- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Pursuing social justice: basic needs, free markets and state intervention
Explain when a society lacks social justice, what basic minimum conditions of life include, and the arguments for free markets and for state intervention as the textbook presents them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain when the textbook would say a society lacks social justice, and what a just society should provide.
- List the basic minimum conditions of life and explain the government's responsibility for them.
- Set out the arguments for free markets and for state intervention, as the textbook presents them.
Principles and theories must finally be turned into policy. This last lesson asks what social justice requires in practice, and examines a debate that the textbook says is going on in India and elsewhere: should we rely on free markets or on state intervention to help the disadvantaged?
When is social justice lacking?
If deep and persistent divisions exist between those with greater wealth, property and the power that comes with them, and those who are excluded and deprived, social justice is lacking. The textbook is careful: justice does not require absolute equality or sameness in how people live. But a society is unjust if the gap between rich and poor is so great that they seem to live in different worlds, and if the deprived have no chance at all to improve their condition however hard they work. A just society should provide basic minimum conditions for healthy, secure lives and the development of talents, and equal opportunities to pursue chosen goals.
A just society does not demand that everyone live the same way, but it must give everyone the basic minimum conditions for a healthy, secure life and fair opportunities to pursue their goals.
Basic minimum conditions
Governments and international organisations such as the World Health Organisation have devised methods to calculate people's basic needs. In general, the textbook says, there is agreement that the following form an important part of them:
- the basic amount of nourishment needed to remain healthy;
- housing;
- a supply of clean drinking water;
- education;
- a minimum wage.
Providing basic needs is considered a responsibility of a democratic government. But it can be a heavy burden, especially in countries such as India with a large number of poor people. Even if we agree that the state should help the most disadvantaged, people disagree about the best method.
Free markets versus state intervention
A free market, in the textbook's simple description, is one where individuals are as far as possible free to own property, make contracts about prices, wages and profits, and compete for the greatest benefit. The two sides of the debate, as the textbook presents them, are summarised below. We present both neutrally.
The debate as the textbook presents it
-
Supporters of free markets
- Free transactions lead overall to a just distribution
- Merit and talent are rewarded; the incompetent get less
- Market is neutral: does not see caste, religion or gender
- Gives more choice to consumers
- Private services often of higher quality
- Many now accept a basic minimum and help for old and sick; state mainly keeps a framework of laws
-
Arguments for state intervention
- Choice exists only for those who can pay
- Private agencies may avoid unprofitable areas or give substandard service, e.g. few good private schools in remote rural areas
- Better private services may be too costly for the poor
- Markets tend to favour the strong, wealthy and powerful
- So the state should ensure basic facilities for all
On the market side, the textbook notes, not all supporters today want absolutely unregulated markets. Many accept that the state may ensure a basic minimum so people can compete on equal terms, but argue that the most efficient way may still be to let markets in health care and education develop, with private agencies providing services and the state empowering people to buy them, plus special help for the old and the sick. On the other side, the textbook observes that while arguments can be made on both sides, free markets often show a tendency to work in favour of the already privileged, which is why many argue the state should step in to make basic facilities available to all.
Disagreement in a democracy
The textbook ends on a constructive note. In a democratic society, disagreements about distribution and justice are inevitable and even healthy, because they force us to examine different views and rationally defend our own. Politics is about negotiating such disagreements through debate. Studying principles of justice should help us discuss the issues and reach agreement on the best way to pursue justice. The chapter also quotes J. S. Mill, whose point, in our words, is that justice concerns not only what is right to do, but what a particular person can claim from us as a moral right.
Worked example 1: is this society unjust?
Made-up Society P: incomes differ, but all children attend decent schools, clinics are available, and many people from poor families rise to well-paid jobs. Made-up Society Q: a small group lives in luxury while most lack clean water, and children of poor families almost never escape poverty however hard they work. Applying the textbook's test: P has inequality but provides basic minimum conditions and real chances to improve, so it is not unjust on this test. Q has 'different worlds' and no chance to improve, so social justice is lacking.
Worked example 2: classifying arguments
Classify each made-up statement as a free-market or a state-intervention argument. (a) 'Give poor families vouchers and let them choose any private school.' (b) 'Private hospitals will not open in this hilly district because it is not profitable, so the government must build one.' (c) 'A shop does not ask your caste before selling to you.' Answers: (a) free market with state empowerment to buy services; (b) state intervention, since private agencies avoid unprofitable areas; (c) free market, the argument that the market is neutral.
Key takeaways: social justice is lacking where the rich and poor live in different worlds and the deprived cannot improve their condition; justice needs basic minimum conditions and equal opportunities, not absolute sameness. Basic needs include nourishment, housing, clean water, education and a minimum wage, and providing them is a responsibility of democratic government. Free-market supporters stress efficiency, choice and neutrality; supporters of intervention note that markets can neglect the poor and favour the privileged. Debate on these questions is healthy in a democracy.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the chapter, does justice require absolute equality in the way people live?
- Yes, everyone must live identically
- Yes, but only in cities
- No, but a society is unjust if rich and poor live in different worlds and the deprived have no chance to improve
- No, justice has nothing to do with living conditions
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says justice does not require absolute equality or sameness, but a society is unjust if the gap is so great that rich and poor seem to live in different worlds and the deprived cannot improve however hard they work.
-
2. Which of the following is NOT listed in the chapter among basic minimum conditions of life?
- Clean drinking water
- A minimum wage
- Housing
- A private car
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter lists nourishment, housing, clean drinking water, education and a minimum wage. A private car is not a basic need.
-
3. Which argument for free markets is mentioned in the chapter?
- The market is neutral and does not care about caste, religion or gender, only talent and skill
- Markets always serve remote rural areas
- Markets make all services free
- Markets never need any laws
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter reports the argument that the market does not care about caste, religion or gender; it is neutral and concerned with talents and skills.
-
4. Case: In a remote made-up district there are very few private schools, and those that exist are of low quality. According to the chapter, this illustrates:
- that rural people do not want education
- that private agencies may avoid markets that are not profitable or provide substandard services, so the government may need to step in
- that free markets always provide the best services everywhere
- that education is not a basic need
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says if private agencies do not find a market profitable they may not enter or may give cheap, substandard service, which is why there may be few good private schools in remote rural areas and the state may need to step in.
-
5. Assertion (A): Disagreements about distribution and justice are healthy in a democratic society. Reason (R): They force us to examine different points of view and rationally defend our own views.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says such disagreements are inevitable and even healthy because they force us to examine different views and defend our own rationally. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.