• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Judicial activism and Public Interest Litigation

Explain how Public Interest Litigation emerged around 1979, how it expanded access to courts and the idea of rights, and weigh the positive and negative effects of judicial activism described in the chapter.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain how PIL changed the rule that only an aggrieved person can approach a court.
  • Describe the early PIL cases and how PIL expanded rights for the poor and for society.
  • Evaluate the positive effects and the criticisms of judicial activism.

Two terms are often heard in discussions of the judiciary: judicial activism and Public Interest Litigation (PIL). Many people think they have revolutionised the functioning of the judiciary and made it more people-friendly. The chief instrument of judicial activism in India is PIL, also called Social Action Litigation (SAL).

From personal grievance to public interest

Normally, a person can approach the courts only if he or she is personally aggrieved: someone whose rights have been violated or who is party to a dispute. This changed around 1979, when the Supreme Court decided to hear a case filed not by the aggrieved persons but by others on their behalf. Because it involved an issue of public interest, such cases came to be called public interest litigation. Around the same time the Court took up the rights of prisoners. This opened the door for public-spirited citizens and voluntary organisations to seek judicial help to protect existing rights, improve the living conditions of the poor, protect the environment and much more. The judiciary, traditionally confined to cases brought before it, began considering cases on the basis of newspaper reports and postal complaints, so the term judicial activism became popular.

Early PILs

  • Hussainara Khatoon vs. Bihar (1979): newspaper reports showed that many undertrial prisoners in Bihar had spent longer in jail than the punishment for their alleged offences would have been. An advocate filed a petition, and the Supreme Court heard it; it became one of the earliest PILs.
  • Sunil Batra vs. Delhi Administration (1980): a prisoner sent a scribbled note to a Supreme Court judge describing torture of prisoners, and the judge converted it into a petition. The Court later stopped treating letters as petitions, but this case was one of the pioneers of PIL.

How PIL expanded rights

First, the Court expanded the idea of rights: clean air, unpolluted water and decent living are rights of the whole society, so individuals as members of society should be able to seek justice when they are violated. Second, the judiciary became ready to consider the rights of those who cannot easily approach the courts, allowing public-spirited citizens, social organisations and lawyers to petition on behalf of the needy and deprived. In a 1984 case, a judge observed, in substance, that the problems of the poor are different in kind and need a different judicial approach, since a strictly adversarial procedure would never let them enforce their rights. Through such cases the courts took up the blinding of jail inmates by police, inhuman conditions in stone quarries, sexual exploitation of children and similar matters, making the right against exploitation meaningful for the poor.

Effects of judicial activism

  • Positive effects
    • Democratised the judiciary: groups as well as individuals gain access
    • Forced executive accountability
    • Made rights meaningful for the poor and disadvantaged
    • Helped make elections freer and fairer
  • Concerns
    • Overburdened the courts
    • Blurred the line between judiciary and the other organs
    • Courts deciding questions that belong to the executive
    • Strains on the balance among the three organs

Impact on the political system

Judicial activism has democratised the judicial system by giving access to groups, not just individuals; it has forced executive accountability; and it has tried to make elections freer and fairer. For example, the Court asked candidates to file affidavits stating their assets, income and educational qualifications, so that voters could choose on the basis of accurate knowledge.

The other side

The chapter also notes a negative side. First, the large number of PILs has overburdened the courts. Second, judicial activism has blurred the line between the executive and legislature on one hand and the judiciary on the other. Courts have become involved in questions that belong to the executive: reducing air or noise pollution, investigating corruption or bringing about electoral reform are matters for the administration under legislative supervision. Some therefore feel that judicial activism has made the balance among the three organs very delicate. Democratic government depends on each organ respecting the powers of the others, and activism may strain this principle. In the Constituent Assembly, Alladi Krishnaswami Ayyar had warned, in substance, that independence should not become a dogma allowing the judiciary to act as a super-legislature or super-executive.

PIL lets public-spirited persons approach the courts on behalf of others in matters of public interest. It has widened access to justice and the meaning of rights, but critics say it overburdens courts and blurs the separation of powers.

Worked example 1: is it a PIL?

(a) A trader sues a supplier for not delivering goods. (b) A voluntary organisation files a petition about children working in hazardous quarries, though none of its members works there. Reasoning: (a) is ordinary litigation by a personally aggrieved party. (b) is a PIL: the petitioner is not personally aggrieved but acts on behalf of others in the public interest, which became possible after 1979.

Worked example 2: you are the judge

A made-up group of citizens files a PIL asking the city to remove slums to beautify the city and attract investment. Slum residents reply that removal would violate their right to life. Reasoning a judge might follow: PIL is meant to protect rights, especially of those who cannot easily reach the courts. The Supreme Court has read the right to shelter and livelihood into the right to life. A 'public interest' that would take away the means of living of a large section of the public is doubtful. A balanced judgment might refuse simple removal and ask the authorities to consider rehabilitation and the residents' rights.

Worked example 3: activism or overreach?

A made-up court orders the city transport department to change the fuel used by all buses within a year. Evaluation: supporters would say the court is protecting the right to clean air of all residents when the executive has failed to act. Critics would say the choice of fuel and timetable is a policy matter for the executive under legislative supervision, and the court's order blurs the separation of powers. The chapter presents both views.

Key takeaways: since about 1979, PIL has let others approach the courts on behalf of the aggrieved, with early cases on undertrials and prisoners' torture. It has widened rights to include clean air, water and decent living and given the poor access to justice. Judicial activism has democratised the judiciary, forced executive accountability and promoted fairer elections, but it has also overburdened courts and blurred the line between the organs of government.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Before the emergence of PIL, who could normally approach the courts?

    1. Anyone at all
    2. Only a person who was personally aggrieved
    3. Only government officials
    4. Only lawyers
    Show answer

    Answer: B. In the normal course of law, a person could approach the courts only if personally aggrieved; PIL changed this around 1979.

  2. 2. Around which year did the Supreme Court begin to hear cases filed by others on behalf of aggrieved persons, setting the trend of PIL?

    1. 1950
    2. 1967
    3. 1979
    4. 1993
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter states that the concept changed around 1979, when the Court heard a case filed not by the aggrieved persons but by others on their behalf.

  3. 3. Which of the following is mentioned in the chapter as a step taken through judicial activism to make elections freer and fairer?

    1. Abolishing the Election Commission
    2. Fixing the date of elections
    3. Banning all political parties
    4. Asking candidates to file affidavits about their assets, income and educational qualifications
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Court asked candidates to file affidavits on assets, income and educational qualifications, so voters could choose with accurate knowledge.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Some people feel that judicial activism has strained the balance among the three organs of government. Reason (R): Courts have become involved in questions, such as reducing pollution or investigating corruption, that belong to the executive under legislative supervision.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: by deciding matters that belong to the other organs, activism blurs the separation of powers, straining the balance.

  5. 5. Which of the following is a criticism of judicial activism mentioned in the chapter?

    1. It has reduced access to courts
    2. It has overburdened the courts
    3. It has stopped protecting the poor
    4. It has made the judiciary dependent on the executive
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter notes that the large number of PILs has overburdened the courts and that activism has blurred the lines between the organs; the other options contradict the chapter.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery