• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

India's parliamentary executive and the President

Explain why India chose a parliamentary executive, how the President is elected and removed, what Article 74(1) says about ministerial advice, and why the President is the formal rather than the real executive.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Give the reasons the framers chose a parliamentary executive over a presidential one.
  • Describe the election, term and impeachment of the President.
  • Explain Article 74(1) and the binding nature of the Council of Ministers' advice.

When the Constitution was written, Indians had already worked a parliamentary system under the Acts of 1919 and 1935. This experience showed that in a parliamentary system the executive can be effectively controlled by the people's representatives. The framers wanted a government sensitive to public expectations, responsible and accountable.

Why a parliamentary and not a presidential executive?

A presidential executive puts great emphasis on the president as the chief executive and source of all executive power, so there is always a danger of a personality cult. The framers wanted a strong executive but with enough safeguards against a personality cult. In a parliamentary system many mechanisms make the executive answerable to and controlled by the legislature. So the Constitution adopted the parliamentary executive at both the national and State levels. Nationally, the President is the formal head of state, and the Prime Minister and Council of Ministers run the government; in the States, the executive consists of the Governor and the Chief Minister and Council of Ministers. The chapter adds a caution through a cartoon voice: India has had very strong Prime Ministers, so even a parliamentary system needs vigilant people and legislatures.

The executive in India

  • Union level
    • President: formal head of state
    • Prime Minister and Council of Ministers: real executive
    • Vice President
  • State level
    • Governor: formal head
    • Chief Minister and Council of Ministers
  • Permanent executive
    • All India services
    • Central and State services

The President: election, term and removal

The Constitution vests the executive power of the Union formally in the President, who in reality exercises it through the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister. The President is elected for five years. There is no direct election by the people: the President is elected indirectly, by the elected MPs and MLAs, according to proportional representation by single transferable vote.

The President can be removed only by Parliament through impeachment, which requires a special majority (as explained in the previous chapter). The only ground for impeachment is violation of the Constitution.

The President at a glance
FeaturePresident of India
TermFive years
Method of electionIndirect: elected MPs and MLAs vote by PR with single transferable vote
RemovalImpeachment by Parliament with a special majority
Only ground for removalViolation of the Constitution
Nature of positionFormal head; acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers

Article 74(1): advice that binds

Article 74(1) says, in substance, that there shall be a Council of Ministers with the Prime Minister at its head to aid and advise the President, who shall act in accordance with that advice; the President may require the Council to reconsider the advice, but must act on the advice given after reconsideration. The word shall indicates that the advice is binding. Because of controversy over the scope of the President's powers, an amendment (the 42nd, 1976) wrote in expressly that the advice is binding. A later amendment (the 44th, 1978) allowed the President to ask the Council to reconsider its advice once, but the reconsidered advice must be accepted.

Formal powers and real power

Formally, the President has wide executive, legislative, judicial and emergency powers. In a parliamentary system these are used only on the advice of the Council of Ministers. The Prime Minister and Council of Ministers have the support of the majority in the Lok Sabha and are the real executive. Jawaharlal Nehru explained the framers' intention in the Constituent Assembly, in substance: they gave the President no real power but made the position one of authority and dignity, a head who neither reigns nor governs. This is a paraphrase, not his exact words.

The executive power of the Union is formally vested in the President, but under Article 74(1) the President acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister; the advice may be sent back once for reconsideration, after which it binds.

Worked example 1: following the advice

In a made-up situation, the Council of Ministers advises the President to sign an ordinance. The President has doubts and returns it for reconsideration. The Council sends back the same advice unchanged. Reasoning: under Article 74(1), the President may ask for reconsideration once, but must act on the reconsidered advice. So the President must sign. The return still matters: it signals the President's concern and can carry weight.

Worked example 2: can the President be removed for this?

A made-up group of MPs wants to remove the President because they dislike his speeches. Reasoning: the only ground for impeachment is violation of the Constitution, and impeachment needs a special majority in Parliament. Disagreement with speeches is not a ground. The fixed term and difficult removal protect the dignity and stability of the office.

Worked example 3: why not a presidential system?

A student argues that a directly elected president would give India a stronger government. Response using the chapter: the framers did want a strong executive, but they feared a personality cult around a single all-powerful president. They chose a parliamentary executive because it keeps the executive answerable to and controlled by the legislature every day, building on India's experience under the 1919 and 1935 Acts.

Key takeaways: India chose a parliamentary executive for accountability and to guard against a personality cult, at both Union and State levels. The President is elected for five years indirectly by elected MPs and MLAs through PR with single transferable vote, and can be impeached by Parliament only for violating the Constitution. Under Article 74(1) the President acts on the binding advice of the Council of Ministers, which may be returned once for reconsideration.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why did the framers prefer a parliamentary executive to a presidential executive?

    1. Because a presidential executive cannot implement laws
    2. Because they wanted a strong executive with safeguards against a personality cult and with accountability to the legislature
    3. Because the British forced them to
    4. Because a parliamentary system needs no elections
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The framers wanted a strong but accountable executive; the presidential system carries a danger of personality cult, while the parliamentary system makes the executive answerable to the legislature.

  2. 2. How is the President of India elected?

    1. Directly by all adult citizens
    2. By the Lok Sabha alone
    3. Indirectly by elected MPs and MLAs through PR with single transferable vote
    4. By the Council of Ministers
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The President is elected indirectly by the elected members of Parliament and of the State Legislative Assemblies according to proportional representation with single transferable vote.

  3. 3. What is the only ground for the impeachment of the President?

    1. Violation of the Constitution
    2. Loss of majority in the Lok Sabha
    3. Disagreement with the Prime Minister
    4. Refusal to sign a Money Bill
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter states that the only ground for impeachment is violation of the Constitution, and the procedure requires a special majority in Parliament.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): The advice of the Council of Ministers is binding on the President. Reason (R): Article 74(1) says the President shall act in accordance with the advice, and must accept the advice given after reconsideration.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the word 'shall' in Article 74(1), reinforced by amendments, makes the advice binding, even after the President returns it once for reconsideration.

  5. 5. Who forms the real executive in India's parliamentary system?

    1. The President and the Vice President
    2. The Chief Justice of India
    3. The Rajya Sabha
    4. The Prime Minister and the Council of Ministers, who have majority support in the Lok Sabha
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The President has wide formal powers, but they are used on the advice of the Council of Ministers; the Prime Minister and Council, backed by a Lok Sabha majority, are the real executive.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery