- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
What is secularism? Opposing inter- and intra-religious domination
Define secularism as the textbook does, a doctrine opposing both inter-religious and intra-religious domination, explain why it is not anti-religious, and state its positive aims of freedom within religions and equality between and within them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain inter-religious domination and why the textbook says secularism opposes it first and foremost.
- Explain intra-religious domination with the textbook's examples, and why secularism is not anti-religious.
- Define secularism as a normative doctrine and state its positive aims.
When many cultures and communities live in one country, how can a democratic state ensure equality for each? Chapter 8 of Political Theory answers through the idea of secularism. The textbook notes something puzzling: in India almost every politician and party professes secularism, yet it faces many doubts and challenges, from clerics and religious nationalists and also from some politicians, activists and academics. The chapter asks: What is secularism? Is it a western implant? Does it suit societies where religion matters deeply? Does it favour minorities? Is it anti-religious? We follow the textbook's answers closely and neutrally.
Inter-religious domination
The textbook points out that discrimination against religious minorities persists in many parts of the world, which shows the continuing importance of secularism. In India, the Constitution declares that every citizen has a right to live with freedom and dignity in any part of the country, yet exclusion and discrimination continue. The textbook cites three stark instances from recent Indian history: the killing of Sikhs in Delhi and elsewhere in 1984; the forced departure of Kashmiri Pandits from their homes in the Kashmir valley, to which many have not been able to return; and the killings in the post-Godhra riots in Gujarat in 2002.
What do these have in common? In each, the textbook says, members of one community were targeted and victimised because of their religious identity: the basic freedoms of a set of citizens were denied. Such incidents reflect inter-religious domination, the domination of one religious community by another. Secularism is first and foremost a doctrine that opposes all such forms of inter-religious domination.
Intra-religious domination
An equally important dimension is opposition to intra-religious domination, domination within a religion. The textbook first sets aside one view: some people believe religion is merely the 'opium of the masses' that will vanish once everyone's needs are met. The textbook calls this an exaggerated sense of human potential: humans will never fully know or control the world; disease, accident, separation and loss will remain, and some suffering is not man-made. Religion, art and philosophy are responses to such suffering. Secularism accepts this, and therefore it is not anti-religious.
However, the textbook notes that religion has some deep-rooted problems:
- One can hardly think of a religion that treats its male and female members equally.
- In religions such as Hinduism, some sections have faced persistent discrimination: dalits have been barred from entering Hindu temples, and in some parts of the country women cannot enter certain temples.
- Organised religion is often taken over by its most conservative faction, which does not tolerate dissent; the textbook notes that religious fundamentalism has become a problem even in parts of the USA.
- Many religions split into sects, leading to sectarian violence and persecution of dissenting minorities.
So religious domination takes two forms. Because secularism opposes all forms of institutionalised religious domination, it challenges both inter-religious and intra-religious domination.
Two forms of religious domination secularism opposes
-
Inter-religious domination
- One religious community dominates another
- Members targeted because of their religious identity
- Basic freedoms of citizens denied
-
Intra-religious domination
- Domination within a religion
- Unequal treatment of women; exclusion of dalits from temples
- Conservative factions suppress dissent; sects persecute dissenters
A definition
Secularism is a normative doctrine that seeks a society free of both inter-religious and intra-religious domination. Positively, it promotes freedom within religions and equality between, as well as within, religions.
The word normative means that secularism describes how society ought to be, an ideal to work towards. With this framework, the textbook turns to a narrower question taken up in the next lesson: what kind of state is needed to realise these goals, and how should it relate to religion and religious communities?
Secularism as the textbook defines it
-
Opposes
- Inter-religious domination
- Intra-religious domination
-
Promotes
- Freedom within religions
- Equality between religions
- Equality within religions
-
Is not
- Anti-religious: it accepts religion responds to real human suffering
Worked example 1: inter or intra?
Classify these made-up situations. (a) In a town, shopkeepers of one religion are forced to close their shops by a mob from another religion. (b) Within a religious community, women are barred from serving on the body that manages its place of worship. (c) A sect expels members who question its leader and threatens them. Answers: (a) inter-religious domination; (b) intra-religious domination (unequal treatment of women); (c) intra-religious domination (persecution of dissenters). Secularism, as the textbook defines it, opposes all three.
Worked example 2: is secularism anti-religious?
A made-up student, Imran, says, 'Secularism wants religion to disappear.' Reply using the chapter: the textbook rejects the view that religion will vanish once needs are met, because some suffering (disease, loss, accident) is part of the human condition and religion, art and philosophy respond to it. Secularism opposes domination, not religion itself, and it promotes freedom within religions. So Imran's claim misreads secularism.
Key takeaways: secularism opposes, first and foremost, inter-religious domination, in which members of a community are targeted for their religious identity. It equally opposes intra-religious domination, such as unequal treatment of women, exclusion of dalits from temples and persecution of dissenters. It is not anti-religious. The textbook defines it as a normative doctrine seeking a society free of both kinds of domination, promoting freedom within religions and equality between and within them.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the chapter, secularism is first and foremost a doctrine that opposes:
- all religions
- inter-religious domination
- economic inequality
- democracy
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says secularism is first and foremost a doctrine that opposes all forms of inter-religious domination; it also opposes intra-religious domination.
-
2. Which of the following is an example of intra-religious domination given in the chapter?
- Dalits being barred from entering Hindu temples
- One country invading another
- A government raising taxes
- Two religions sharing a festival
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter gives the barring of dalits from Hindu temples, and of women from some temples, as examples of discrimination within a religion, which is intra-religious domination.
-
3. Why does the chapter say secularism is not anti-religious?
- Because it makes religion compulsory
- Because it supports only the majority religion
- Because it accepts that religion, art and philosophy respond to suffering that is part of the human condition
- Because it bans all criticism of religion
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says some suffering is not man-made and religion, art and philosophy are responses to it; secularism accepts this and therefore is not anti-religious.
-
4. Positively stated, secularism according to the chapter promotes:
- one state religion
- the disappearance of religion
- domination by the largest community
- freedom within religions and equality between, as well as within, religions
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says that, put positively, secularism promotes freedom within religions, and equality between as well as within religions.
-
5. Assertion (A): Secularism challenges intra-religious as well as inter-religious domination. Reason (R): Secularism is opposed to all forms of institutionalised religious domination.
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says that as secularism is opposed to all forms of institutionalised religious domination, it challenges not merely inter-religious but also intra-religious domination. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.