• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Prime Minister and the Council of Ministers

Explain how the Prime Minister is appointed and chooses ministers, the six-month rule, the 15 per cent limit on the Council of Ministers, collective responsibility, the sources of prime ministerial power and how coalition politics changed the office.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain how the Prime Minister is appointed and how the Council of Ministers is formed and limited in size.
  • Explain collective responsibility and the pre-eminence of the Prime Minister.
  • List the sources of the Prime Minister's power and the four effects of coalition politics on it.

No discussion of government in India happens without mentioning one office: the Prime Minister. The reason is simple: the President acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers, and the Council is headed by the Prime Minister, which makes the Prime Minister the most important functionary of the government.

Majority support and appointment

In a parliamentary executive the Prime Minister must have the support of the majority in the Lok Sabha. That support makes the Prime Minister powerful, and the moment it is lost, so is the office. For many years after independence one party had a majority and its leader became Prime Minister. Since 1989, there have been many occasions when no party had a majority, so parties formed coalitions, and a leader acceptable to most partners became Prime Minister. Formally, the President appoints as Prime Minister a leader who has majority support.

Forming the Council of Ministers

The Prime Minister decides who will be ministers and allocates their ranks and portfolios. Depending on seniority and political importance, ministers are ranked as cabinet minister, minister of state or deputy minister. Chief Ministers do the same in the States. The Prime Minister and all ministers must be members of Parliament; a person who becomes a minister or Prime Minister without being an MP must be elected to Parliament within six months. (In the Constituent Assembly, some members, such as Begum Aizaz Rasul, argued instead for a Swiss-style executive elected by the legislature, so that all interests would be represented.)

Size. Before the 91st Amendment Act (2003), the size of the Council of Ministers was decided by the needs of the moment, which led to very large councils; when no party had a clear majority there was a temptation to win MPs' support by offering ministerial posts, and this happened in many States too. The amendment provided that the Council of Ministers shall not exceed 15 per cent of the total number of members of the House of the People (or of the Assembly, in the States).

Collective responsibility

The most important feature of a parliamentary executive is that it is routinely under the control and supervision of the legislature. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha: a ministry that loses the confidence of the Lok Sabha must resign. The ministry acts as an executive committee of Parliament, governing collectively on its behalf. The principle rests on cabinet solidarity:

  • A vote of no confidence even against a single minister leads to the resignation of the entire Council of Ministers.
  • A minister who disagrees with a cabinet policy or decision must either accept it or resign.
  • All ministers are bound to support a policy for which there is collective responsibility.

Pre-eminence of the Prime Minister

The Council of Ministers cannot exist without the Prime Minister; it comes into being only after the Prime Minister takes the oath. The death or resignation of the Prime Minister automatically dissolves the Council, whereas the death, dismissal or resignation of a minister only creates a vacancy. The Prime Minister is the link between the Council of Ministers on one side and the President and Parliament on the other, which is why Nehru called the office 'the linchpin of Government'. It is the Prime Minister's constitutional duty to communicate to the President all decisions of the Council relating to the administration of the Union and proposals for legislation.

Sources of the Prime Minister's power

  • Within government
    • Control over the Council of Ministers
    • Command over the bureaucracy
  • In Parliament
    • Leadership of the Lok Sabha
  • In public life
    • Access to media
    • Projection of personality in elections
  • Abroad
    • Projection as national leader at summits and on foreign visits

Coalition politics and prime ministerial power

How much power a Prime Minister actually uses depends on political conditions. The office has been unassailable when a single party had a Lok Sabha majority, but not under coalitions. Since 1989 India has had many coalition governments, several of which could not complete their term. The chapter lists four effects:

  1. A growing discretionary role of the President in selecting Prime Ministers.
  2. More consultation among partners, leading to erosion of prime ministerial authority.
  3. Restrictions on prerogatives such as choosing ministers and deciding their ranks and portfolios.
  4. Policies decided through negotiation and compromise among allies, so the Prime Minister acts more as a negotiator than as leader of the government.

At the State level a similar parliamentary executive exists, with one key variation: the Governor, appointed by the President on the advice of the central government, has more discretionary powers than the President, though the main principles of the parliamentary system apply.

Collective responsibility: the Council of Ministers stands or falls together before the Lok Sabha. The Prime Minister is the linchpin: no Prime Minister, no Council. The Council may not exceed 15 per cent of the Lok Sabha's total membership (91st Amendment, 2003).

Worked example 1: the 15 per cent ceiling

A made-up State Assembly has 240 members. What is the largest permitted Council of Ministers, including the Chief Minister? Working: 15 per cent of 240 = 0.15 × 240 = 36. A council of 40 would breach the limit. For a made-up House of 500 members the ceiling would be 0.15 × 500 = 75.

Worked example 2: what happens next?

Consider three made-up events. (a) A minister resigns over a scandal. (b) The Prime Minister resigns. (c) The Lok Sabha passes a no-confidence motion against one minister. Reasoning: (a) creates only a vacancy; the Council continues. (b) automatically dissolves the whole Council of Ministers. (c) under collective responsibility, the entire Council must resign, not just the one minister.

Worked example 3: the six-month rule

A made-up expert who is not an MP is appointed a minister on 1 March. Reasoning: the minister must become a member of Parliament within six months, that is, by about 1 September. If not, he or she cannot continue as minister.

Key takeaways: the Prime Minister must command a Lok Sabha majority, is formally appointed by the President and chooses ministers, ranks and portfolios. Ministers must be MPs or become MPs within six months, and the Council may not exceed 15 per cent of the House. The Council is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. The Prime Minister is the linchpin of government, but coalition politics has made the office more of a negotiator. In the States, the Governor has more discretion than the President.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A person who is not a member of Parliament is appointed a minister. Within what period must he or she become an MP?

    1. One month
    2. Six months
    3. One year
    4. Five years
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter states that a person who becomes a minister or Prime Minister without being an MP has to get elected to Parliament within six months.

  2. 2. The 91st Amendment Act (2003) limited the size of the Council of Ministers to:

    1. 10 per cent of the total membership of the House
    2. 25 per cent of the total membership of the House
    3. 15 per cent of the total membership of the House
    4. One-third of the members present
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The amendment provided that the Council of Ministers shall not exceed 15 per cent of the total number of members of the Lok Sabha (or the Assembly in States).

  3. 3. What happens when the Prime Minister resigns?

    1. Only the Prime Minister's post falls vacant
    2. The President takes over as head of government
    3. The Lok Sabha is automatically dissolved
    4. The Council of Ministers is automatically dissolved
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Council of Ministers cannot exist without the Prime Minister: the death or resignation of the Prime Minister automatically dissolves it, while a minister's exit only creates a vacancy.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): A vote of no confidence against a single minister leads to the resignation of the entire Council of Ministers. Reason (R): The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha, based on the principle of cabinet solidarity.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because the ministry stands together and is collectively responsible, losing confidence in one minister means the whole Council must resign.

  5. 5. Which of the following is NOT one of the effects of coalition politics on the Prime Minister listed in the chapter?

    1. Erosion of prime ministerial authority through more consultation
    2. Restrictions on choosing ministers and their portfolios
    3. The Prime Minister acting more as a negotiator
    4. The Prime Minister gaining the power to dissolve the Rajya Sabha
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter lists a larger presidential role, erosion of authority, restrictions on choosing ministers, and policy by negotiation. The Rajya Sabha is a permanent House that cannot be dissolved.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery