Revision notes

Chapter 7 Federalism: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What federalism is and why its practice matters

Key features of a federation

  • Two levels of government
    • National
    • Regional (States)
    • Each autonomous in its own sphere
  • Dual identity
    • Belong to region and nation
  • Written, supreme constitution
    • Source of power of both levels
    • Divides subjects
  • Independent judiciary
    • Settles centre-State disputes
Lessons from other federations in the chapter
CaseWhat went wrongLesson
USSRExcessive centralisation; domination of one regionToo strong a centre can break a federation
West IndiesWeak centre; independent unit economies; competition among unitsToo weak a centre can also fail
NigeriaDistrust among ethnic regions; religious and resource conflictsFederal institutions need trust to work

Federalism accommodates two levels of government, each autonomous in its sphere, under a written supreme constitution with an independent judiciary to settle disputes. Whether it holds a country together depends on its design and on a political culture of trust, cooperation and restraint.

Key takeaways: federalism accommodates national and regional governments, each autonomous in its sphere, with people holding dual identities, under a written supreme constitution and an independent judiciary. India has single citizenship. Several federations broke up or nearly did; the chapter concludes that the design and practice of federalism, especially trust, cooperation and restraint, matter as much as the constitution itself.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Federalism in the Indian Constitution and the division of powers

How the Constitution divides legislative subjects
ListExample subjects given in the chapterWho makes laws
Union ListDefence, atomic energy, foreign affairs, war and peace, banking, railways, post and telegraph, airways, ports, foreign trade, currency and coinageUnion legislature alone
State ListAgriculture, police, prisons, local government, public health, land, liquor, trade and commerce within the State, livestock and animal husbandry, State public servicesNormally only the State legislature
Concurrent ListEducation, transfer of property other than agricultural land, forests, trade unions, adulteration, adoption and successionBoth the Union and State legislatures
Residuary powersAll matters not in any list, for example cyber lawsUnion legislature alone

Division of legislative powers

  • Union List
    • Defence
    • Foreign affairs
    • Currency
    • Railways
  • State List
    • Police
    • Agriculture
    • Public health
    • Local government
  • Concurrent List
    • Education
    • Forests
    • Trade unions
    • Adoption and succession
  • Residuary
    • Matters in no list
    • Union legislates, e.g. cyber laws

Article 1: India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States. Powers are divided by the Union, State and Concurrent Lists; residuary powers go to the Union; financial powers are concentrated at the centre while States carry large responsibilities.

Key takeaways: after Partition, the Constituent Assembly chose a federation built on unity and centre-State cooperation. Article 1 calls India a Union of States; the word 'federation' is not used. Union and State governments both have constitutional status. Legislative subjects are divided into the Union, State and Concurrent Lists, with residuary powers for the Union. Financial powers are centralised, while States have large responsibilities and limited revenue.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Federalism with a strong central government

Provisions that give the centre greater power
ProvisionHow it strengthens the centre
Parliament's power over States' existenceParliament can form a new State by separating territory or uniting States, and alter a State's boundary or name; the concerned State legislature's view is sought as a safeguard
Emergency provisionsDuring an emergency, power becomes lawfully centralised, and Parliament can make laws on State subjects
Financial powersRevenue-generating items are under the centre; States depend largely on central grants and assistance; the centre uses its discretion in grants and loans
PlanningPlanning after independence centralised economic decision-making; a Planning Commission appointed by the Union government coordinated and supervised resource management, as the textbook describes
GovernorCan recommend dismissal of the State government and dissolution of the Assembly; can reserve a State bill for the President's assent, letting the centre delay or veto it
Legislating on the State ListParliament can make laws on State List matters if the Rajya Sabha approves
Superior executive powerUnion executive power is superior; under Article 257 the Union can give directions to States
All India ServicesIAS and IPS officers serving States are under central control; States cannot discipline or remove them
Articles 33 and 34Parliament can protect persons in Union or State service for actions taken during martial law to maintain or restore order

Sources of central dominance

  • Territorial
    • Parliament can create States, change boundaries and names
  • Emergency
    • Power lawfully centralised
    • Parliament legislates on State subjects
  • Financial
    • Main revenues with the centre
    • Grants, loans, planning
  • Legislative and executive
    • Governor can reserve State bills
    • Rajya Sabha route to State List
    • Article 257 directions
  • Administrative
    • All India Services under central control

India is a federation with a strong centre: Parliament controls the existence and boundaries of States, emergencies centralise power, the centre holds the main revenues, Governors can reserve State bills, Article 257 lets the Union direct States, and All India Services officers answer to the centre.

Key takeaways: the framers created a strong centre out of concern for unity, amid the integration of over 500 princely states, and for development through planning. Parliament controls the formation and boundaries of States; emergency provisions centralise power; the centre holds the main revenues; the Governor can reserve State bills; Parliament can legislate on State subjects with Rajya Sabha approval; Article 257 lets the Union direct States; and All India Services officers are under central control.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Centre-State relations, demands for autonomy, Governors and President's rule

How politics shaped federalism
PhasePolitical situationCentre-State relations
1950s and early 1960sFoundation laid under Nehru; one party dominant at the centre and in the StatesLargely normal except over the formation of new States; States optimistic about central grants and development policies
Mid-1960s onwardsOne-party dominance declined; opposition parties came to power in many StatesDemands for greater powers and autonomy; States protested what they saw as central interference
Since the 1990sEra of coalition politics at the centre; national and regional parties in power in StatesGreater say for States, respect for diversity, the beginning of a more mature federalism

Four kinds of autonomy demands

  • Powers
    • More and more important subjects for States
  • Finance
    • Independent revenue sources
    • Control over resources
  • Administration
    • Less central control over officials
  • Culture and language
    • Resistance to linguistic domination
    • Promotion of regional language and culture

Article 356: President's rule when a State's government cannot be carried on according to the Constitution; Parliament must ratify it; it can last up to three years; the courts can examine its validity. The Sarkaria Commission (1983-88) urged strictly non-partisan Governors.

Key takeaways: centre-State relations changed with politics: normal under one-party dominance, tense after the mid-1960s, and more mature in the coalition era since the 1990s. Autonomy demands concern powers, finance, administration, and culture and language. The Governor, appointed by the centre, and Article 356 have been the most controversial parts of the system; President's rule needs parliamentary ratification, can last up to three years and is subject to judicial review.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

New States, inter-State disputes and special provisions

Reorganisation of States
YearDevelopment described in the chapter
December 1953States Reorganisation Commission set up; recommended linguistic States, at least for major linguistic groups
1956Reorganisation of some States; beginning of linguistic States
1960Gujarat and Maharashtra created
1966Punjab and Haryana separated
LaterNorth-east reorganised: Manipur, Tripura, Meghalaya, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh created
2000Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand created from Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh and Bihar
2014Telangana formed by dividing Andhra Pradesh

Two kinds of inter-State dispute

  • Border disputes
    • Claims over territory of a neighbouring State
    • Mixed-language border areas
    • More about sentiment
    • Example in the chapter: Belgaum
  • River-water disputes
    • Sharing a river's water
    • Affect drinking water and agriculture
    • More serious, test cooperation
    • Examples in the chapter: Kaveri, Narmada

States were reorganised mainly on linguistic lines from 1956, and later also for administrative efficiency (2000, 2014). Border and river-water disputes are legal and political, best settled by negotiation. Asymmetric federalism gives special provisions to some States, especially in the north-east.

Key takeaways: linguistic reorganisation began with the States Reorganisation Commission (1953) and the 1956 reorganisation, followed by Gujarat and Maharashtra (1960), Punjab and Haryana (1966), new north-eastern States, three new States in 2000 and Telangana in 2014. Border and river-water disputes between States are political as well as legal. The Constitution makes special provisions for several States, especially in the north-east; the textbook records that the special status of Jammu and Kashmir under Article 370 no longer exists. Federalism depends on trust, toleration and cooperation.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery