Revision notes

Chapter 4 Executive: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What an executive is and the types of executive

Political and permanent executive
Part of the executiveWho it includesRole
Political executiveHeads of government and their ministersOverall responsibility for government policy; elected and changes with elections
Permanent executiveCivil servants (the bureaucracy)Day-to-day administration; continues when governments change

Three types of executive

  • Presidential
    • President is head of state and head of government
    • Very powerful office
    • USA, Brazil, most of Latin America
  • Parliamentary
    • Prime minister heads government
    • President or monarch is nominal head of state
    • Germany, Italy, Japan, UK, Portugal, India
  • Semi-presidential
    • Both president and prime minister
    • President may hold significant day-to-day powers
    • France, Russia, Sri Lanka

Executive: the organ that implements laws and policies. Political executive: elected heads and ministers. Permanent executive: civil servants. Presidential: one powerful president heads state and government. Parliamentary: a nominal head of state and a prime minister with the real power. Semi-presidential: both, with a president who has real day-to-day powers.

Key takeaways: the executive implements laws and policies and often frames policy. It has a political part (heads of government and ministers) and a permanent part (civil servants). In a presidential system one president holds all executive power; in a parliamentary system a nominal head of state coexists with a prime minister who holds real power; in a semi-presidential system the president also has significant powers. The title of an office does not decide the type of system.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

India's parliamentary executive and the President

The executive in India

  • Union level
    • President: formal head of state
    • Prime Minister and Council of Ministers: real executive
    • Vice President
  • State level
    • Governor: formal head
    • Chief Minister and Council of Ministers
  • Permanent executive
    • All India services
    • Central and State services
The President at a glance
FeaturePresident of India
TermFive years
Method of electionIndirect: elected MPs and MLAs vote by PR with single transferable vote
RemovalImpeachment by Parliament with a special majority
Only ground for removalViolation of the Constitution
Nature of positionFormal head; acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers

The executive power of the Union is formally vested in the President, but under Article 74(1) the President acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister; the advice may be sent back once for reconsideration, after which it binds.

Key takeaways: India chose a parliamentary executive for accountability and to guard against a personality cult, at both Union and State levels. The President is elected for five years indirectly by elected MPs and MLAs through PR with single transferable vote, and can be impeached by Parliament only for violating the Constitution. Under Article 74(1) the President acts on the binding advice of the Council of Ministers, which may be returned once for reconsideration.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Discretionary powers of the President and the Vice President

Discretion of the President

  • Right to be informed
    • PM must furnish information the President calls for
  • Return advice
    • Once, for reconsideration
    • Reconsidered advice binds
  • Veto over Bills
    • Return non-Money Bills once
    • No time limit: pocket veto
  • Appoint PM in a hung House
    • Judge who can command a majority
    • Greater when coalitions rule
President and Vice President compared
FeaturePresidentVice President
TermFive yearsFive years
ElectorsElected MPs and elected MLAsMembers of Parliament only (State legislators excluded)
RemovalImpeachment by Parliament with special majority for violating the ConstitutionResolution of the Rajya Sabha by majority, agreed to by the Lok Sabha
Other roleFormal head of stateEx-officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha; acts as President during a vacancy

The President's discretion: return advice once, withhold assent to non-Money Bills (with no time limit, the 'pocket veto'), and choose a Prime Minister when no one clearly commands a majority. Discretion grows when coalitions and unstable governments make politics uncertain.

Key takeaways: the President has a right to be informed and can act with discretion when returning advice, when withholding assent to non-Money Bills (including the pocket veto, as in the 1986 Post Office Bill case), and when choosing a Prime Minister in a hung House. Discretion grows in times of coalition. A fixed-term head of state is needed to appoint governments and represent the nation. The Vice President, elected by MPs, chairs the Rajya Sabha and acts as President during a vacancy.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

The Prime Minister and the Council of Ministers

Sources of the Prime Minister's power

  • Within government
    • Control over the Council of Ministers
    • Command over the bureaucracy
  • In Parliament
    • Leadership of the Lok Sabha
  • In public life
    • Access to media
    • Projection of personality in elections
  • Abroad
    • Projection as national leader at summits and on foreign visits

Collective responsibility: the Council of Ministers stands or falls together before the Lok Sabha. The Prime Minister is the linchpin: no Prime Minister, no Council. The Council may not exceed 15 per cent of the Lok Sabha's total membership (91st Amendment, 2003).

Key takeaways: the Prime Minister must command a Lok Sabha majority, is formally appointed by the President and chooses ministers, ranks and portfolios. Ministers must be MPs or become MPs within six months, and the Council may not exceed 15 per cent of the House. The Council is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. The Prime Minister is the linchpin of government, but coalition politics has made the office more of a negotiator. In the States, the Governor has more discretion than the President.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

The permanent executive: the bureaucracy

Political executive and bureaucracy

  • Ministers (political executive)
    • Elected; change with elections
    • Decide policy
    • Answerable to the legislature
    • Keep political control over the administration
  • Civil servants (permanent executive)
    • Recruited on merit; permanent
    • Help draft and implement policy
    • Politically neutral
    • Serve any elected government faithfully
Main kinds of civil services
ServiceRecruited byWhere they workWho can discipline them
All India Services (IAS, IPS)UPSCAllotted to a State; may go on deputation to the centreCentral government
Central servicesUPSCCentral government offices anywhere in IndiaCentral government
State civil servicesState Public Service CommissionWithin the State that recruited themState government

The bureaucracy is permanent, recruited on merit by public service commissions, politically neutral, and under the political control of ministers answerable to the legislature. IAS and IPS officers serve States but are appointed and disciplined by the centre.

Key takeaways: the civil service is the permanent executive that helps ministers frame and implement policy. It works under political control and must be politically neutral. Recruitment is on merit through the UPSC and State Public Service Commissions, whose members have security of tenure, with reservations to make the service representative. IAS and IPS officers give the centre control over key State officers. Concerns remain about insensitivity, political interference and accountability, which measures such as the Right to Information aim to address.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery