- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
John Rawls and the veil of ignorance
Explain John Rawls's thought experiment of the veil of ignorance, why rational people behind it would think from the position of the worst-off and want policies that benefit society as a whole, and why Rawls rests fairness on reason rather than benevolence.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the problem Rawls was trying to solve and what the veil of ignorance is.
- Explain why people behind the veil would think from the position of the worst-off and also want the whole society to benefit.
- Explain why Rawls's argument relies on rational self-interest rather than morality or self-sacrifice.
Can help for the least privileged be justified by reason, and not only by charity or kindness? The well-known political philosopher John Rawls argued that it can. His theory of just distribution is one of the most discussed parts of this chapter.
The problem
If people are asked to choose the kind of society they want, they will probably choose rules that give them a privileged position. We cannot expect everyone to set aside personal interests, especially when the choice affects their children's future; indeed, we expect parents to support what is best for their children. But such perspectives cannot be the basis of a theory of justice for a whole society. So how can we reach a decision that is both fair and just?
The veil of ignorance
Rawls's answer is to imagine making decisions about how society should be organised without knowing which position we ourselves will occupy in it. We do not know what family we will be born into, whether of an 'upper' or 'lower' caste, rich or poor, privileged or disadvantaged. Rawls argues that if we do not know who we will be, we will tend to support rules that are fair to all members. He calls this thinking under a veil of ignorance.
Veil of ignorance: imagine choosing the rules of a society without knowing your own future position in it, your family, caste, wealth or advantages. Rational people choosing this way would pick rules that are fair to all.
Behind the veil, each person still decides as people usually do, in terms of their own interests. But since no one knows who they will be, each will picture the future society from the point of view of the worst-off. A reasoning person sees that the privileged will enjoy special opportunities, but what if he or she is born into a disadvantaged section where few opportunities exist? So it makes sense, from self-interest, to choose rules that ensure reasonable opportunities for the weaker sections, so that important resources like education, health and shelter are available to all, not only the upper class.
Reasoning behind the veil of ignorance
- Do not know your future position Rich or poor, privileged or disadvantaged, any caste or family.
- Think in self-interest as usual Ask: what rules are best for me?
- Consider being worst-off I might be born where few opportunities exist.
- Choose protective rules Education, health, shelter available to all.
- Also keep the whole society thriving I might be born better-off too, so do not weaken them needlessly.
Reason, not heroism
Of course, it is not easy to erase our identities and imagine ourselves behind a veil. But it is equally hard for most people to be self-sacrificing and share their good fortune with strangers; that is why we associate self-sacrifice with heroism. Given these human limitations, the textbook says, it is better to have a framework that does not require extraordinary actions. The merit of the veil of ignorance is that it expects people to be their usual rational selves, thinking for themselves and choosing what they regard as in their interest. The point is that under the veil they will find it in their interest to think from the position of the worst-off.
Benefiting society as a whole
Wearing the imagined veil is the first step towards fair laws and policies. Rational people will not only see things from the worst-off's perspective; they will also try to make sure their policies benefit society as a whole. Both go hand in hand. Since anyone might be born among the worst-off, each wants rules that protect them; but since anyone might also be born privileged, each will avoid policies that needlessly weaken the better-off. So it is in everyone's interest that society as a whole, not just one section, benefits. Such fairness is the outcome of rational action, not benevolence or generosity.
Rawls therefore argues that rational thinking, not morality, can lead us to judge impartially how to distribute the benefits and burdens of society. In his approach, no moral goals or norms are given in advance; we remain free to decide what is best for ourselves. The textbook says it is this belief that makes Rawls's theory an important and compelling way to approach fairness and justice.
Two routes to helping the worst-off
-
Benevolence or self-sacrifice
- Depends on generosity
- Hard for most people; seen as heroic
- Not a reliable basis for rules
-
Rawls: rational choice behind the veil
- Depends only on ordinary self-interest
- Ignorance of one's position makes self-interest impartial
- Fairness follows from reason
Worked example 1: choosing a school system behind the veil
Imagine choosing between two made-up school systems without knowing whether you will be born into a rich or a poor family. System X: excellent schools only for those who can pay high fees; nothing for others. System Y: good basic schooling for every child, with room for some schools to do even better. Reasoning: under X, if you are born poor you get no education. Under Y, even the worst-off position includes a good basic education, and the better-off are not made needlessly worse. Rawlsian choice: Y, chosen from self-interest under uncertainty, not from charity.
Worked example 2: a made-up payoff table
A made-up society has three positions. Under rule set A, the yearly incomes (illustrative units) for the top, middle and bottom positions are 100, 50 and 5. Under rule set B they are 90, 50 and 30. Behind the veil you might land in any position. Step 1: worst position under A = 5; under B = 30. Step 2: B protects the worst-off far better. Step 3: B still keeps the top position well off (90), so society as a whole is not weakened needlessly. Rawlsian reasoning favours B.
| Position | Rule set A | Rule set B |
|---|---|---|
| Top | 100 | 90 |
| Middle | 50 | 50 |
| Bottom (worst-off) | 5 | 30 |
Key takeaways: Rawls asks us to choose rules behind a veil of ignorance about our own future position. Acting from ordinary self-interest, rational people would think from the position of the worst-off and ensure education, health and shelter for all, while also wanting society as a whole to benefit. Fairness thus follows from rational choice, not from benevolence or morality given in advance, which the textbook calls a compelling approach to justice.
Check your understanding
-
1. Rawls's 'veil of ignorance' asks us to imagine:
- choosing rules for society without knowing our own future position in it
- ignoring all laws
- choosing rules that favour our own family
- letting only experts decide
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says Rawls asks us to imagine deciding how society should be organised without knowing what position, family, caste or wealth we would have in it.
-
2. According to Rawls, as the chapter explains, people behind the veil of ignorance would envisage the future society from the point of view of:
- the richest
- the rulers
- the worst-off
- foreigners
Show answer
Answer: C. Since no one knows who they will be, each person will envisage the future society from the point of view of the worst-off, in case that is where they end up.
-
3. Rawls argues that fairness can be the outcome of:
- benevolence and generosity only
- religious duty
- the free market alone
- rational action, not benevolence or generosity
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says that such fairness would be the outcome of rational action, not benevolence or generosity; rational thinking, not morality, leads us to judge impartially.
-
4. The chapter says the merit of the veil of ignorance is that it:
- requires people to be heroes
- expects people to be their usual rational selves, choosing what they regard as in their interest
- forces everyone to be equal in income
- removes all choice
Show answer
Answer: B. Because self-sacrifice is rare and heroic, the textbook prefers a framework that does not need extraordinary actions; the veil only expects people to be their usual rational, self-interested selves.
-
5. Assertion (A): Rational people behind the veil would also avoid policies that needlessly weaken the better-off. Reason (R): They might themselves be born into a privileged position in the future society.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says that since one could also be born privileged, it makes sense to ensure chosen policies do not make the better-off weaker; so society as a whole should benefit. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.