- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The western model of secularism and Ataturk's Turkey
Explain the mainstream western, American-inspired model of secularism as mutual exclusion of religion and state, its individualist idea of freedom and equality and its historical roots, and contrast it with Kemal Ataturk's interventionist secularism in Turkey.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the western model's idea of separation as mutual exclusion and what it means for state policy.
- Explain its individualist understanding of freedom and equality and why it neglects community and minority rights.
- Describe Kemal Ataturk's secularism in Turkey and how it differed from both the western and the Indian models.
All secular states share one feature: they are neither theocratic nor do they establish a religion. Beyond that, they differ. This lesson studies the mainstream western conception, inspired mainly by the American model, and then a very different version practised in Turkey.
Separation as mutual exclusion
In the mainstream western conception, separation of religion and state means mutual exclusion: the state will not intervene in religion's affairs, and religion will not interfere in the state's. Each has its own sphere with independent jurisdiction.
Mutual exclusion in the western model
-
Religion kept out of the state
- No policy may have an exclusively religious rationale
- No religious classification may be the basis of public policy
-
State kept out of religion
- No aid to any religious institution
- No financial support to schools run by religious communities
- No hindrance to religious communities within the law
The textbook spells out what non-interference implies. If a religious institution forbids women from becoming priests, the state can do little. If a community excommunicates dissenters, the state can only be a silent witness. If a religion forbids some of its own members from entering a temple's sanctum, the state must let the matter rest. On this view, religion is a private matter, not a matter of state policy or law.
Individualist freedom and equality
This conception interprets freedom and equality individualistically: liberty is the liberty of individuals, and equality is equality between individuals. There is little room for the idea that a community may follow practices of its own choosing, and little scope for community-based or minority rights.
The textbook explains why through history. Apart from the presence of Jewish communities, most western societies were marked by a great deal of religious homogeneity. So they naturally focused on intra-religious domination. Strict separation of church and state was emphasised to secure, among other things, individual freedom, while issues of inter-religious equality, and hence minority rights, were often neglected.
Finally, this mainstream secularism has no place for state-supported religious reform, which follows directly from treating separation as mutual exclusion.
The mainstream western model treats separation as mutual exclusion: the state stays out of religion and religion stays out of the state, freedom and equality are understood for individuals, and there is no room for state-supported religious reform.
A different path: Kemal Ataturk's Turkey
The textbook presents a very different secularism practised in Turkey in the first half of the twentieth century by Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, who came to power after the First World War. This was not principled distance from organised religion but active intervention in, and suppression of, religion. Ataturk was determined to end the institution of the Khalifa in Turkish public life and believed only a clean break with traditional thinking could lift Turkey from the state it was in. He set out aggressively to modernise and secularise the country.
| Area | Measure |
|---|---|
| Name | He changed his own name from Mustafa Kemal Pasha to Kemal Ataturk (meaning Father of the Turks) |
| Dress | The Fez, a traditional cap worn by Muslims, was banned by the Hat Law; western clothing was encouraged for men and women |
| Calendar | The Western (Gregorian) calendar replaced the traditional Turkish calendar |
| Script | In 1928, a new Turkish alphabet in a modified Latin form was adopted |
The textbook invites students to imagine a secularism that does not leave them free to keep their name, wear the dress they are used to or use their accustomed language, and to compare it with Indian secularism. As the next lesson shows, Nehru's secularism, for example, did not mean hostility to religion.
Two contrasting secularisms
-
Mainstream western (American-inspired)
- Mutual exclusion of state and religion
- State neither aids nor hinders religion
- Religion a private matter
- No state-supported religious reform
-
Ataturk's Turkey
- Active intervention in and suppression of religion
- Khalifa ended in public life
- Dress, calendar and script changed by the state
- Modernisation imposed from above
Worked example 1: what would the western model do?
In a made-up country following the mainstream western model, a religious body refuses to allow women to become priests, and a school run by a religious community asks the government for funds. Applying the model: the state does not intervene in the priesthood rule, since religion is a private matter; and it does not fund the religious school, since it cannot aid religious institutions. Both answers follow from mutual exclusion.
Worked example 2: why the neglect of minority rights?
Why did the western model pay little attention to minority rights? Reasoning step by step: (1) most western societies were largely of one religion; (2) so the main problem they faced was domination within that religion (for example, by a church over individuals); (3) the solution stressed was church-state separation to protect individual freedom; (4) with few large religious minorities, inter-religious equality and minority rights received less attention. This is the historical explanation the textbook gives.
Key takeaways: all secular states are neither theocratic nor establish a religion. The mainstream western model treats separation as mutual exclusion: no religious rationale for policy, no state aid to religious institutions, no state interference in religious practices; religion is private. It understands freedom and equality individualistically, leaving little room for community or minority rights, because western societies were largely religiously homogeneous, and it rejects state-supported religious reform. Ataturk's Turkey, by contrast, actively intervened in and suppressed religion.
Check your understanding
-
1. In the mainstream western model of secularism, separation of religion and state is understood as:
- mutual exclusion
- principled distance
- state-supported reform
- an established church
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says that in the commonly prevalent conception, inspired mainly by the American model, separation is understood as mutual exclusion: neither interferes in the other's affairs.
-
2. Under the western model, if a religious community excommunicates its dissenters, the state:
- must punish the community
- must fund the dissenters
- can only be a silent witness
- must take over the community
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says that under this view, if a religious community excommunicates its dissenters, the state can only be a silent witness, since religion is a private matter.
-
3. Why, according to the chapter, did western secularism focus on intra-religious domination and neglect minority rights?
- Because western societies had many religions
- Because minorities refused rights
- Because the state supported religious reform
- Because most western societies were marked by a great deal of religious homogeneity
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says that, except for the presence of Jews, most western societies were religiously homogeneous, so they focused on intra-religious domination and often neglected inter-religious equality and minority rights.
-
4. Which measure was taken in Ataturk's Turkey, according to the chapter?
- The Fez was banned by the Hat Law
- A state religion was established
- All schools were run by clerics
- Arabic script was made compulsory
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says the Fez was banned by the Hat Law, western clothing encouraged, the Gregorian calendar adopted and, in 1928, a new Turkish alphabet in modified Latin form introduced.
-
5. Assertion (A): The mainstream western model has no place for state-supported religious reform. Reason (R): It understands the separation of state and religion as a relationship of mutual exclusion.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says this feature follows directly from the understanding that separation entails mutual exclusion: if the state stays out of religion, it cannot support reform within it. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.