• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

What federalism is and why its practice matters

Explain the key ideas of federalism, why some federations broke up while India stayed united, and what the cases of the West Indies and Nigeria teach about trust and cooperation among units.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the key features of a federal system: two levels of government, dual identities, a written supreme constitution and an independent judiciary.
  • Explain why adopting a federal constitution alone does not guarantee unity.
  • Draw lessons from the West Indies and Nigeria cases described in the chapter.

Since 1947 the political map of India has changed many times: the boundaries, names and number of States have changed, often according to the wishes of their people (for instance, Mysore became Karnataka and Madras became Tamil Nadu). These changes tell the story of federalism in India. This chapter asks what federalism is, how the Constitution organises it, and what tensions arise in practice.

Federations that did not stay united

The USSR, once a superpower, broke up after 1989 into several independent countries. The chapter says a major reason was excessive centralisation and concentration of power, and the domination of Russia over regions with their own languages and cultures. Czechoslovakia, Yugoslavia and Pakistan also faced division, and Canada came close to a break-up between its English- and French-speaking regions. All of these were federations. So it is a great achievement that India, born in 1947 after a painful partition, has remained united for over seven decades. The lesson the chapter draws: besides adopting a federal constitution, the nature of the federal system and the practice of federalism matter.

India's diversity

India is a land of continental size and immense diversity: many major languages and hundreds of minor ones, several major religions, and millions of indigenous people. Yet Indians share a common land, a common history, especially the freedom struggle, and many other features. So national leaders saw India as a country of unity in diversity, sometimes described as unity with diversity.

Key ideas of federalism

Federalism is not a fixed set of principles applied everywhere in the same way; American, German and Indian federalism differ. But some key ideas are common:

  1. Federalism is an institutional mechanism to accommodate two sets of polities: one at the regional level and one at the national level. Each government is autonomous in its own sphere. Some federations even have dual citizenship; India has single citizenship.
  2. People have two sets of identities and loyalties: to their region and to the nation. Each level has distinct powers and responsibilities and a separate system of government.
  3. The details are set out in a written constitution, which is supreme and is the source of power of both governments. Subjects concerning the whole nation, such as defence or currency, belong to the union; regional or local matters belong to the States.
  4. An independent judiciary settles legal disputes between the centre and the States about the division of powers.

Key features of a federation

  • Two levels of government
    • National
    • Regional (States)
    • Each autonomous in its own sphere
  • Dual identity
    • Belong to region and nation
  • Written, supreme constitution
    • Source of power of both levels
    • Divides subjects
  • Independent judiciary
    • Settles centre-State disputes

But the actual working of a federation depends on real politics, culture, ideology and history. A culture of trust, cooperation, mutual respect and restraint helps federations work smoothly. If any single unit, linguistic group or ideology comes to dominate the whole federation, deep resentment can arise, leading to demands for secession or even civil war.

Case box: the West Indies

Like India, the West Indies was colonised by the British. In 1958 a federation of the West Indies was formed, with a weak central government and economically independent units. These features and competition among the units led to its dissolution in 1962. Later, in 1973, the independent islands set up joint authorities, a common legislature, a supreme court, a common currency and to a degree a common market, known as the Caribbean Community, which even has a common executive of the member governments' heads. The chapter's comment: the units could neither live together as one country nor live completely separately.

Case box: Nigeria

Until 1914, Northern and Southern Nigeria were separate British colonies. At the Ibadan Constitutional Conference of 1950, Nigerian leaders chose a federal constitution. The three major ethnic groups controlled different regions, and their attempts to extend influence into other regions led to fear, conflict and eventually military rule. Though democracy was restored in 1999, religious differences and conflicts over control of oil revenues continued to trouble the federation, as the textbook describes it. Nigeria shows how an overlap of religious, ethnic and economic differences among units, combined with distrust, can make even a federal arrangement fail to produce unity.

Lessons from other federations in the chapter
CaseWhat went wrongLesson
USSRExcessive centralisation; domination of one regionToo strong a centre can break a federation
West IndiesWeak centre; independent unit economies; competition among unitsToo weak a centre can also fail
NigeriaDistrust among ethnic regions; religious and resource conflictsFederal institutions need trust to work

Federalism accommodates two levels of government, each autonomous in its sphere, under a written supreme constitution with an independent judiciary to settle disputes. Whether it holds a country together depends on its design and on a political culture of trust, cooperation and restraint.

Worked example 1: is it federal?

A made-up country has one government that can abolish its provinces' councils whenever it likes; the councils have no constitutional powers. Reasoning: there are not two autonomous levels of government guaranteed by a supreme constitution, so the country is not federal, even though it has provinces. Contrast India, where both the union and State governments have constitutional status and defined spheres.

Worked example 2: dual identity

A made-up student says she is 'a Keralite and an Indian'. Reasoning: this illustrates the dual identity and loyalty that federalism accommodates: belonging to a region and to the nation. Note that India still has a single citizenship; the dual identity is cultural and political, not two citizenships.

Worked example 3: too strong or too weak?

Match each made-up federation to the case it most resembles. Federation A: a centre with almost no money or powers whose units compete with each other. Federation B: a centre that controls everything and lets one region dominate the languages of others. Answers: A resembles the West Indies federation of 1958-62; B resembles the chapter's account of the USSR. Both show that balance between centre and units matters.

Key takeaways: federalism accommodates national and regional governments, each autonomous in its sphere, with people holding dual identities, under a written supreme constitution and an independent judiciary. India has single citizenship. Several federations broke up or nearly did; the chapter concludes that the design and practice of federalism, especially trust, cooperation and restraint, matter as much as the constitution itself.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the chapter, what was a major reason for the break-up of the USSR?

    1. Too many elections
    2. Dual citizenship
    3. A weak central government
    4. Excessive centralisation and the domination of one region over others
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says excessive centralisation and concentration of power, and Russia's domination over regions with their own languages and cultures, were major reasons.

  2. 2. Which of the following is true of India's federal system?

    1. India has dual citizenship
    2. India has a single citizenship
    3. Indian States have their own citizenship only
    4. India has no citizenship law
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Some federations have dual citizenship, but the chapter notes that India has only a single citizenship.

  3. 3. In a federation, who settles legal disputes between the centre and the States about the division of powers?

    1. The army
    2. The largest State
    3. An independent judiciary
    4. The central executive alone
    Show answer

    Answer: C. An independent judiciary has the power to resolve legal disputes between the central government and the States about the division of powers.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Adopting a federal constitution does not by itself guarantee that a country will stay united. Reason (R): Several countries that were federations, such as the USSR and Yugoslavia, still broke up.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R supports A: these federations broke up despite federal constitutions, which shows that the nature and practice of federalism also matter.

  5. 5. What does the West Indies case show, as described in the chapter?

    1. A strong centre always holds units together
    2. Dual citizenship causes break-ups
    3. Federalism is impossible for islands
    4. A federation with a weak centre and competing, economically independent units dissolved, yet the units still needed joint institutions
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The West Indies federation (1958-62) had a weak centre and competing units and was dissolved; later the islands formed joint authorities in the Caribbean Community, showing they could neither live together fully nor fully apart.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery