Revision notes

Chapter 4 Social Justice: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What is justice? From dharma and Plato to Kant

Early ideas of justice mentioned in the chapter
TraditionIdea of justice
Ancient IndiaJustice was associated with dharma; maintaining dharma, a just social order, was a primary duty of kings
China: ConfuciusKings should maintain justice by punishing wrongdoers and rewarding the virtuous
Athens, fourth century BC: PlatoIn The Republic, examined through a dialogue why we should be concerned about justice

Socrates' argument for being just (our summary)

  1. Challenge The unjust seem to prosper if they are not caught.
  2. Imagine everyone unjust All twist rules for themselves.
  3. Result No one can be sure of benefiting; nobody is secure; all are harmed.
  4. Conclusion Being just is in our long-term interest; justice means the well-being of all, giving each his due.

Justice concerns how a society distributes social goods and duties. In the modern view, influenced by Kant's idea of human dignity, it means giving every person due and equal consideration, including the chance to develop their talents and pursue their goals.

— Key idea, in our own words

'Giving each his due': two understandings

  • Plato's Socrates
    • Just ruler cares for well-being of all, like a doctor
    • Each person receives what is due within a just order
  • Modern view (Kant)
    • Every human being has dignity
    • Due to each: opportunity to develop talents and pursue goals
    • Equal consideration for all individuals

Key takeaways: justice, like love, is understood intuitively, but it concerns the ordering of public life and the distribution of social goods and duties, so it is central to politics. Ancient India linked justice to dharma, Confucius to punishing wrong and rewarding virtue, and Plato's Socrates argued that justice serves everyone's long-term interest and means the well-being of all. 'Giving each his due' now rests on human dignity (Kant): equal consideration and the opportunity to develop one's talents.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Three principles of justice: equal treatment, proportionality and special needs

Three principles of justice

  • Equal treatment for equals
    • Equal civil, political and social rights
    • No discrimination by class, caste, race or gender
    • Same work, same reward
  • Proportionate justice
    • Reward in proportion to effort and quality
    • Account for skill, effort, danger
    • Starts from a baseline of equal rights
  • Recognition of special needs
    • Special help for disability, age, deprivation
    • Extends equal treatment
    • Prevents an unequal society

Justice means treating equals equally, rewarding different effort and skill in proportion, and giving special help to those with special needs. The third principle extends the first: people unequal in important respects may be treated differently.

— Summary in our own words

Key takeaways: equal treatment for equals gives everyone equal civil, political and social rights, forbids discrimination by class, caste, race or gender, and requires the same reward for the same work. Proportionate justice rewards effort, skill and danger, from a baseline of equal rights. Recognising special needs gives extra help to those disadvantaged by disability, age or deprivation, and extends rather than contradicts equal treatment.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Harmonising the principles and just distribution

Why the principles must be balanced (our summary)

  1. Stress equal treatment only May fail to reward merit and effort.
  2. Stress merit only Marginalised groups who lacked nourishment and education fall behind.
  3. Stress special needs Groups debate who qualifies and how far help should go.
  4. Government harmonises Balances all three, then reviews the results and adjusts.

Then back to step 1: Stress equal treatment only

Social justice requires both fair laws that treat people equally and a just distribution of goods, services and opportunities, so that everyone has the basic conditions to pursue their goals: a level playing field.

— Key definition, in our own words
Indian examples of measures for social justice given in the chapter
MeasurePurpose described in the chapter
Abolition of untouchability by the ConstitutionPromote social equality; ensure 'lower' castes have access to temples, jobs and basic necessities like water
Reservations in government jobs and quotas in education for Scheduled Castes and TribesAddress lack of access combined with caste discrimination
Land reforms by various state governmentsRedistribute an important resource, land, more fairly

Key takeaways: the three principles can clash: equal treatment may ignore merit, and merit alone may disadvantage the marginalised; governments must harmonise them. In India, caste discrimination combined with lack of access led the Constitution to provide reservations for Scheduled Castes and Tribes. Social justice needs both fair laws and a just distribution of goods and opportunities, a level playing field, as with the abolition of untouchability and land reforms. Such debates should be examined calmly with principles of justice.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

John Rawls and the veil of ignorance

Veil of ignorance: imagine choosing the rules of a society without knowing your own future position in it, your family, caste, wealth or advantages. Rational people choosing this way would pick rules that are fair to all.

— Rawls's idea, in our own words

Reasoning behind the veil of ignorance

  1. Do not know your future position Rich or poor, privileged or disadvantaged, any caste or family.
  2. Think in self-interest as usual Ask: what rules are best for me?
  3. Consider being worst-off I might be born where few opportunities exist.
  4. Choose protective rules Education, health, shelter available to all.
  5. Also keep the whole society thriving I might be born better-off too, so do not weaken them needlessly.

Two routes to helping the worst-off

  • Benevolence or self-sacrifice
    • Depends on generosity
    • Hard for most people; seen as heroic
    • Not a reliable basis for rules
  • Rawls: rational choice behind the veil
    • Depends only on ordinary self-interest
    • Ignorance of one's position makes self-interest impartial
    • Fairness follows from reason
Illustrative incomes under two rule sets (made-up units)
PositionRule set ARule set B
Top10090
Middle5050
Bottom (worst-off)530

Key takeaways: Rawls asks us to choose rules behind a veil of ignorance about our own future position. Acting from ordinary self-interest, rational people would think from the position of the worst-off and ensure education, health and shelter for all, while also wanting society as a whole to benefit. Fairness thus follows from rational choice, not from benevolence or morality given in advance, which the textbook calls a compelling approach to justice.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Pursuing social justice: basic needs, free markets and state intervention

A just society does not demand that everyone live the same way, but it must give everyone the basic minimum conditions for a healthy, secure life and fair opportunities to pursue their goals.

— Key idea, in our own words

The debate as the textbook presents it

  • Supporters of free markets
    • Free transactions lead overall to a just distribution
    • Merit and talent are rewarded; the incompetent get less
    • Market is neutral: does not see caste, religion or gender
    • Gives more choice to consumers
    • Private services often of higher quality
    • Many now accept a basic minimum and help for old and sick; state mainly keeps a framework of laws
  • Arguments for state intervention
    • Choice exists only for those who can pay
    • Private agencies may avoid unprofitable areas or give substandard service, e.g. few good private schools in remote rural areas
    • Better private services may be too costly for the poor
    • Markets tend to favour the strong, wealthy and powerful
    • So the state should ensure basic facilities for all

Key takeaways: social justice is lacking where the rich and poor live in different worlds and the deprived cannot improve their condition; justice needs basic minimum conditions and equal opportunities, not absolute sameness. Basic needs include nourishment, housing, clean water, education and a minimum wage, and providing them is a responsibility of democratic government. Free-market supporters stress efficiency, choice and neutrality; supporters of intervention note that markets can neglect the poor and favour the privileged. Debate on these questions is healthy in a democracy.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery