- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Harmonising the principles and just distribution
Explain why governments must harmonise the three principles of justice, what just distribution means within a society, and how measures such as abolishing untouchability, reservations and land reforms relate to it.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the tensions among the three principles and why governments must harmonise them.
- Define just distribution and the idea of a level playing field.
- Give the textbook's Indian examples of measures for social justice and explain why such debates should be examined calmly.
The three principles of the last lesson do not always point in the same direction. This lesson looks at how they can clash, why governments must balance them, and how social justice reaches beyond fair laws to the distribution of goods and opportunities.
Tensions among the principles
The textbook notes that in India lack of access to good education or health care is often combined with social discrimination on grounds of caste. The Constitution therefore allowed for reservations of government jobs and quotas for admission to educational institutions for people belonging to the Scheduled Castes and Tribes.
Governments may find it hard to harmonise the three principles: equal treatment for equals, recognition of different efforts and skills in deciding rewards and burdens, and a minimum standard of living and equal opportunities for the needy. Pursuing equal treatment alone may sometimes work against rewarding merit. Emphasising merit as the main principle may leave marginalised sections at a disadvantage, because they lacked access to good nourishment or education. Different groups favour different policies depending on which principle they stress. So it becomes a function of governments to harmonise the principles to promote a just society.
Why the principles must be balanced (our summary)
- Stress equal treatment only May fail to reward merit and effort.
- Stress merit only Marginalised groups who lacked nourishment and education fall behind.
- Stress special needs Groups debate who qualifies and how far help should go.
- Government harmonises Balances all three, then reviews the results and adjusts.
Then back to step 1: Stress equal treatment only
Just distribution
To achieve social justice, governments may have to do more than ensure that laws and policies treat individuals fairly. Social justice also concerns the just distribution of goods and services, between nations or between groups and individuals within a society. Where there are serious economic or social inequalities, it may be necessary to redistribute important resources to provide something like a level playing field. Within a country, social justice requires not only equal treatment under laws and policies but also some basic equality of life conditions and opportunities, so that each person can pursue his or her objectives and express himself or herself.
Social justice requires both fair laws that treat people equally and a just distribution of goods, services and opportunities, so that everyone has the basic conditions to pursue their goals: a level playing field.
| Measure | Purpose described in the chapter |
|---|---|
| Abolition of untouchability by the Constitution | Promote social equality; ensure 'lower' castes have access to temples, jobs and basic necessities like water |
| Reservations in government jobs and quotas in education for Scheduled Castes and Tribes | Address lack of access combined with caste discrimination |
| Land reforms by various state governments | Redistribute an important resource, land, more fairly |
Examining passionate debates calmly
Disagreements about whether and how to redistribute resources and ensure equal access to education and jobs arouse fierce passions, and sometimes even violence, because people feel their own and their families' futures are at stake. The textbook recalls that proposals for reserving seats in education or government employment have at times led to anger and violence. As students of political theory, it says, we should be able to calmly examine the issues using principles of justice. The key question is: can schemes to help the disadvantaged be justified by a theory of justice? The next lesson takes up John Rawls's answer.
The textbook also includes a cartoon about the blindfolded statue of justice: she is blindfolded to be impartial, but then how does she see people's special needs? The puzzle captures the tension between impartial equal treatment and attention to special needs.
It also quotes Dr B. R. Ambedkar, whose idea, in our own words, is that a just society is one in which the graded feelings of reverence towards those above and contempt towards those below dissolve into a compassionate society.
Worked example 1: spotting a conflict of principles
A made-up college has 100 seats. If it admits purely by entrance-test rank, almost no students from a made-up district without secondary schools are admitted. Analysis: proportionate justice (reward merit shown in the test) points one way. Recognition of special needs (these students lacked schools) points another. Equal treatment (all sit the same test) is satisfied on paper. Role of government: to harmonise, for example by improving schools in that district and by measures in admission, judged by whether they make society fairer. The textbook does not prescribe one answer; it asks us to reason with the principles.
Worked example 2: equal laws, unequal conditions
In a made-up state, the law lets every citizen buy land, but 80 per cent of the land is owned by 5 per cent of families. Reasoning: laws treat people equally, but life conditions are very unequal, so there is no level playing field. Just distribution might call for redistribution of an important resource, as land reform does in the textbook's example.
Key takeaways: the three principles can clash: equal treatment may ignore merit, and merit alone may disadvantage the marginalised; governments must harmonise them. In India, caste discrimination combined with lack of access led the Constitution to provide reservations for Scheduled Castes and Tribes. Social justice needs both fair laws and a just distribution of goods and opportunities, a level playing field, as with the abolition of untouchability and land reforms. Such debates should be examined calmly with principles of justice.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the chapter, why did the Constitution allow reservations of government jobs and quotas in education for Scheduled Castes and Tribes?
- Because lack of access to good education and health care was often combined with social discrimination on grounds of caste
- Because all citizens have identical needs
- To reward the wealthy
- To end proportionate justice
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says lack of access to education, health care and other facilities is often combined with caste discrimination, and therefore the Constitution allowed for reservations and quotas.
-
2. Just distribution, as the chapter uses the term, means:
- giving everyone identical incomes
- a fair distribution of goods and services, possibly with redistribution, to create a level playing field
- letting the strongest take what they can
- distributing only political rights
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says social justice concerns the just distribution of goods and services, and serious inequality may require redistributing resources to provide something like a level playing field.
-
3. Which is given in the chapter as an example of a measure to redistribute an important resource?
- Free markets
- The veil of ignorance
- Land reforms by state governments
- Higher salaries for ministers
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says various state governments have taken measures to redistribute land more fairly by instituting land reforms.
-
4. The cartoon of the blindfolded statue of justice raises which puzzle?
- Whether courts should be abolished
- Why judges wear robes
- Whether laws should be secret
- If justice is blindfolded to be impartial, how can she see people's special needs?
Show answer
Answer: D. The cartoon asks how blindfolded, impartial justice can see special needs, capturing the tension between impartial equal treatment and recognition of special needs.
-
5. Assertion (A): It becomes a function of governments to harmonise the different principles of justice. Reason (R): Different groups favour different policies depending on which principle of justice they emphasise, and the principles can pull in different directions.
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says equal treatment may work against merit, merit may disadvantage the marginalised, and groups favour different principles; therefore governments must harmonise them. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.