• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

What is justice? From dharma and Plato to Kant

Explain why justice is central to politics, how different traditions understood it, why Plato's Socrates argued it is in our interest to be just, and how 'giving each person his due' has been reinterpreted through Kant's idea of dignity.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the textbook's comparison of justice with love, and why justice is central to politics.
  • Describe how justice was understood in ancient India, by Confucius, and in Plato's Republic.
  • Explain 'giving each person his due' and how Kant's idea of human dignity changed its meaning.

Chapter 4 of Political Theory opens with a comparison. We understand love intuitively even if we cannot define every shade of it; the same is true of justice. Both stir passionate responses, and no one hates either: everyone wants justice for themselves and, to some extent, for others. But unlike love, which concerns our relations with a few people we know well, justice concerns our life in society: how public life is ordered and the principles by which social goods and social duties are distributed among members. That is why questions of justice are of central importance for politics.

Justice in different traditions

All cultures have grappled with justice, though they interpreted it differently. The textbook gives three examples:

Early ideas of justice mentioned in the chapter
TraditionIdea of justice
Ancient IndiaJustice was associated with dharma; maintaining dharma, a just social order, was a primary duty of kings
China: ConfuciusKings should maintain justice by punishing wrongdoers and rewarding the virtuous
Athens, fourth century BC: PlatoIn The Republic, examined through a dialogue why we should be concerned about justice

Why be just? Plato's Republic

In The Republic, Socrates talks with two young friends, Glaucon and Adeimantus. They ask why anyone should be just, observing that unjust people often seem better off: those who twist rules for their own benefit, avoid taxes, lie and deceive often succeed more than the honest. If you are clever enough not to be caught, injustice seems to pay. (The textbook remarks that we still hear such views today.) Glaucon also states a view in the dialogue, which we can paraphrase: people find that suffering injustice is worse than the gain from doing it, so they agree among themselves to have neither, and from this agreement laws arise.

Socrates replies that if everyone were unjust, manipulating rules for their own interest, nobody could be sure of gaining from injustice; no one would be secure, and all would be harmed. So it is in our own long-term interest to obey laws and be just. He adds that to see why justice matters we must understand what it is. Justice is not merely doing good to friends and harm to enemies, or pursuing our own interests; it involves the well-being of all people. Just as a doctor cares for the well-being of patients, a just ruler or government must care for the well-being of the people, and this includes giving each person his due.

Socrates' argument for being just (our summary)

  1. Challenge The unjust seem to prosper if they are not caught.
  2. Imagine everyone unjust All twist rules for themselves.
  3. Result No one can be sure of benefiting; nobody is secure; all are harmed.
  4. Conclusion Being just is in our long-term interest; justice means the well-being of all, giving each his due.

Giving each person his due, then and now

The idea that justice means giving each person his due remains part of our understanding today, but our idea of what is due has changed since Plato. Now it is closely linked to what is due to each person as a human being. The German philosopher Immanuel Kant held that human beings possess dignity. If all persons have dignity, then what is due to each is the opportunity to develop their talents and pursue their chosen goals. Justice therefore requires that we give due and equal consideration to all individuals.

Justice concerns how a society distributes social goods and duties. In the modern view, influenced by Kant's idea of human dignity, it means giving every person due and equal consideration, including the chance to develop their talents and pursue their goals.

— Key idea, in our own words

'Giving each his due': two understandings

  • Plato's Socrates
    • Just ruler cares for well-being of all, like a doctor
    • Each person receives what is due within a just order
  • Modern view (Kant)
    • Every human being has dignity
    • Due to each: opportunity to develop talents and pursue goals
    • Equal consideration for all individuals

Worked example 1: testing 'injustice pays'

A made-up shopkeeper, Lalit, thinks: 'If I cheat on weights and am never caught, I gain.' Apply Socrates' reasoning. Step 1: if Lalit's view is right, it is right for everyone. Step 2: then his suppliers, landlord and customers also cheat him whenever they can. Step 3: no one can trust any deal; Lalit too is insecure and loses. Conclusion: in the long run, a world of injustice harms everyone, including Lalit, so justice serves his own long-term interest.

Worked example 2: what is 'due' to a person?

A made-up village panchayat decides that only boys from landowning families may use the new library. Applying Kant's idea: every child, as a human being with dignity, is due the opportunity to develop talents. The rule denies this to girls and to children of landless families. Conclusion: under the modern understanding of 'giving each his due', the rule is unjust because it fails to give equal consideration to all.

Key takeaways: justice, like love, is understood intuitively, but it concerns the ordering of public life and the distribution of social goods and duties, so it is central to politics. Ancient India linked justice to dharma, Confucius to punishing wrong and rewarding virtue, and Plato's Socrates argued that justice serves everyone's long-term interest and means the well-being of all. 'Giving each his due' now rests on human dignity (Kant): equal consideration and the opportunity to develop one's talents.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the chapter, in ancient Indian society justice was associated with:

    1. dharma, whose maintenance was a primary duty of kings
    2. free markets
    3. the veil of ignorance
    4. the will of the majority
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says that in ancient India justice was associated with dharma, and maintaining dharma or a just social order was considered a primary duty of kings.

  2. 2. In The Republic, the young people who ask Socrates why one should be just are:

    1. Cephalus and Polemarchus
    2. Kant and Rawls
    3. Glaucon and Adeimantus
    4. Confucius and Mencius
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says Plato examined justice through a dialogue between Socrates and his young friends Glaucon and Adeimantus.

  3. 3. Socrates' main argument for being just, as summarised in the chapter, is that:

    1. the gods reward the just
    2. unjust people are always caught
    3. kings command it
    4. if everyone were unjust, no one would be secure, so justice is in our long-term interest
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Socrates reminds the young men that if everyone manipulated rules, no one could be sure of benefiting and nobody would be secure; hence it is in our long-term interest to be just.

  4. 4. According to Kant, as presented in the chapter, what is due to each person because they possess dignity?

    1. Equal income regardless of work
    2. The opportunity to develop their talents and pursue their chosen goals
    3. A position decided by birth
    4. Obedience to rulers
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says that if all persons have dignity, what is due to each is the opportunity to develop their talents and pursue their chosen goals.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Questions of justice are of central importance for politics. Reason (R): Justice concerns how public life is ordered and the principles by which social goods and duties are distributed.

    1. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says that because justice concerns the ordering of public life and the distribution of social goods and duties, questions of justice are central to politics. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery