- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Appointment and removal of judges and the structure of the judiciary
Explain how the Chief Justice of India and other judges are appointed and how the role of the senior judges evolved, the procedure and grounds for removing a judge, and the single integrated, pyramid-shaped structure of courts.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the convention for appointing the Chief Justice of India and the evolution of consultation for other judges.
- State the grounds and procedure for removing a Supreme Court or High Court judge.
- Describe the single integrated judicial system and the role of each level of courts.
Who sits in the Supreme Court and the High Courts makes a difference to how the Constitution is interpreted. Judges' views, for instance about an active and assertive judiciary or a more restrained one, affect the fate of laws. So appointments have never been free from political controversy: the chapter notes that the Council of Ministers, Governors, Chief Ministers and the Chief Justice of India all influence them.
Appointing the Chief Justice of India
Over the years a convention developed that the senior-most judge of the Supreme Court is appointed Chief Justice of India (CJI). According to the textbook, this convention was broken twice, in 1973 and 1975, when judges were appointed CJI by superseding more senior judges.
Appointing other judges
Other judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts are appointed by the President after 'consulting' the CJI. Since the President acts on ministerial advice, this in effect left the final decision with the Council of Ministers. What, then, was the status of consultation with the CJI? The question came before the Supreme Court repeatedly between 1982 and 1998:
- At first the Court held that the CJI's role was purely consultative.
- Then it held that the CJI's opinion must be followed by the President.
- Finally it suggested a novel procedure: the CJI should recommend names in consultation with the four senior-most judges of the Court, establishing the principle of collegiality.
Thus, as the textbook describes it, the decision of the group of senior Supreme Court judges carries greater weight in appointments, and both the Supreme Court and the Council of Ministers play important roles.
How consultation on appointments evolved (as described in the textbook)
- Constitution's text President appoints after 'consulting' the CJI; in effect the Council of Ministers decides.
- First view CJI's role is purely consultative.
- Second view CJI's opinion must be followed.
- Collegiality CJI recommends names in consultation with the four senior-most judges.
Removal of judges
A judge of the Supreme Court or a High Court can be removed only on the ground of proven misbehaviour or incapacity. A motion containing the charges must be approved by a special majority in both Houses of Parliament. Removal is therefore very difficult and impossible without a general consensus among MPs. Note the balance: the executive plays a crucial role in appointment, while the legislature holds the power of removal. This ensures both balance of power and judicial independence.
The chapter records that only one case of removing a Supreme Court judge has come before Parliament. In that case, begun in 1991, an inquiry by Supreme Court judges found serious misconduct, and the motion won two-thirds of those present and voting, but it did not get the support of a majority of the total membership of the House, so the judge was not removed. This shows how demanding the special-majority requirement is.
Structure of the judiciary
The Constitution provides a single integrated judicial system. Unlike some other federal countries, India does not have separate State courts. The structure is a pyramid: the Supreme Court at the top, High Courts below it, and district and subordinate courts at the bottom. Lower courts work under the direct superintendence of higher courts.
| Level | Main powers described in the chapter |
|---|---|
| Supreme Court | Its decisions bind all courts; can transfer High Court judges; can move cases from any court to itself; can transfer cases between High Courts |
| High Court | Hears appeals from lower courts; issues writs to restore Fundamental Rights; deals with cases within the State's jurisdiction; superintends courts below it |
| District Court | Deals with cases arising in the district; hears appeals from lower courts; decides serious criminal cases |
| Subordinate courts | Consider civil and criminal cases |
Single integrated judiciary
-
Supreme Court
- Top of the pyramid
- Binding on all courts
-
High Courts
- Appeals and writs
- Superintend lower courts
-
District Courts
- District cases and appeals
- Serious criminal offences
-
Subordinate Courts
- Civil and criminal cases
Judges are removed only for proven misbehaviour or incapacity, by a special majority in both Houses. The executive has a key role in appointment, the legislature in removal. India has one integrated pyramid of courts with the Supreme Court at the top.
Worked example 1: will the judge be removed?
A made-up House has 500 members. In a removal motion, 330 members are present and voting, and 230 vote in favour. Working: two-thirds of 330 = 220, and 230 exceeds it, so condition (i) is met. A majority of total membership requires more than 250 (more than half of 500), and 230 falls short, so condition (ii) fails. The motion fails in this House, and the judge is not removed. This mirrors the only real case in the chapter.
Worked example 2: who decides this case?
(a) A theft case in a town. (b) An appeal against a district court's judgment. (c) A request to move a case from one High Court to another. Answers: (a) a subordinate court; (b) the High Court; (c) the Supreme Court, which can transfer cases between High Courts.
Worked example 3: separate State courts?
A student assumes that, as a federation, India must have separate State and federal courts, as some federations do. Correction: India's Constitution creates a single integrated judiciary. High Courts and lower courts in the States are part of the same pyramid headed by the Supreme Court, whose decisions bind them all.
Key takeaways: by convention the senior-most Supreme Court judge becomes CJI, though the convention was broken twice. Other judges are appointed by the President after consulting the CJI; between 1982 and 1998 the Supreme Court moved from a consultative role to collegiality, with the CJI recommending names with the four senior-most judges, according to the textbook. Removal requires proven misbehaviour or incapacity and a special majority in both Houses. Courts form a single integrated pyramid.
Check your understanding
-
1. By convention, who is appointed Chief Justice of India?
- The youngest judge of the Supreme Court
- The senior-most judge of the Supreme Court
- The Attorney General
- The Chief Justice of the largest High Court
Show answer
Answer: B. A convention developed of appointing the senior-most judge of the Supreme Court as CJI, though the textbook notes it was broken twice.
-
2. On what grounds can a judge of the Supreme Court or a High Court be removed?
- Delivering judgments against the government
- Reaching the age of 55
- Loss of confidence of the Lok Sabha
- Proven misbehaviour or incapacity
Show answer
Answer: D. The only grounds are proven misbehaviour or incapacity, and the motion must be approved by a special majority in both Houses.
-
3. What principle did the Supreme Court establish when it suggested that the CJI recommend names in consultation with the four senior-most judges?
- Seniority
- Judicial review
- Collegiality
- Separation of powers
Show answer
Answer: C. By requiring the CJI to consult the four senior-most judges before recommending names, the Court established the principle of collegiality, according to the textbook.
-
4. Assertion (A): In the only removal case of a Supreme Court judge before Parliament, the judge was not removed. Reason (R): The motion got two-thirds of those present and voting but not the support of a majority of the total membership of the House.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: a special majority needs both conditions, and failing the total-membership condition meant the motion failed.
-
5. Which of the following is a power of the Supreme Court in the integrated judiciary?
- Issuing writs only to district courts
- Deciding only criminal cases
- Transferring cases from one High Court to another
- Hearing only cases within one State
Show answer
Answer: C. The Supreme Court can transfer cases between High Courts, move cases to itself and transfer High Court judges; its decisions bind all courts.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.