- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Centre-State relations, demands for autonomy, Governors and President's rule
Trace how centre-State relations changed with the political process, explain the four kinds of autonomy demands, and analyse the controversies over the role of Governors and the use of Article 356.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the three phases of centre-State relations described in the chapter.
- Explain the four kinds of autonomy demands with the chapter's examples.
- Explain Article 356, the Governor's role and why they became controversial, including the Sarkaria Commission's recommendation.
The Constitution recognises the separate identity of the regions and yet gives more power to the centre. Once the identity of the States is accepted, it is natural for them to expect a greater role in governing themselves and the country. This produces demands and tensions. Legal disputes can go to the judiciary, but demands for autonomy are political and must be resolved through negotiation.
The Constitution as a skeleton
The chapter calls the Constitution a framework or skeleton whose flesh and blood is provided by the actual political process. So Indian federalism has been shaped by changing politics:
| Phase | Political situation | Centre-State relations |
|---|---|---|
| 1950s and early 1960s | Foundation laid under Nehru; one party dominant at the centre and in the States | Largely normal except over the formation of new States; States optimistic about central grants and development policies |
| Mid-1960s onwards | One-party dominance declined; opposition parties came to power in many States | Demands for greater powers and autonomy; States protested what they saw as central interference |
| Since the 1990s | Era of coalition politics at the centre; national and regional parties in power in States | Greater say for States, respect for diversity, the beginning of a more mature federalism |
Demands for autonomy
Many States and parties have demanded more autonomy, but autonomy means different things to different States:
- Division of powers: changing the division of powers in favour of the States and giving them more and more important powers. The chapter mentions demands of this kind from States such as Tamil Nadu, Punjab and West Bengal at various times.
- Financial autonomy: independent sources of revenue and greater control over resources. In 1977 the West Bengal government brought out a document demanding a restructuring of centre-State relations.
- Administrative autonomy: States resent central control over the administrative machinery.
- Cultural and linguistic autonomy: for example, opposition to the domination of Hindi in Tamil Nadu, or demands to advance the Punjabi language and culture. In the 1960s there were agitations in some States against the imposition of Hindi. Even in the Constituent Assembly, Nehru had appealed to Hindi-speaking provinces to show greater tolerance towards others.
Four kinds of autonomy demands
-
Powers
- More and more important subjects for States
-
Finance
- Independent revenue sources
- Control over resources
-
Administration
- Less central control over officials
-
Culture and language
- Resistance to linguistic domination
- Promotion of regional language and culture
Note the difference between autonomy and secession: autonomy is a demand for more powers within the federation; secession is a demand to leave it.
The Governor's role
The Governor's role has always been controversial between the States and the centre. The Governor is not elected; many Governors have been retired military officers, civil servants or politicians. Because the Governor is appointed by the central government, his or her actions are often seen as central interference, especially when different parties rule at the centre and in the State. The Sarkaria Commission, appointed by the central government in 1983 to examine centre-State relations (it reported in 1988), recommended that appointments of Governors be strictly non-partisan.
Article 356: President's rule
Article 356 provides for President's rule in a State when a situation has arisen in which the government of the State cannot be carried on in accordance with the Constitution. It results in the Union government taking over the State government. The President's proclamation must be ratified by Parliament, and President's rule can be extended up to three years. The Governor can recommend the dismissal of the State government and the suspension or dissolution of the Assembly. This has led to many conflicts. In some cases State governments were dismissed even when they had a majority, as in Kerala in 1959, or without testing their majority, as happened in several States after 1967. The chapter notes that Article 356 was used sparingly until 1967 but more often afterwards, when different parties ruled at the centre and in many States, and that the office of Governor was sometimes used to keep a majority party or coalition from taking office. Some cases reached the Supreme Court, which ruled that the constitutional validity of imposing President's rule can be examined by the judiciary.
Article 356: President's rule when a State's government cannot be carried on according to the Constitution; Parliament must ratify it; it can last up to three years; the courts can examine its validity. The Sarkaria Commission (1983-88) urged strictly non-partisan Governors.
Worked example 1: a fit case for President's rule?
Consider made-up situations. (a) Different parties rule at the centre and in the State and are bitter rivals. (b) No party wins a majority in a State election, and there are fears that MLAs may be bribed. (c) A State government openly refuses to obey a Supreme Court decision in an inter-State water dispute. Reasoning: (a) is not a breakdown of constitutional government; political rivalry is normal in a federation. (b) calls first for an attempt to form a government and test its majority in the House, not immediate President's rule. (c) is the strongest case, since refusing to follow the Constitution's highest court suggests the State government is not being carried on according to the Constitution. Any proclamation would still need Parliament's ratification and could be examined by the courts.
Worked example 2: classify the demand
Classify each made-up demand. (i) 'Give States a larger share of tax revenue.' (ii) 'Move agriculture-related industries to the State List.' (iii) 'Let the State decide transfers of senior officers.' (iv) 'Do not impose any one language on our schools.' Answers: (i) financial; (ii) division of powers; (iii) administrative; (iv) cultural and linguistic.
Worked example 3: why is the Governor controversial?
Reasoning from the chapter: the Governor is appointed by the centre, not elected; Governors have often been former politicians or officials; and the Governor's powers to recommend President's rule and to reserve bills can be used against a State government run by an opposing party. Hence the Sarkaria Commission's call for strictly non-partisan appointments.
Key takeaways: centre-State relations changed with politics: normal under one-party dominance, tense after the mid-1960s, and more mature in the coalition era since the 1990s. Autonomy demands concern powers, finance, administration, and culture and language. The Governor, appointed by the centre, and Article 356 have been the most controversial parts of the system; President's rule needs parliamentary ratification, can last up to three years and is subject to judicial review.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the chapter, how should demands for autonomy, as distinct from legal disputes, be resolved?
- Only by the Supreme Court
- By the Governor alone
- By imposing President's rule
- Through negotiations, since they are political
Show answer
Answer: D. Legal disputes can be resolved by the judiciary, but demands for autonomy are political in nature and need to be resolved through negotiations.
-
2. Which kind of autonomy demand is a demand for independent sources of revenue and greater control over resources?
- Cultural autonomy
- Administrative autonomy
- Financial autonomy
- Linguistic autonomy
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter calls the demand for independent revenue sources and control over resources financial autonomy; the 1977 West Bengal document is an example.
-
3. What did the Sarkaria Commission recommend about Governors?
- That appointments of Governors be strictly non-partisan
- That the office be abolished
- That Governors be directly elected
- That Governors be chosen by the Chief Minister alone
Show answer
Answer: A. The Sarkaria Commission (appointed 1983, reported 1988) recommended that appointments of Governors should be strictly non-partisan.
-
4. Assertion (A): The Supreme Court can examine the constitutional validity of a decision to impose President's rule. Reason (R): President's rule under Article 356 has to be ratified by Parliament.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: B. Both statements are true according to the chapter, but R does not explain A: parliamentary ratification is a separate safeguard. Judicial examination follows from the Court's rulings on cases that came before it.
-
5. For how long can President's rule be extended, according to the chapter?
- Six months only
- Up to three years
- Five years
- One year
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter states that President's rule can be extended till three years, with the proclamation ratified by Parliament.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.