• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Judicial review, rights and the judiciary's relationship with Parliament

Explain how the Supreme Court protects rights through writs and judicial review, the grounds on which laws can be struck down, and the long conflict between Parliament and the judiciary that led to the basic structure doctrine.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the two ways the judiciary remedies violations of rights, with the relevant Articles.
  • Define judicial review and state the two grounds on which a law can be struck down.
  • Trace the conflict between Parliament and the judiciary up to the Kesavananda Bharati case and identify unresolved issues.

The judiciary protects individual rights and interprets the Constitution. This lesson brings those roles together and then looks at the judiciary's sometimes tense relationship with Parliament.

Two ways to remedy violations of rights

  1. The Supreme Court can restore Fundamental Rights by issuing writs such as habeas corpus and mandamus (Article 32); the High Courts have similar writ powers (Article 226).
  2. The Supreme Court can declare a law unconstitutional and therefore non-operational (Article 13).

Together these make the Supreme Court both the protector of Fundamental Rights and the interpreter of the Constitution. The second way involves judicial review.

Judicial review

Perhaps the most important power of the Supreme Court is judicial review: the power of the Supreme Court (or High Courts) to examine the constitutionality of any law. If the Court concludes that a law is inconsistent with the Constitution, it declares the law unconstitutional and inapplicable. The term 'judicial review' appears nowhere in the Constitution; the power is implicit in the fact that India has a written Constitution and that the Court can strike down laws that go against Fundamental Rights.

Judicial review can be used on two grounds: a law may be struck down because it violates Fundamental Rights, or because it violates the federal distribution of powers. For example, if a central law, in some States' view, deals with a State List subject, the States can go to the Supreme Court, which may declare it unconstitutional. The review power covers laws passed by State legislatures too. Together with the writ power, judicial review makes the judiciary very powerful, and PILs have added further to its role in protecting rights. The chapter also notes that South Africa's constitution includes public interest litigation in its bill of rights.

Grounds for striking down a law by judicial review

  • Violation of Fundamental Rights
    • Law inconsistent with Part III
    • Declared void under Article 13
  • Violation of federal distribution of powers
    • Union law on a State List matter
    • State law on a Union List matter
  • Applies to
    • Laws of Parliament
    • Laws of State legislatures

Judiciary and Parliament

The courts have also tried to prevent subversion of the Constitution through political practice, bringing areas once thought beyond review, such as certain powers of the President and Governor, under judicial scrutiny, and giving directions to investigating agencies in some cases. The Constitution rests on a delicate principle of limited separation of powers and checks and balances: Parliament is supreme in making laws and amending the Constitution, the executive in implementing them, and the judiciary in settling disputes and deciding whether laws conform to the Constitution. Yet conflict between Parliament and the judiciary has been a recurring theme.

Soon after the Constitution came into force, Parliament wanted to restrict the right to property to implement land reforms. The Court held that Parliament could not restrict Fundamental Rights this way, and when Parliament amended the Constitution, the Court said that even an amendment could not abridge a Fundamental Right. The central questions were: the scope of the right to private property; the scope of Parliament's power to curtail Fundamental Rights; the scope of its power to amend the Constitution; and whether it could abridge Fundamental Rights while enforcing Directive Principles. Between 1967 and 1973 the controversy became very serious, extending to land reform, preventive detention, reservations in jobs, acquisition of property and compensation.

The Kesavananda Bharati case (1973)

In 1973 the Supreme Court gave the decision that has regulated relations between Parliament and the judiciary ever since. In the Kesavananda Bharati case, it ruled that there is a basic structure of the Constitution that nobody, not even Parliament through an amendment, can violate. It did two more things: it held that the right to property was not part of the basic structure and so could be suitably abridged; and it reserved to itself the right to decide which matters are part of the basic structure. The chapter calls this perhaps the best example of how the judiciary uses its power to interpret the Constitution. The later removal of the right to property from the Fundamental Rights also changed the nature of the relationship.

Parliament and the judiciary: a timeline
PeriodKey development described in the chapter
Early 1950sConflict over restricting property rights for land reform; Court says even amendments cannot abridge Fundamental Rights
1967 to 1973Conflict intensifies over land reform, preventive detention, reservations and compensation for acquired property
1973Kesavananda Bharati: basic structure cannot be violated; property not part of it; Court decides what is basic structure
LaterRight to property removed from Fundamental Rights; relationship changes

Issues still unresolved

Some issues remain potential sources of conflict. Can the judiciary intervene in and regulate the functioning of legislatures? A legislature can punish a person for breach of its privileges, but can that person seek the courts' protection? Can a member disciplined by the legislature get relief from the court? The Constitution says judges' conduct cannot be discussed in Parliament, yet legislatures have at times cast aspersions on the judiciary, and the judiciary has criticised legislatures and issued instructions on legislative business, which legislatures see as violating parliamentary sovereignty. The chapter concludes that democracy depends on a delicate balance and on each organ respecting the authority of the others, all within the limits set by the Constitution.

Judicial review: the power of the Supreme Court and High Courts to strike down laws, of Parliament or of the States, that violate Fundamental Rights or the federal distribution of powers. Kesavananda Bharati (1973): Parliament cannot amend the basic structure, and the Court decides what that structure includes.

Worked example 1: writ or judicial review?

(a) Police detain a person without legal grounds; the Court orders his release. (b) A State passes a law banning newspapers from criticising the government; the Court declares the law void. Reasoning: (a) uses the writ power (habeas corpus) to restore a right in a specific case. (b) uses judicial review to strike down a law inconsistent with freedom of speech. The writ acts on an action; judicial review acts on a law.

Worked example 2: which ground?

A made-up Union law regulates a subject that is clearly in the State List, and a State challenges it. Reasoning: the Court would apply judicial review on the ground of the federal distribution of powers, not Fundamental Rights. If it agrees, it declares the law unconstitutional. The challenge would come under its original jurisdiction, since it is a Union-State dispute.

Worked example 3: can Parliament amend this?

A made-up amendment seeks to abolish judicial review entirely. Reasoning using the Kesavananda Bharati principle: Parliament can amend the Constitution, but not its basic structure, and the Court decides what belongs to that structure. An amendment removing the courts' power to test laws against the Constitution would very likely be challenged as violating the basic structure. Contrast the right to property, which the Court held was not part of the basic structure.

Key takeaways: the Supreme Court remedies violations of rights by writs (Articles 32 and 226) and by striking down laws (Article 13). Judicial review, implicit in a written Constitution, tests laws of Parliament and State legislatures against Fundamental Rights and the federal division of powers. Conflict with Parliament over property and amendment powers, intense between 1967 and 1973, was largely settled by Kesavananda Bharati's basic structure doctrine, though issues such as privileges remain.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which Article allows the Supreme Court to declare a law unconstitutional and non-operational for violating Fundamental Rights, as cited in the chapter?

    1. Article 13
    2. Article 32
    3. Article 226
    4. Article 144
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter cites Article 13 for declaring a law unconstitutional. Articles 32 and 226 concern writs by the Supreme Court and High Courts; Article 144 requires authorities to aid the Supreme Court.

  2. 2. Which statement about judicial review is correct?

    1. The term is clearly stated in the Constitution
    2. It is implicit in a written Constitution and the Court's power to strike down laws that violate Fundamental Rights
    3. It applies only to laws made by Parliament
    4. It allows courts to make new laws
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Judicial review is not named in the Constitution but is implicit; it applies to laws of Parliament and State legislatures.

  3. 3. On which two grounds can a law be struck down through judicial review, according to the chapter?

    1. Violation of Fundamental Rights or of the federal distribution of powers
    2. Unpopularity or high cost
    3. Violation of Directive Principles or Fundamental Duties
    4. Being passed in a joint session or by voice vote
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The review power covers laws that violate Fundamental Rights and laws that violate the distribution of powers between the Union and the States.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): After the Kesavananda Bharati case, Parliament cannot amend the basic structure of the Constitution. Reason (R): In that case the Court ruled that the right to property was part of the basic structure.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The assertion is true. The reason is false: the Court held that the right to property was not part of the basic structure and could be suitably abridged.

  5. 5. Which of the following is described in the chapter as an unresolved issue between the legislature and the judiciary?

    1. Whether India has a single integrated judiciary
    2. Whether the President is elected indirectly
    3. Whether money bills begin in the Lok Sabha
    4. Whether a person punished by the legislature for breach of privilege can seek the protection of the courts
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter names questions about legislative privileges and the courts' power to intervene in legislatures as unresolved; the other options are settled provisions.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Judiciary

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery