- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Three principles of justice: equal treatment, proportionality and special needs
Explain the three principles of justice in the chapter, equal treatment for equals, proportionate justice and recognition of special needs, with examples, and show how they relate.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the principle of equal treatment for equals and the rights it includes.
- Explain proportionate justice and the factors that can justify different rewards for different work.
- Explain the principle of recognising special needs and why it extends, rather than contradicts, equal treatment.
Modern societies broadly agree on the equal importance of all people. But how exactly do we give each person his or her due? The textbook sets out three principles that have been put forward. Each captures something important, and a just society needs all three.
Principle 1: equal treatment for equals
All individuals share certain characteristics as human beings, so they deserve equal rights and equal treatment. In most liberal democracies these include civil rights (life, liberty and property), political rights (such as the right to vote, enabling participation), and certain social rights (such as the right to equal opportunities).
The principle also requires no discrimination on grounds of class, caste, race or gender. People should be judged by their work and actions, not by the group they belong to. If two people of different castes do the same work, whether breaking stones or delivering pizzas, they should get the same reward. The textbook's illustration: if one person gets one hundred rupees for some work and another only seventy-five rupees for the same work because of caste, that is unjust. Likewise a male teacher being paid more than a female teacher for the same work would be unjustifiable.
Principle 2: proportionate justice
Equal treatment is not the only principle. Sometimes treating everyone identically would be unjust. Imagine a school deciding that everyone who wrote an exam should get the same marks because they are all students of the same school. Most would think it fairer to award marks by the quality of the answers, and possibly the effort put in. So, provided everyone starts from the same baseline of equal rights, justice can mean rewarding people in proportion to the scale and quality of their effort.
Most people agree that the same work should get the same reward, but that different kinds of work can fairly be rewarded differently, taking account of the effort required, the skills required, the dangers involved, and so on. On these criteria, the textbook observes, some workers, such as miners, skilled craftsmen or people in dangerous but socially useful professions like policemen, may not always receive a just reward compared with what others earn. For justice, equal treatment needs to be balanced with proportionality.
Principle 3: recognition of special needs
The third principle asks society to take account of people's special needs when distributing rewards or duties. Equal basic status and rights, non-discrimination and proportionate reward may still not ensure that people enjoy equality in other aspects of life or that society as a whole is just. People with special needs or disabilities may be unequal in some particular respect and deserve special help. Agreement on which inequalities count is not always easy, but physical disability, age, and lack of access to good education or health care are treated as grounds for special treatment in many countries. If people with very different living standards are treated equally in every respect with those deprived of even basic needs, the result is likely to be an unequal society, not a just one.
Importantly, the textbook says this principle does not necessarily contradict equal treatment; it extends it. Treating equals equally can imply that people who are not equal in certain important respects may be treated differently.
Three principles of justice
-
Equal treatment for equals
- Equal civil, political and social rights
- No discrimination by class, caste, race or gender
- Same work, same reward
-
Proportionate justice
- Reward in proportion to effort and quality
- Account for skill, effort, danger
- Starts from a baseline of equal rights
-
Recognition of special needs
- Special help for disability, age, deprivation
- Extends equal treatment
- Prevents an unequal society
Justice means treating equals equally, rewarding different effort and skill in proportion, and giving special help to those with special needs. The third principle extends the first: people unequal in important respects may be treated differently.
Worked example 1: which principle applies?
Identify the principle. (a) A made-up factory pays men and women the same wage for the same job. (b) A made-up firm pays a diver who repairs underwater pipes more than an office clerk. (c) A made-up school gives a visually impaired student extra time in an examination. Answers: (a) equal treatment for equals; (b) proportionate justice, since diving involves more danger and skill; (c) recognition of special needs.
Worked example 2: a pay calculation (illustrative)
Suppose (made-up figures) two workers of different castes each lay 200 bricks a day. Worker P is paid ₹500 and worker Q ₹375. Step 1: the work is identical (200 bricks each). Step 2: Q is paid ₹500 − ₹375 = ₹125 less, which is 125 ÷ 500 = 25 per cent less. Step 3: the only difference is caste, a group characteristic. Conclusion: this violates equal treatment for equals; both should receive ₹500. This mirrors the textbook's hundred-rupee versus seventy-five-rupee illustration.
Key takeaways: equal treatment for equals gives everyone equal civil, political and social rights, forbids discrimination by class, caste, race or gender, and requires the same reward for the same work. Proportionate justice rewards effort, skill and danger, from a baseline of equal rights. Recognising special needs gives extra help to those disadvantaged by disability, age or deprivation, and extends rather than contradicts equal treatment.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under the principle of equal treatment for equals, people should be judged on the basis of:
- their caste or community
- their work and actions
- their gender
- their family's wealth
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says that under this principle people should be judged on the basis of their work and actions, not the group they belong to.
-
2. Which factors does the chapter say may justify rewarding different kinds of work differently?
- Caste and religion
- Gender and age
- Effort required, skills required and dangers involved
- Place of birth
Show answer
Answer: C. Proportionate justice takes into account factors such as the effort required, the skills required and the possible dangers involved in the work.
-
3. Case: A made-up teacher gives every student the same marks regardless of their answers, saying 'they all took the same exam'. Which principle of justice does the chapter suggest is being ignored?
- Proportionate justice
- Equal treatment for equals
- Recognition of special needs
- Freedom of expression
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter uses this very example: most people would think it fairer to award marks according to the quality of the answers and the effort put in, which is proportionate justice.
-
4. According to the chapter, the principle of recognising special needs:
- completely contradicts equal treatment
- applies only to the rich
- replaces proportionate justice
- extends the principle of equal treatment rather than contradicting it
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says this principle does not necessarily contradict equal treatment but extends it, since people unequal in important respects may be treated differently.
-
5. Assertion (A): Treating people with very different living standards equally in all respects may produce an unequal society. Reason (R): Those deprived of even basic needs cannot compete on equal terms with those who enjoy many opportunities.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says treating the deprived equally in all respects with the privileged is likely to result in an unequal society; R explains why, since the deprived start far behind.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.