- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Why we need an independent judiciary
Explain the rule of law and the role of the judiciary, what independence of the judiciary means and does not mean, and the constitutional measures that protect it.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the rule of law and the principal role of the judiciary.
- State the three elements of judicial independence and explain why independence does not mean lack of accountability.
- List the constitutional measures that secure the independence of the judiciary.
Courts are often seen only as arbitrators of disputes between private parties, but the judiciary also performs political functions. It is an important organ of government; the chapter calls the Supreme Court of India one of the very powerful courts in the world. Since 1950 the judiciary has played an important role in interpreting and protecting the Constitution and the rights it guarantees.
Rule of law and the role of the judiciary
Disputes are bound to arise between individuals, between groups, and between individuals or groups and the government. All must be settled by an independent body according to the rule of law: the idea that all individuals, rich or poor, men or women, of any caste, are subject to the same law. The principal role of the judiciary is to protect the rule of law and ensure the supremacy of law. It safeguards individual rights, settles disputes according to law, and ensures that democracy does not give way to the dictatorship of an individual or group. To do this, it must be independent of political pressures.
What independence means
- The executive and legislature must not restrain the judiciary's functioning in a way that prevents it from doing justice.
- The other organs should not interfere with the judiciary's decisions.
- Judges must be able to perform their functions without fear or favour.
Independence does not mean arbitrariness or absence of accountability. The judiciary is part of the country's democratic political structure, and so it is accountable to the Constitution, to democratic traditions and to the people.
How the Constitution protects independence
| Measure | How it protects independence |
|---|---|
| Legislature not involved in appointments | It was believed that party politics would then play no role in appointing judges |
| Qualifications | A judge must have experience as a lawyer and/or be well versed in law; political opinions or loyalty should not count |
| Fixed tenure | Judges hold office until the retirement age and can be removed only in exceptional cases, so they can act without fear or favour |
| Difficult removal | The Constitution prescribes a very difficult procedure, giving security of office |
| Financial independence | Salaries and allowances of judges are not subject to the legislature's approval |
| Contempt of court | Courts can penalise those guilty of contempt, protecting judges from unfair criticism |
| No discussion of conduct in Parliament | Parliament cannot discuss judges' conduct except during proceedings to remove a judge |
Independence of the judiciary
-
Appointment
- No role for the legislature
- Legal experience and knowledge required
-
Tenure
- Hold office till retirement age
- Removal only by a very difficult procedure
-
Finance
- Salaries not voted by the legislature
-
Protection from criticism
- Power to punish contempt
- Conduct not discussed in Parliament except in removal
-
But accountable to
- Constitution
- Democratic traditions
- The people
Independence of the judiciary: the other organs must not restrain or interfere with it, and judges must decide without fear or favour; it is secured by appointment without the legislature, security of tenure, financial independence and the contempt power, but it is not freedom from accountability.
Worked example 1: which measure is at work?
Identify the safeguard in each made-up case. (a) A State legislature wants to cut a High Court judge's salary after an unpopular ruling. (b) A newspaper prints a false claim that a judge was bribed, and the court acts against it. (c) A judge who decided against the government continues in office until retirement. Answers: (a) salaries are not subject to legislative approval, so the cut is not possible; (b) the contempt power protects judges from unfair criticism; (c) security of tenure.
Worked example 2: odd one out
Which of these is NOT a way of ensuring judicial independence? (i) Judges are generally not removed before retirement age. (ii) Parliament has no say in appointing judges. (iii) A High Court judge cannot be transferred to another High Court. (iv) Salaries are not voted by the legislature. Reasoning: (i), (ii) and (iv) are safeguards described in the chapter. (iii) is false: the Supreme Court can transfer High Court judges, as the next lesson shows. So (iii) is the odd one out.
Worked example 3: is an independent judge unaccountable?
A student argues that because judges cannot be easily removed, they answer to no one. Evaluation: independence protects judges from pressure by the other organs, but judges are still bound by the Constitution and laws, by democratic traditions such as reasoned public judgments, and ultimately by the people; a judge can be removed for proven misbehaviour or incapacity. So the claim is incorrect.
Key takeaways: the judiciary protects the rule of law, under which everyone is subject to the same law, safeguards rights and prevents dictatorship. Independence means freedom from restraint and interference by other organs and the ability to decide without fear or favour, but it comes with accountability to the Constitution, democratic traditions and the people. It is secured by the method of appointment, qualifications, security of tenure, a difficult removal procedure, financial independence, the contempt power and limits on parliamentary discussion of judges.
Check your understanding
-
1. What does the rule of law imply, according to the chapter?
- The ruler makes all laws
- Laws apply only to citizens who vote
- Judges are above the law
- All individuals, rich or poor, of any caste or gender, are subject to the same law
Show answer
Answer: D. The rule of law means all individuals are subjected to the same law; protecting it and ensuring the supremacy of law is the judiciary's principal role.
-
2. Which of the following is NOT an element of judicial independence as described in the chapter?
- Other organs must not restrain the judiciary from doing justice
- Other organs should not interfere with its decisions
- Judges must work without fear or favour
- Judges are not accountable to anyone
Show answer
Answer: D. Independence does not imply absence of accountability: the judiciary is accountable to the Constitution, democratic traditions and the people.
-
3. How does the Constitution give the judiciary financial independence?
- Judges collect court fees as salary
- The salaries and allowances of judges are not subject to the approval of the legislature
- Judges are paid by the President personally
- Judges' salaries are fixed by the Election Commission
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter states that the salaries and allowances of judges are not subject to legislative approval, so the judiciary does not depend financially on the other organs.
-
4. Assertion (A): The judiciary has the power to punish those guilty of contempt of court. Reason (R): This power is seen as an effective protection for judges against unfair criticism.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the contempt power exists to protect judges and their decisions from unfair personal criticism, supporting their independence.
-
5. When can Parliament discuss the conduct of a judge?
- At any time during Question Hour
- Only during the budget session
- Only when a proceeding to remove the judge is being carried out
- Never, under any circumstances
Show answer
Answer: C. Parliament cannot discuss the conduct of judges except when a proceeding to remove a judge is under way.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.