| Tradition | Idea of justice |
|---|---|
| Ancient India | Justice was associated with dharma; maintaining dharma, a just social order, was a primary duty of kings |
| China: Confucius | Kings should maintain justice by punishing wrongdoers and rewarding the virtuous |
| Athens, fourth century BC: Plato | In The Republic, examined through a dialogue why we should be concerned about justice |
Socrates' argument for being just (our summary)
- Challenge The unjust seem to prosper if they are not caught.
- Imagine everyone unjust All twist rules for themselves.
- Result No one can be sure of benefiting; nobody is secure; all are harmed.
- Conclusion Being just is in our long-term interest; justice means the well-being of all, giving each his due.
Justice concerns how a society distributes social goods and duties. In the modern view, influenced by Kant's idea of human dignity, it means giving every person due and equal consideration, including the chance to develop their talents and pursue their goals.
'Giving each his due': two understandings
-
Plato's Socrates
- Just ruler cares for well-being of all, like a doctor
- Each person receives what is due within a just order
-
Modern view (Kant)
- Every human being has dignity
- Due to each: opportunity to develop talents and pursue goals
- Equal consideration for all individuals
Key takeaways: justice, like love, is understood intuitively, but it concerns the ordering of public life and the distribution of social goods and duties, so it is central to politics. Ancient India linked justice to dharma, Confucius to punishing wrong and rewarding virtue, and Plato's Socrates argued that justice serves everyone's long-term interest and means the well-being of all. 'Giving each his due' now rests on human dignity (Kant): equal consideration and the opportunity to develop one's talents.