• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Criticisms of Indian secularism and the textbook's responses

Set out the six criticisms of Indian secularism discussed in the chapter, anti-religious, western import, minoritism, interventionist, vote bank politics and impossible project, together with the responses the textbook gives.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State each of the six criticisms of Indian secularism the chapter discusses.
  • Give the textbook's response to each, including the train and auditorium examples on minority rights.
  • Explain the dilemma of personal laws and the textbook's view of vote bank politics, presenting the arguments as the book does.

Indian secularism, the textbook says, has faced fierce criticism. It examines six criticisms and asks whether secularism can be defended against them. We present each criticism and the textbook's response, attributing the arguments to the textbook and taking no side on present-day political disputes.

1. 'Secularism is anti-religious'

Response: secularism is against institutionalised religious domination, which is not the same as being anti-religious. Some argue it threatens religious identity, but because it promotes religious freedom and equality, it protects religious identity. It does undermine identities that are dogmatic, violent, fanatical, exclusivist or that foster hatred of other religions. The real question, the textbook says, is whether what is undermined is worthy or unworthy.

2. 'Secularism is a western import'

First response: many things in India, from trousers to the internet and parliamentary democracy, originated in the west; and Europeans do not refuse to use zero because it was invented in India. But the textbook calls this a shallow response. Deeper response: a secular state must have ends of its own. Western states became secular by challenging the control of established religious authority, so the western model is not simply a product of the Christian world. And mutual exclusion is not the defining feature of all secular states; separation can be interpreted differently. India evolved its own variant: secularism has both western and non-western origins. In the west, church-state separation was central; in countries like India, peaceful coexistence of religious communities has been important.

3. 'Minoritism'

Indian secularism does advocate minority rights. Is this justified? The textbook uses two examples.

  1. The train compartment. Four adults share a compartment; one wants to smoke, one cannot bear smoke, and two mild smokers stay silent. Settled by vote, the non-smoker loses 3 to 1, which seems fair. But if the non-smoker has asthma and smoke could cause a life-threatening attack, his preference expresses a fundamental and urgent interest. Voting is then inappropriate; a person has a prior right to the satisfaction of such interests. The same holds for communities: the most fundamental interests of minorities must be protected by constitutional law. Minority rights are justified as long as they protect fundamental interests.
  2. The auditorium. A film is shown on a first floor reached only by stairs. Everyone may buy a ticket, but old people, someone with a broken leg and wheelchair users cannot climb. A lift or ramp lets them achieve what others get by the stairs. This is not special treatment but treating them with the same respect and dignity as others. So minority rights need not, and should not, be viewed as special privileges.

4. 'Secularism is interventionist'

Some say Indian secularism is coercive and interferes too much with communities' religious freedom. Response: by rejecting separation as mutual exclusion, it rejects total non-interference, but that does not make it excessively interventionist. Principled distance also allows non-interference, and interference need not be coercive. State-supported reform should not be equated with change imposed from above.

The textbook acknowledges a big dilemma: why have the personal laws (laws on marriage, inheritance and family matters, governed by different religions) of all communities not been reformed? A secularist might see them as community-specific rights protected by the Constitution, or as an affront to secular principles because they treat women unequally. In the textbook's words, they can be seen as expressions of freedom from inter-religious domination or as instances of intra-religious domination. The textbook's view is that such tensions need not last forever: personal laws can be reformed so that they reflect both minority rights and equality between men and women, but reform should come neither by state or group coercion, nor should the state stay totally aloof. The state should act as a facilitator, supporting liberal and democratic voices within every religion.

5. 'Vote bank politics'

The textbook says that, as an empirical claim, the charge that secularism encourages vote bank politics is not entirely false, but puts it in perspective. In a democracy politicians are bound to seek votes; the real question is what the vote is sought for: only for the politician's power, or also for the group's welfare? If a group gets no benefit, the politician is to blame; if its interests are protected, that serves the secular aim of protecting minorities. But if one group's welfare is pursued at the cost of other groups' rights, a new injustice is born.

The textbook then states its concerns about vote bank politics in general terms: it distorts elections when a whole group is mobilised to vote as one monolithic unit, artificially presenting the group's interest as single despite its diversity; parties may put short-term electoral gain above long-term development, focusing on emotive issues rather than genuine problems; competition can deepen social division by portraying groups as rivals for limited resources; and when parties set aside equality of all citizens in favour of one group's interests, the textbook says this has ironically led to further alienation and marginalisation of that group and made social reform within it harder.

6. 'An impossible project'

The cynical criticism is that people with deep religious differences can never live together in peace. Response: this is empirically false; Indian civilisation shows such living together is possible, and the Ottoman Empire is another example. Critics may reply that coexistence then rested on hierarchy and will not work when equality is a dominant value. The textbook's further response is that Indian secularism mirrors the future of the world: with migration from former colonies and globalisation, Europe, America and parts of the Middle East are becoming as religiously and culturally diverse as India, so the world watches the Indian experiment with keen interest.

Six criticisms and the textbook's responses

  • Anti-religious
    • Opposes domination, not religion; protects religious identity
  • Western import
    • Has western and non-western origins; India's own variant
  • Minoritism
    • Protects fundamental interests; not special privilege (train, auditorium)
  • Interventionist
    • Principled distance allows non-interference; reform by facilitation, not coercion
  • Vote bank politics
    • Seeking votes is normal; the issue is whose welfare and at whose cost
  • Impossible project
    • Coexistence has existed; India's experiment mirrors a diverse world

Minority rights are justified when they protect fundamental interests; like a ramp for those who cannot climb stairs, they give the same respect and dignity others already enjoy, not a special privilege.

— The textbook's argument, in our own words

Worked example 1: applying the train example

In a made-up housing society, residents vote 40 to 5 to hold loud celebrations every night in the courtyard. Five residents include a heart patient whose doctor has warned against sleepless nights. Applying the textbook's reasoning: for ordinary preferences, majority voting is fair. But the heart patient's interest in rest is fundamental and urgent. Just as the asthmatic passenger has a prior right, the patient's fundamental interest should be protected rather than decided by vote. The textbook extends this logic to communities and constitutional minority rights.

Worked example 2: matching criticisms with responses

Match each made-up statement with the criticism it answers. (a) 'Mixed societies have lived together before, and many countries are now becoming as diverse as India.' (b) 'Secularism weakens only fanatical and exclusivist identities.' (c) 'Separation can take more than one form, and India developed its own.' Answers: (a) answers 'impossible project'; (b) answers 'anti-religious'; (c) answers 'western import'.

Key takeaways: the textbook responds to six criticisms. Secularism opposes domination, not religion, and protects religious identity. It has western and non-western origins, and India has its own variant. Minority rights protect fundamental interests and are not special privileges. Principled distance allows non-interference and favours reform by facilitating liberal voices, not coercion, though personal laws remain a dilemma. Seeking votes is normal, but pursuing one group's interest at others' cost, or treating a group as a monolith, is harmful. Peaceful coexistence is possible, and India's experiment matters to a diversifying world.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the chapter's train compartment example, why is voting inappropriate once the non-smoker has asthma?

    1. Because voting is always wrong
    2. Because his preference now expresses a fundamental and urgent interest, to which he has a prior right
    3. Because smokers are a minority
    4. Because trains do not allow voting
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says that when it comes to fundamental interests, voting is inappropriate; a person has a prior right to the satisfaction of significant interests. The same holds for minority communities.

  2. 2. What lesson does the chapter draw from the auditorium example?

    1. Minority rights need not and should not be viewed as special privileges
    2. Only young people should watch films
    3. Stairs are unfair to everyone
    4. Majorities should always decide
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says a ramp or lift treats people with the same respect and dignity as others; so minority rights need not, and should not, be viewed as special privileges.

  3. 3. According to the chapter, how should reform of personal laws be brought about?

    1. By state coercion
    2. By group coercion
    3. By the state staying totally aloof
    4. By the state acting as a facilitator supporting liberal and democratic voices within every religion
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says such reform should come neither by state or group coercion, nor should the state keep total distance; it should act as a facilitator supporting liberal and democratic voices within every religion.

  4. 4. The chapter's response to the criticism that secularism is an 'impossible project' includes the point that:

    1. religious diversity is shrinking worldwide
    2. only small countries can be secular
    3. Indian secularism mirrors the future of a world becoming more diverse through migration and globalisation
    4. coexistence has never existed
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says coexistence has been realised in Indian history and in the Ottoman Empire, and that India's experiment mirrors the future of the world as Europe, America and parts of the Middle East grow more diverse.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The textbook says secularism undermines some forms of religious identity. Reason (R): It undermines identities that are dogmatic, violent, fanatical, exclusivist or that foster hatred of other religions.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says secularism protects religious identity in general but undermines dogmatic, violent, fanatical and exclusivist forms that foster hatred. R specifies and explains the identities referred to in A.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Secularism

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery