| Measure | How it protects independence |
|---|---|
| Legislature not involved in appointments | It was believed that party politics would then play no role in appointing judges |
| Qualifications | A judge must have experience as a lawyer and/or be well versed in law; political opinions or loyalty should not count |
| Fixed tenure | Judges hold office until the retirement age and can be removed only in exceptional cases, so they can act without fear or favour |
| Difficult removal | The Constitution prescribes a very difficult procedure, giving security of office |
| Financial independence | Salaries and allowances of judges are not subject to the legislature's approval |
| Contempt of court | Courts can penalise those guilty of contempt, protecting judges from unfair criticism |
| No discussion of conduct in Parliament | Parliament cannot discuss judges' conduct except during proceedings to remove a judge |
Independence of the judiciary
-
Appointment
- No role for the legislature
- Legal experience and knowledge required
-
Tenure
- Hold office till retirement age
- Removal only by a very difficult procedure
-
Finance
- Salaries not voted by the legislature
-
Protection from criticism
- Power to punish contempt
- Conduct not discussed in Parliament except in removal
-
But accountable to
- Constitution
- Democratic traditions
- The people
Independence of the judiciary: the other organs must not restrain or interfere with it, and judges must decide without fear or favour; it is secured by appointment without the legislature, security of tenure, financial independence and the contempt power, but it is not freedom from accountability.
Key takeaways: the judiciary protects the rule of law, under which everyone is subject to the same law, safeguards rights and prevents dictatorship. Independence means freedom from restraint and interference by other organs and the ability to decide without fear or favour, but it comes with accountability to the Constitution, democratic traditions and the people. It is secured by the method of appointment, qualifications, security of tenure, a difficult removal procedure, financial independence, the contempt power and limits on parliamentary discussion of judges.