• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Federalism in the Indian Constitution and the division of powers

Explain how the Constituent Assembly chose a federation based on cooperation, why Article 1 calls India a Union of States, and how the Union, State and Concurrent Lists and residuary powers divide legislative power.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the background to India's federal design and its emphasis on cooperation and unity.
  • Interpret Article 1 and explain the two sets of government created by the Constitution.
  • Classify subjects into the Union, State and Concurrent Lists and explain residuary powers and financial centralisation.

Even before independence, most national leaders knew that governing a country as large as India required dividing powers between the provinces and the centre, and that India's regional and linguistic diversity needed recognition. In a democracy, people of each region should govern themselves and share power. The real question was how much power the regional governments should have.

From compromise to cooperation

Before Partition, in view of the Muslim League's agitation for greater representation of Muslims, a compromise formula giving very large powers to the regions was discussed. Once Partition was decided, the Constituent Assembly chose a government based on unity and cooperation between the centre and the States, with separate powers for the States. The most important feature of India's federal system is the principle that centre-State relations would be based on cooperation. So, while recognising diversity, the Constitution emphasised unity.

Article 1: a Union of States

The Constitution does not even use the word 'federation'. Article 1 says that India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States, and that the States and their territories are specified in the First Schedule. The Constitution creates two sets of government: the union (central) government for the whole nation, and a State government for each State. Both have constitutional status and clearly identified areas of activity. Disputes about which powers belong to whom can be resolved by the judiciary on the basis of the Constitution.

Division of powers: three lists

How the Constitution divides legislative subjects
ListExample subjects given in the chapterWho makes laws
Union ListDefence, atomic energy, foreign affairs, war and peace, banking, railways, post and telegraph, airways, ports, foreign trade, currency and coinageUnion legislature alone
State ListAgriculture, police, prisons, local government, public health, land, liquor, trade and commerce within the State, livestock and animal husbandry, State public servicesNormally only the State legislature
Concurrent ListEducation, transfer of property other than agricultural land, forests, trade unions, adulteration, adoption and successionBoth the Union and State legislatures
Residuary powersAll matters not in any list, for example cyber lawsUnion legislature alone

Division of legislative powers

  • Union List
    • Defence
    • Foreign affairs
    • Currency
    • Railways
  • State List
    • Police
    • Agriculture
    • Public health
    • Local government
  • Concurrent List
    • Education
    • Forests
    • Trade unions
    • Adoption and succession
  • Residuary
    • Matters in no list
    • Union legislates, e.g. cyber laws

Financial centralisation

An important aspect of the division of powers is that economic and financial powers are centralised in the hands of the central government. The States have immense responsibilities but very meagre revenue sources. A cartoon voice in the chapter compares this to a household where one member holds all the money and another must run the house. This imbalance is a recurring source of tension, as later lessons show.

Article 1: India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States. Powers are divided by the Union, State and Concurrent Lists; residuary powers go to the Union; financial powers are concentrated at the centre while States carry large responsibilities.

Worked example 1: which list?

Classify each subject. (a) Railways. (b) Police. (c) Education. (d) A new subject, such as regulating a technology not foreseen in any list. (e) Currency and coinage. (f) Trade unions. Answers: (a) Union List; (b) State List; (c) Concurrent List; (d) residuary, so the Union legislates; (e) Union List; (f) Concurrent List.

Worked example 2: why mention residuary powers?

A student asks why the Constitution needs a separate rule for residuary powers. Reasoning: no list can foresee every future subject. Without a rule, every new subject would trigger a dispute between the centre and the States. By giving residuary powers to the Union, as in the chapter's example of cyber laws, the Constitution settles such questions in advance. (Recall from Chapter 1 that the idea of residuary powers was adapted from the Canadian Constitution.)

Worked example 3: who resolves the dispute?

A made-up State claims that a new central law deals with agriculture, a State List subject. Reasoning: both governments have constitutional status, so the question of who holds the power is legal. The judiciary, specifically the Supreme Court under its original jurisdiction, resolves it on the basis of the lists in the Constitution.

Key takeaways: after Partition, the Constituent Assembly chose a federation built on unity and centre-State cooperation. Article 1 calls India a Union of States; the word 'federation' is not used. Union and State governments both have constitutional status. Legislative subjects are divided into the Union, State and Concurrent Lists, with residuary powers for the Union. Financial powers are centralised, while States have large responsibilities and limited revenue.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. How does Article 1 of the Constitution describe India?

    1. As a federation of autonomous provinces
    2. As a confederation of States
    3. India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States
    4. As a unitary republic without States
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 1 says that India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States; the Constitution does not use the word federation.

  2. 2. Which of the following subjects is in the Concurrent List, according to the chapter?

    1. Defence
    2. Education
    3. Police
    4. Currency and coinage
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Education is in the Concurrent List. Defence and currency are Union List subjects; police is a State List subject.

  3. 3. Who has the power to make laws on residuary matters, such as cyber laws?

    1. The Supreme Court
    2. State legislatures alone
    3. Both together
    4. The Union legislature alone
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Residuary powers cover all matters not in any list, and the Union legislature alone can legislate on them.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): States in India often feel dissatisfied with the division of powers. Reason (R): Economic and financial powers are centralised, while the States have immense responsibilities but meagre revenue sources.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the gap between the States' responsibilities and their limited revenue sources is a key reason for dissatisfaction.

  5. 5. What was the most important feature of the federal system adopted after Partition, according to the chapter?

    1. Very large powers for the regions
    2. No division of powers at all
    3. Relations between the States and the centre based on cooperation, with emphasis on unity
    4. Separate constitutions for each State
    Show answer

    Answer: C. After Partition, the Assembly chose unity and cooperation between centre and States, with separate powers for the States; cooperation is the most important feature.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery