• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court

Explain the original, writ, appellate and advisory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court and its special leave power, and how Articles 137 and 144 show its power and the unified nature of the judiciary.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain original jurisdiction and why it makes the Supreme Court an umpire in federal disputes.
  • Distinguish writ, appellate and advisory jurisdiction and state the utility of advisory opinions.
  • Explain what Articles 137 and 144 say about the Supreme Court's powers.

The Supreme Court is one of the most powerful courts anywhere, yet it works within limits set by the Constitution, which defines its functions. Its scope of powers is called its jurisdiction.

Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court

  • Original
    • Disputes between the Union and States
    • Disputes among States
  • Writ
    • Habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari, quo warranto
    • To protect Fundamental Rights
  • Appellate
    • Appeals in civil, criminal and constitutional cases
  • Advisory
    • Advice to the President on matters of public importance and law
  • Special powers
    • Special leave to appeal against any judgment of any court in India

Original jurisdiction

Original jurisdiction means cases that go directly to the Supreme Court without first going to lower courts. Cases involving federal relations, that is disputes between the Union and the States and among States, go straight to it. In any federation such disputes are bound to arise, and the Supreme Court acts as the umpire. It is called original jurisdiction because only the Supreme Court can deal with these cases; neither High Courts nor lower courts can. In doing so it not only settles disputes but also interprets the powers of the Union and States under the Constitution.

Writ jurisdiction

Any individual whose Fundamental Right is violated can directly move the Supreme Court. The Court can issue special orders called writs. The High Courts can also issue writs, and the person has the choice of approaching either the High Court or the Supreme Court directly. Through writs the Court can order the executive to act or not to act in a particular way.

Appellate jurisdiction

The Supreme Court is the highest court of appeal. A person can appeal against a High Court's decision, but the High Court must certify that the case is fit for appeal, meaning it involves a serious question of interpretation of law or the Constitution. In criminal cases where a lower court has passed a death sentence, an appeal can be made to the High Court or Supreme Court. The Supreme Court can also decide to admit appeals even when the High Court has not allowed one (its special leave power). On appeal, the Court reconsiders the case and its legal issues; if it thinks the law or the Constitution has a different meaning from what lower courts understood, it changes the ruling and gives a new interpretation. High Courts too have appellate jurisdiction over courts below them.

Advisory jurisdiction

The President can refer to the Supreme Court any matter of public importance or involving interpretation of the Constitution for its advice. However, the Supreme Court is not bound to give advice, and the President is not bound to accept it. Its utility is two-fold: the government can obtain legal opinion before acting, which may prevent unnecessary litigation later; and in light of the advice, it can make suitable changes in its actions or laws.

Comparing the jurisdictions
JurisdictionWho brings the matterTypical matterIs the outcome binding?
OriginalUnion or StatesFederal disputes between Union and States or among StatesYes
WritAny person whose Fundamental Right is violatedRestoring a Fundamental RightYes
AppellateA party dissatisfied with a lower court's decisionAppeals in civil, criminal and constitutional casesYes
AdvisoryThe PresidentMatter of public importance or constitutional interpretationNo: the Court need not advise and the President need not accept

Articles 137 and 144: the Court's authority

Article 137 gives the Supreme Court power to review any judgment or order it has made. Article 144 says that all authorities, civil and judicial, in India shall act in aid of the Supreme Court. Together these show the unified judiciary and the Court's powers: its decisions bind all other courts in India, its orders are enforceable throughout the country, but it is not bound by its own decisions and can review them at any time. In a case of contempt of the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court itself decides.

Original: federal disputes, only in the Supreme Court. Writ: Fundamental Rights, also in High Courts. Appellate: highest court of appeal. Advisory: on the President's reference; neither giving nor accepting advice is compulsory. Its decisions bind all courts, but it may review its own.

Worked example 1: name the jurisdiction

Match each made-up situation to a jurisdiction. (a) Two States dispute the sharing of a river's water. (b) The government asks whether a proposed law on citizenship of certain residents would be constitutional. (c) People evicted from a dam site appeal against a High Court judgment. (d) A detained person's relative asks the Court to order his production before it. Answers: (a) original; (b) advisory; (c) appellate; (d) writ (habeas corpus).

Worked example 2: is the advice binding?

The President refers a legal question to the Supreme Court; the Court gives its opinion, and the government partly disagrees. Reasoning: under advisory jurisdiction, the President is not bound to accept the advice, and the Court was not even bound to give it. But the opinion helps the government avoid later litigation and adjust its laws, which is its practical value.

Worked example 3: can the Court change its own ruling?

A made-up ruling of the Supreme Court is later found to rest on a mistaken reading of a statute. Reasoning: under Article 137, the Supreme Court can review any judgment or order it has made, because it is not bound by its own decisions. Lower courts, by contrast, must follow its decisions until it changes them.

Key takeaways: the Supreme Court has original jurisdiction over federal disputes (only it can hear them), writ jurisdiction to protect Fundamental Rights (shared with High Courts), appellate jurisdiction as the highest court of appeal (with special leave power), and advisory jurisdiction on the President's reference (not binding either way). Its decisions bind all courts, all authorities must act in its aid (Article 144), and it can review its own judgments (Article 137).

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A dispute between the Union government and a State government is heard by the Supreme Court under its:

    1. writ jurisdiction
    2. appellate jurisdiction
    3. advisory jurisdiction
    4. original jurisdiction
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Disputes between the Union and States, and among States, go directly to the Supreme Court under its original jurisdiction; no other court can hear them.

  2. 2. Which statement about the Supreme Court's advisory jurisdiction is correct?

    1. The Court must give advice and the President must accept it
    2. The Court is not bound to give advice and the President is not bound to accept it
    3. The Court must give advice but the President need not accept it
    4. Advice can be sought by any citizen
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The President may refer matters to the Court, but the Court is not bound to give advice and the President is not bound to accept it.

  3. 3. A person whose Fundamental Right is violated wants a writ. Which courts can he or she approach?

    1. Only the district court
    2. Only the Supreme Court
    3. Only the High Court
    4. Either the High Court or directly the Supreme Court
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Both the Supreme Court (Article 32) and the High Courts (Article 226) can issue writs, and the person may choose either.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): The Supreme Court can change its own earlier ruling. Reason (R): Under Article 137, the Supreme Court has the power to review any judgment or order made by it.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: Article 137 gives the Court power to review its own judgments, so it is not bound by its earlier decisions.

  5. 5. What does Article 144 provide?

    1. The Supreme Court shall review its judgments
    2. The President can seek the Court's advice
    3. All authorities, civil and judicial, in India shall act in aid of the Supreme Court
    4. Judges' salaries are not voted
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 144 says that all civil and judicial authorities in India shall act in aid of the Supreme Court, which shows its authority and the unified judiciary.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery