• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

New States, inter-State disputes and special provisions

Trace the creation of linguistic and other new States, explain border and river-water disputes between States, and describe the special provisions for some States, including the north-east and Jammu and Kashmir as the textbook describes them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Trace the reorganisation of States from the States Reorganisation Commission to the States created in 2000 and 2014.
  • Explain why border and river-water disputes are political as well as legal.
  • Describe the special provisions for certain States as described in the textbook.

Federalism in India has also been shaped by demands for new States, by disputes between States, and by special arrangements for States with distinctive histories. The chapter treats these as signs of the tensions, and the flexibility, of the Indian federation.

Demands for new States

The national movement created pan-Indian unity but also strengthened unity around common language, region and culture, and it was a movement for democracy. So during the national movement it was decided that, as far as possible, States would be created on the basis of common cultural and linguistic identity. After independence this led to demands for linguistic States.

Reorganisation of States
YearDevelopment described in the chapter
December 1953States Reorganisation Commission set up; recommended linguistic States, at least for major linguistic groups
1956Reorganisation of some States; beginning of linguistic States
1960Gujarat and Maharashtra created
1966Punjab and Haryana separated
LaterNorth-east reorganised: Manipur, Tripura, Meghalaya, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh created
2000Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand created from Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh and Bihar
2014Telangana formed by dividing Andhra Pradesh

The divisions of 2000 were made both to meet demands for separate States and for greater administrative efficiency, showing that language is not the only basis on which States have been formed.

Inter-State conflicts

Besides disputes with the centre, States have disputes with one another. The judiciary arbitrates legal disputes, but these disputes have political implications and are best resolved through negotiation and mutual understanding. Two types recur:

  1. Border disputes. Although language defines State boundaries, border areas often have people speaking more than one language, so a linguistic majority alone cannot settle them. The chapter's examples include the long-standing dispute between Maharashtra and Karnataka over Belgaum, a Manipur-Nagaland border dispute, and the Punjab-Haryana dispute over border areas and the capital city of Chandigarh, which houses the capitals of both States.
  2. River-water disputes. The chapter says these are even more serious than border disputes, which are more about sentiment, because they concern drinking water and agriculture. Its examples are the Kaveri (Cauvery) dispute between Tamil Nadu and Karnataka, which reached the Supreme Court though there is a river water tribunal, and the dispute among Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh and Maharashtra over the Narmada.

Two kinds of inter-State dispute

  • Border disputes
    • Claims over territory of a neighbouring State
    • Mixed-language border areas
    • More about sentiment
    • Example in the chapter: Belgaum
  • River-water disputes
    • Sharing a river's water
    • Affect drinking water and agriculture
    • More serious, test cooperation
    • Examples in the chapter: Kaveri, Narmada

Special provisions

The most extraordinary feature of India's federal arrangement, the chapter says, is that many States receive differential (asymmetric) treatment. We saw one example in the Rajya Sabha, where representation is asymmetrical by population, while smaller States get a minimum. The division of powers is common to all States, yet the Constitution makes special provisions for some States because of their particular social and historical circumstances. Most apply to the north-eastern States (such as Assam, Nagaland, Arunachal Pradesh and Mizoram) because of their sizeable indigenous tribal populations with distinct histories and cultures; the chapter notes that these provisions have not been able to stem alienation and insurgency in parts of the region. Special provisions also exist for hill States like Himachal Pradesh and for some other States, such as Andhra Pradesh, Goa, Gujarat, Maharashtra, Sikkim and Telangana.

Jammu and Kashmir, as described in the textbook

The textbook explains that Jammu and Kashmir, a large princely state, had the option of joining India or Pakistan or remaining independent; after tribal infiltrators were sent from Pakistan's side in October 1947, its ruler sought India's help and acceded to the Indian Union. Under Article 370 it was given greater autonomy: the State's concurrence was required for laws on matters in the Union and Concurrent Lists, though over time large parts of the Constitution were applied to it with the State government's concurrence. According to the textbook, this special status no longer exists: under the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019, the State was reorganised into two Union Territories, Jammu and Kashmir, and Ladakh, with effect from 31 October 2019.

Conclusion of the chapter

The chapter compares federalism to a rainbow, in which each colour is separate yet together they form a harmonious pattern. Federalism must continually balance the centre and the States, and no legal formula can guarantee smooth working. Ultimately people and the political process must develop mutual trust, toleration and cooperation. National unity cannot be built by flattening differences; forced unity breeds strife. Only a polity responsive to diversity and to demands for autonomy can be the basis of a cooperative federation.

States were reorganised mainly on linguistic lines from 1956, and later also for administrative efficiency (2000, 2014). Border and river-water disputes are legal and political, best settled by negotiation. Asymmetric federalism gives special provisions to some States, especially in the north-east.

Worked example 1: basis for a new State

Which basis does the chapter's history support for forming States: common language, common economic interests, common religion, or administrative convenience? Reasoning: the national movement decided that States should be formed, as far as possible, on common cultural and linguistic identity, which guided reorganisation from 1956. The 2000 divisions also cited administrative efficiency. Religion was never a basis, in keeping with the Constitution's secular character. So language and administrative convenience both have support in the chapter.

Worked example 2: why negotiation?

Two made-up States dispute the sharing of a river. The Supreme Court can interpret agreements and laws. Reasoning: farmers and cities in both States depend on the water, so any decision has political consequences, and a State unhappy with a ruling may resist it. The chapter therefore argues that such disputes are best resolved through negotiation and mutual understanding, with courts and tribunals as the legal mechanisms.

Worked example 3: would merging Hindi-speaking States fit federalism?

Suppose a proposal says that, since most people in several northern States speak Hindi, they should become one State. Evaluation: federalism values self-government by regions and administrative efficiency, not language alone. One giant State could be hard to administer, would ignore distinct regional histories and identities, and could upset the balance among States. The 2000 reorganisation actually divided large States for efficiency. So the proposal would not be in tune with the chapter's idea of federalism.

Key takeaways: linguistic reorganisation began with the States Reorganisation Commission (1953) and the 1956 reorganisation, followed by Gujarat and Maharashtra (1960), Punjab and Haryana (1966), new north-eastern States, three new States in 2000 and Telangana in 2014. Border and river-water disputes between States are political as well as legal. The Constitution makes special provisions for several States, especially in the north-east; the textbook records that the special status of Jammu and Kashmir under Article 370 no longer exists. Federalism depends on trust, toleration and cooperation.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. When was the States Reorganisation Commission set up, according to the chapter?

    1. August 1947
    2. November 1956
    3. January 1950
    4. December 1953
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter states that the States Reorganisation Commission was set up in December 1953 and recommended linguistic States; reorganisation took place in 1956.

  2. 2. Which States were created in 2000?

    1. Gujarat, Maharashtra and Haryana
    2. Mizoram, Meghalaya and Tripura
    3. Telangana, Goa and Sikkim
    4. Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand
    Show answer

    Answer: D. In 2000 Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh and Bihar were divided to create Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand.

  3. 3. Why does the chapter consider river-water disputes more serious than border disputes?

    1. Because rivers cross international borders
    2. Because they relate to drinking water and agriculture in the States concerned
    3. Because only the President can decide them
    4. Because border disputes never reach the courts
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Border disputes are more about sentiment, while river-water disputes concern drinking water and agriculture, which makes them more serious.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Most special provisions in the Constitution pertain to the north-eastern States. Reason (R): These States have sizeable indigenous tribal populations with a distinct history and culture.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the chapter links the special provisions for the north-east to their large tribal populations with distinct history and culture.

  5. 5. To what does the chapter compare federalism in its conclusion?

    1. A ladder
    2. A pyramid
    3. A rainbow
    4. A machine
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says federalism is like a rainbow, where each colour is separate, yet together they make a harmonious pattern.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Federalism

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery