- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Federalism with a strong central government
Explain why the framers created a strong centre and list the constitutional provisions that make the Indian federation centralised, from Parliament's power over State boundaries to emergency, financial and administrative powers.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Give the two concerns, unity and development, that led to a strong centre.
- List and explain the provisions that strengthen the central government.
- Explain how Article 257 and the All India Services give the centre influence over State administration.
It is generally accepted that the Indian Constitution created a strong central government. The framers wanted a federal constitution that would accommodate diversity, but they also wanted a strong centre for two reasons.
Why a strong centre?
- Unity. At independence India was not only divided into British-made provinces; there were more than 500 princely states to be integrated into existing States or formed into new ones. A strong centre was needed to stem disintegration and bring about social and political change.
- Development. Poverty, illiteracy and inequalities of wealth needed planning and coordination by a strong central government working with the States.
In the Constituent Assembly, T.T. Krishnamachari observed, in substance, that in all constitutions the drift had been towards the centre, because States had become welfare states and responsibility for the country's economic well-being had become the centre's paramount duty. This is a paraphrase.
Provisions that create a strong centre
| Provision | How it strengthens the centre |
|---|---|
| Parliament's power over States' existence | Parliament can form a new State by separating territory or uniting States, and alter a State's boundary or name; the concerned State legislature's view is sought as a safeguard |
| Emergency provisions | During an emergency, power becomes lawfully centralised, and Parliament can make laws on State subjects |
| Financial powers | Revenue-generating items are under the centre; States depend largely on central grants and assistance; the centre uses its discretion in grants and loans |
| Planning | Planning after independence centralised economic decision-making; a Planning Commission appointed by the Union government coordinated and supervised resource management, as the textbook describes |
| Governor | Can recommend dismissal of the State government and dissolution of the Assembly; can reserve a State bill for the President's assent, letting the centre delay or veto it |
| Legislating on the State List | Parliament can make laws on State List matters if the Rajya Sabha approves |
| Superior executive power | Union executive power is superior; under Article 257 the Union can give directions to States |
| All India Services | IAS and IPS officers serving States are under central control; States cannot discipline or remove them |
| Articles 33 and 34 | Parliament can protect persons in Union or State service for actions taken during martial law to maintain or restore order |
Article 257
Article 257(1) says, in substance, that the executive power of every State must be exercised so as not to impede or prejudice the executive power of the Union, and that the Union's executive power extends to giving directions to a State as the Government of India finds necessary for that purpose. The chapter cites this to show that the centre's executive powers are superior to those of the States.
Financial dependence and charges of discrimination
Even in normal times, the centre has very effective financial powers. Because the centre controls the main sources of revenue and decides on many grants and loans, the distribution of resources is considered lopsided by critics, and the chapter notes it has led to charges of discrimination against States ruled by parties opposed to the party at the centre.
Sources of central dominance
-
Territorial
- Parliament can create States, change boundaries and names
-
Emergency
- Power lawfully centralised
- Parliament legislates on State subjects
-
Financial
- Main revenues with the centre
- Grants, loans, planning
-
Legislative and executive
- Governor can reserve State bills
- Rajya Sabha route to State List
- Article 257 directions
-
Administrative
- All India Services under central control
India is a federation with a strong centre: Parliament controls the existence and boundaries of States, emergencies centralise power, the centre holds the main revenues, Governors can reserve State bills, Article 257 lets the Union direct States, and All India Services officers answer to the centre.
Worked example 1: unitary bias in action
Identify the central power in each made-up case. (a) Parliament merges two districts of one State into a new State. (b) A State bill on land is sent by the Governor to the President, who withholds assent. (c) The Union directs a State not to obstruct the building of a national highway. (d) A State wants to dismiss an IPS officer but cannot. Answers: (a) Parliament's power over States' existence and boundaries; (b) the Governor's power to reserve bills; (c) Article 257 directions; (d) central control over the All India Services.
Worked example 2: dependence on grants
A made-up State needs ₹100 crore for its schools and hospitals in a year but can raise only ₹40 crore from its own taxes. Working: the gap is 100 − 40 = ₹60 crore, so 60 per cent of the spending depends on transfers from the centre. This illustrates the chapter's point that States have immense responsibilities but meagre revenue sources, which makes them dependent on central grants and assistance.
Worked example 3: does a strong centre make States weak?
Discussion: a strong centre helped integrate over 500 princely states and plan development, which the framers saw as necessary. But if central powers are used to interfere in States' own spheres, States feel weakened and demand autonomy. The chapter's view is that the balance depends on how powers are used in practice, which the next lesson explores.
Key takeaways: the framers created a strong centre out of concern for unity, amid the integration of over 500 princely states, and for development through planning. Parliament controls the formation and boundaries of States; emergency provisions centralise power; the centre holds the main revenues; the Governor can reserve State bills; Parliament can legislate on State subjects with Rajya Sabha approval; Article 257 lets the Union direct States; and All India Services officers are under central control.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which two concerns, according to the chapter, prompted the framers to create a strong central government?
- Defence and foreign trade
- Elections and judiciary
- Religion and language
- Unity and development
Show answer
Answer: D. The concern for unity, including integrating over 500 princely states, and for development through planning led the framers to create a strong centre.
-
2. Who has the power to form a new State or change the boundary or name of a State?
- The State legislature alone
- Parliament
- The Governor
- The Supreme Court
Show answer
Answer: B. Parliament is empowered to form new States, alter boundaries and change names; the view of the concerned State legislature is sought as a safeguard.
-
3. What does Article 257(1) provide, as cited in the chapter?
- States may ignore Union directions
- A State's executive power must not impede the Union's, and the Union may give directions to States
- Each State has its own army
- The Governor is elected by the State
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 257(1) requires States to exercise executive power so as not to impede the Union's, and allows the Union to give directions to States for that purpose.
-
4. Assertion (A): The Governor's power to reserve State bills strengthens the central government. Reason (R): A reserved bill goes to the President, giving the centre an opportunity to delay, examine and even veto it.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because a reserved bill goes to the President (acting on central advice), the centre gains a say over State legislation.
-
5. Under what condition can Parliament make laws on a subject in the State List in normal times, as described in the chapter?
- If the Supreme Court orders it
- If any one State agrees
- If the Rajya Sabha ratifies the move
- It can never do so
Show answer
Answer: C. Parliament can legislate on State List matters if the move is ratified by the Rajya Sabha; during an emergency it can also do so.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.