Revision notes

Chapter 6 Judiciary: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Why we need an independent judiciary

Constitutional safeguards for judicial independence
MeasureHow it protects independence
Legislature not involved in appointmentsIt was believed that party politics would then play no role in appointing judges
QualificationsA judge must have experience as a lawyer and/or be well versed in law; political opinions or loyalty should not count
Fixed tenureJudges hold office until the retirement age and can be removed only in exceptional cases, so they can act without fear or favour
Difficult removalThe Constitution prescribes a very difficult procedure, giving security of office
Financial independenceSalaries and allowances of judges are not subject to the legislature's approval
Contempt of courtCourts can penalise those guilty of contempt, protecting judges from unfair criticism
No discussion of conduct in ParliamentParliament cannot discuss judges' conduct except during proceedings to remove a judge

Independence of the judiciary

  • Appointment
    • No role for the legislature
    • Legal experience and knowledge required
  • Tenure
    • Hold office till retirement age
    • Removal only by a very difficult procedure
  • Finance
    • Salaries not voted by the legislature
  • Protection from criticism
    • Power to punish contempt
    • Conduct not discussed in Parliament except in removal
  • But accountable to
    • Constitution
    • Democratic traditions
    • The people

Independence of the judiciary: the other organs must not restrain or interfere with it, and judges must decide without fear or favour; it is secured by appointment without the legislature, security of tenure, financial independence and the contempt power, but it is not freedom from accountability.

Key takeaways: the judiciary protects the rule of law, under which everyone is subject to the same law, safeguards rights and prevents dictatorship. Independence means freedom from restraint and interference by other organs and the ability to decide without fear or favour, but it comes with accountability to the Constitution, democratic traditions and the people. It is secured by the method of appointment, qualifications, security of tenure, a difficult removal procedure, financial independence, the contempt power and limits on parliamentary discussion of judges.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Appointment and removal of judges and the structure of the judiciary

How consultation on appointments evolved (as described in the textbook)

  1. Constitution's text President appoints after 'consulting' the CJI; in effect the Council of Ministers decides.
  2. First view CJI's role is purely consultative.
  3. Second view CJI's opinion must be followed.
  4. Collegiality CJI recommends names in consultation with the four senior-most judges.
The pyramid of courts
LevelMain powers described in the chapter
Supreme CourtIts decisions bind all courts; can transfer High Court judges; can move cases from any court to itself; can transfer cases between High Courts
High CourtHears appeals from lower courts; issues writs to restore Fundamental Rights; deals with cases within the State's jurisdiction; superintends courts below it
District CourtDeals with cases arising in the district; hears appeals from lower courts; decides serious criminal cases
Subordinate courtsConsider civil and criminal cases

Single integrated judiciary

  • Supreme Court
    • Top of the pyramid
    • Binding on all courts
  • High Courts
    • Appeals and writs
    • Superintend lower courts
  • District Courts
    • District cases and appeals
    • Serious criminal offences
  • Subordinate Courts
    • Civil and criminal cases

Judges are removed only for proven misbehaviour or incapacity, by a special majority in both Houses. The executive has a key role in appointment, the legislature in removal. India has one integrated pyramid of courts with the Supreme Court at the top.

Key takeaways: by convention the senior-most Supreme Court judge becomes CJI, though the convention was broken twice. Other judges are appointed by the President after consulting the CJI; between 1982 and 1998 the Supreme Court moved from a consultative role to collegiality, with the CJI recommending names with the four senior-most judges, according to the textbook. Removal requires proven misbehaviour or incapacity and a special majority in both Houses. Courts form a single integrated pyramid.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court

Jurisdiction of the Supreme Court

  • Original
    • Disputes between the Union and States
    • Disputes among States
  • Writ
    • Habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari, quo warranto
    • To protect Fundamental Rights
  • Appellate
    • Appeals in civil, criminal and constitutional cases
  • Advisory
    • Advice to the President on matters of public importance and law
  • Special powers
    • Special leave to appeal against any judgment of any court in India
Comparing the jurisdictions
JurisdictionWho brings the matterTypical matterIs the outcome binding?
OriginalUnion or StatesFederal disputes between Union and States or among StatesYes
WritAny person whose Fundamental Right is violatedRestoring a Fundamental RightYes
AppellateA party dissatisfied with a lower court's decisionAppeals in civil, criminal and constitutional casesYes
AdvisoryThe PresidentMatter of public importance or constitutional interpretationNo: the Court need not advise and the President need not accept

Original: federal disputes, only in the Supreme Court. Writ: Fundamental Rights, also in High Courts. Appellate: highest court of appeal. Advisory: on the President's reference; neither giving nor accepting advice is compulsory. Its decisions bind all courts, but it may review its own.

Key takeaways: the Supreme Court has original jurisdiction over federal disputes (only it can hear them), writ jurisdiction to protect Fundamental Rights (shared with High Courts), appellate jurisdiction as the highest court of appeal (with special leave power), and advisory jurisdiction on the President's reference (not binding either way). Its decisions bind all courts, all authorities must act in its aid (Article 144), and it can review its own judgments (Article 137).

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Judicial activism and Public Interest Litigation

Effects of judicial activism

  • Positive effects
    • Democratised the judiciary: groups as well as individuals gain access
    • Forced executive accountability
    • Made rights meaningful for the poor and disadvantaged
    • Helped make elections freer and fairer
  • Concerns
    • Overburdened the courts
    • Blurred the line between judiciary and the other organs
    • Courts deciding questions that belong to the executive
    • Strains on the balance among the three organs

PIL lets public-spirited persons approach the courts on behalf of others in matters of public interest. It has widened access to justice and the meaning of rights, but critics say it overburdens courts and blurs the separation of powers.

Key takeaways: since about 1979, PIL has let others approach the courts on behalf of the aggrieved, with early cases on undertrials and prisoners' torture. It has widened rights to include clean air, water and decent living and given the poor access to justice. Judicial activism has democratised the judiciary, forced executive accountability and promoted fairer elections, but it has also overburdened courts and blurred the line between the organs of government.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Judicial review, rights and the judiciary's relationship with Parliament

Grounds for striking down a law by judicial review

  • Violation of Fundamental Rights
    • Law inconsistent with Part III
    • Declared void under Article 13
  • Violation of federal distribution of powers
    • Union law on a State List matter
    • State law on a Union List matter
  • Applies to
    • Laws of Parliament
    • Laws of State legislatures
Parliament and the judiciary: a timeline
PeriodKey development described in the chapter
Early 1950sConflict over restricting property rights for land reform; Court says even amendments cannot abridge Fundamental Rights
1967 to 1973Conflict intensifies over land reform, preventive detention, reservations and compensation for acquired property
1973Kesavananda Bharati: basic structure cannot be violated; property not part of it; Court decides what is basic structure
LaterRight to property removed from Fundamental Rights; relationship changes

Judicial review: the power of the Supreme Court and High Courts to strike down laws, of Parliament or of the States, that violate Fundamental Rights or the federal distribution of powers. Kesavananda Bharati (1973): Parliament cannot amend the basic structure, and the Court decides what that structure includes.

Key takeaways: the Supreme Court remedies violations of rights by writs (Articles 32 and 226) and by striking down laws (Article 13). Judicial review, implicit in a written Constitution, tests laws of Parliament and State legislatures against Fundamental Rights and the federal division of powers. Conflict with Parliament over property and amendment powers, intense between 1967 and 1973, was largely settled by Kesavananda Bharati's basic structure doctrine, though issues such as privileges remain.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery