- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The secular state: beyond theocracy and established religion
Explain why the state matters for preventing religious domination, distinguish a theocratic state and a state with an established religion from a secular state, and state the conditions the textbook lists for a truly secular state.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why education and individual goodness alone cannot end religious discrimination, and why the state matters.
- Define a theocratic state and a state with an established religion, with the textbook's historical examples.
- State the conditions for a truly secular state and explain why separation is necessary but not sufficient.
How can religious domination be prevented? One way, the textbook says, is to work for mutual enlightenment: education can change mindsets, and examples of people of one community saving members of another during a riot are inspiring. But it is unlikely that education or the goodness of some individuals will eliminate religious discrimination. In modern societies the state has enormous public power, and how it acts makes a crucial difference. So we must ask what kind of state can prevent religious conflict and promote harmony.
Step 1: not a theocracy
To prevent domination by any religious group, a state must not be run by the heads of any particular religion. A state governed directly by a priestly order is called theocratic. The textbook's historical example is the Papal States of medieval Europe. Lacking separation between religious and political institutions, theocratic states are known for hierarchies, oppression and reluctance to allow freedom of religion to other groups. If we value peace, freedom and equality, religious institutions and state institutions must be separated.
Step 2: no established religion
Some think separation is enough. The textbook disagrees: many non-theocratic states still have a close alliance with a particular religion. In sixteenth-century England, the state was not run by priests but clearly favoured the Anglican Church and its members; England had an established Anglican religion, the official religion of the state. The textbook notes that some states today also have an official state religion. Such regimes may leave little room for internal dissent or religious equality.
So to be truly secular, a state must not only refuse to be theocratic but must also have no formal, legal alliance with any religion.
Three kinds of state and religion
-
Theocratic state
- Governed directly by a priestly order
- No separation of religious and political institutions
- Example: medieval Papal States
-
State with established religion
- Not run by priests
- Formal alliance with one official religion
- Example: 16th-century England and the Anglican Church
-
Secular state
- Not theocratic
- No formal legal alliance with any religion
- Pursues ends partly from non-religious sources
Step 3: secular ends
The separation of religion and state is, the textbook stresses, necessary but not sufficient. A secular state must be committed to principles and goals at least partly derived from non-religious sources. These ends include:
- peace;
- religious freedom;
- freedom from religiously grounded oppression, discrimination and exclusion;
- inter-religious and intra-religious equality.
The state must be separated from organised religion for the sake of these values. But there is no reason why this separation must take one particular form; its nature and extent can differ according to the values it is meant to promote and how those values are spelt out. The textbook goes on to compare two conceptions: the mainstream western one, best represented by the American state, and an alternative best exemplified by the Indian state.
A secular state is neither theocratic nor allied with any religion, and it pursues ends such as peace, religious freedom and equality between and within religions. Separation from religion is necessary but not sufficient, and can take more than one form.
Tests for a secular state (our summary of the textbook)
- Is it run by a priestly order? If yes, it is theocratic, not secular.
- Does it have an official religion? If yes, it has an established religion, not secular.
- Does it pursue secular ends? Peace, religious freedom, freedom from religious oppression, equality between and within religions.
- Secular state The form of separation may differ, as in the American and Indian models.
Worked example 1: classifying states
Classify these made-up states. Alpha is ruled by a council of high priests who make all laws. Beta has an elected parliament but declares one religion its official faith and funds only its institutions. Gamma has no official religion, is not run by clergy, and its laws aim at religious freedom and equality for all faiths. Answers: Alpha is theocratic; Beta has an established religion; Gamma meets the textbook's conditions for a secular state.
Worked example 2: is separation enough?
A made-up state, Delta, has no official religion and no clergy in government, but it does nothing when one community is repeatedly driven out of its homes by another. Is Delta fully secular by the textbook's standard? Reasoning: Delta passes the separation tests but fails to pursue secular ends: peace, freedom from religiously grounded oppression and inter-religious equality. Conclusion: separation is necessary but not sufficient; Delta falls short of a truly secular state.
Key takeaways: education and personal goodness help but cannot by themselves end religious discrimination, so the state's role is crucial. A theocratic state is governed by a priestly order; a state with an established religion has a formal alliance with one faith; neither is secular. A secular state separates religious and state institutions, has no legal alliance with any religion, and pursues ends from non-religious sources: peace, religious freedom, freedom from religious oppression and equality between and within religions. Separation can take different forms.
Check your understanding
-
1. A state governed directly by a priestly order is called:
- a federal state
- a theocratic state
- a secular state
- a welfare state
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says a state governed directly by a priestly order is called theocratic, giving the Papal States of medieval Europe as an example.
-
2. Sixteenth-century England is used in the chapter as an example of a state that:
- had no religion at all
- was run by priests
- was not theocratic but had an established religion, the Anglican Church
- followed the Indian model of secularism
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says England in the sixteenth century was not run by a priestly class but clearly favoured the Anglican Church, the official established religion.
-
3. According to the chapter, the separation of religion and state is:
- necessary but not sufficient for a secular state
- sufficient by itself for a secular state
- unnecessary for a secular state
- possible only in one form
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says separation is a necessary but not a sufficient ingredient; a secular state must also pursue ends at least partly derived from non-religious sources.
-
4. Which of the following is NOT among the ends the chapter says a secular state should pursue?
- Peace
- Religious freedom
- Inter-religious and intra-religious equality
- Promotion of one official religion
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter lists peace, religious freedom, freedom from religiously grounded oppression, discrimination and exclusion, and inter- and intra-religious equality. Promoting an official religion would make it a state with an established religion.
-
5. Assertion (A): Separation of religion and state is not by itself sufficient for a state to be secular. Reason (R): Many non-theocratic states have kept a close formal alliance with a particular religion, leaving little room for religious equality.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says some think separation is enough, but many non-theocratic states, such as sixteenth-century England with its Anglican Church, remained allied to one religion. R explains why separation alone is not sufficient, so both are true and R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.