head of state and the prime minister as head of government.

Semi-presidential system. There is both a president and a prime minister, but, unlike the parliamentary system, the president may have significant day-to-day powers. The president and prime minister may belong to the same party or to opposing parties. Examples: France, Russia and Sri Lanka. In France the president appoints the prime minister and ministers but cannot dismiss them, because they are responsible to parliament.

Three types of executive

  • Presidential
    • President is head of state and head of government
    • Very powerful office
    • USA, Brazil, most of Latin America
  • Parliamentary
    • Prime minister heads government
    • President or monarch is nominal head of state
    • Germany, Italy, Japan, UK, Portugal, India
  • Semi-presidential
    • Both president and prime minister
    • President may hold significant day-to-day powers
    • France, Russia, Sri Lanka

Case box: Sri Lanka's executive presidency

According to the textbook, Sri Lanka amended its constitution in 1978 to introduce an executive presidency. The people directly elect the President, who has vast powers: he or she chooses the Prime Minister from the party with a majority in Parliament, can remove the Prime Minister or ministers, is Commander-in-Chief and is also head of government. The textbook describes a six-year term and a removal procedure in which Parliament passes a resolution and the matter can be referred to the Supreme Court. Compare this with India, where the President is indirectly elected, is bound by ministerial advice and is impeached by Parliament alone.

Executive: the organ that implements laws and policies. Political executive: elected heads and ministers. Permanent executive: civil servants. Presidential: one powerful president heads state and government. Parliamentary: a nominal head of state and a prime minister with the real power. Semi-presidential: both, with a president who has real day-to-day powers.

Worked example 1: is a president always presidential?

A student says: 'A country with a president has a presidential executive; one with a prime minister has a parliamentary executive.' Correction using the chapter: India and Germany have presidents but are parliamentary systems, because their presidents are nominal heads of state. France and Russia have both a president and a prime minister and are semi-presidential. What matters is where real power lies and to whom the government is responsible, not the title.

Worked example 2: classify the made-up countries

Country P: the directly elected president heads both state and government and picks ministers who are not members of the legislature. Country Q: a hereditary queen opens parliament each year, while a prime minister who must keep the support of the lower house runs the government. Country R: an elected president with real powers appoints a prime minister who is responsible to parliament. Answers: P is presidential; Q is parliamentary with a constitutional monarchy; R is semi-presidential.

Worked example 3: political or permanent?

Classify: (a) a Union cabinet minister; (b) a district collector; (c) a Chief Minister; (d) a police superintendent. Answers: (a) and (c) are political executive, holding office because of elections and majority support; (b) and (d) are permanent executive, civil servants who continue when governments change.

Key takeaways: the executive implements laws and policies and often frames policy. It has a political part (heads of government and ministers) and a permanent part (civil servants). In a presidential system one president holds all executive power; in a parliamentary system a nominal head of state coexists with a prime minister who holds real power; in a semi-presidential system the president also has significant powers. The title of an office does not decide the type of system.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of the following best defines the executive?

    1. The organ that makes laws
    2. The organ that settles disputes between citizens
    3. The organ that primarily implements laws and policies and administers
    4. The body that conducts elections
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The executive is the organ that primarily looks after implementation and administration of laws and policies adopted by the legislature, though it also helps frame policy.

  2. 2. Those responsible for day-to-day administration, such as civil servants, are called the:

    1. political executive
    2. permanent executive
    3. legislature
    4. judiciary
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter calls heads of government and ministers the political executive, and those responsible for day-to-day administration the permanent executive.

  3. 3. In which system is the president both head of state and head of government, with a very powerful office?

    1. Parliamentary
    2. Semi-presidential
    3. Constitutional monarchy
    4. Presidential
    Show answer

    Answer: D. In a presidential system, such as the USA or Brazil, the president is both head of state and head of government.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): India has a parliamentary executive even though it has a President. Reason (R): In a parliamentary system, the president is usually a nominal head of state while the prime minister and cabinet wield effective power.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: having a president does not make a system presidential; in India the President is the formal head while the Prime Minister and Council of Ministers hold real power.

  5. 5. Which group of countries does the chapter give as examples of semi-presidential systems?

    1. France, Russia and Sri Lanka
    2. USA, Brazil and Argentina
    3. Germany, Italy and Japan
    4. UK, Portugal and Canada
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter lists France, Russia and Sri Lanka as semi-presidential; the USA and Brazil as presidential; and Germany, Italy, Japan, the UK and Portugal as parliamentary.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery