- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
The Indian model of secularism and principled distance
Explain Nehru's view of secularism, how Indian secularism arose, its three differences from the western model, the idea of principled distance with negative and positive engagement, and why it is more than 'equal respect for all religions'.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State Nehru's understanding of secularism as the textbook presents it.
- Explain how Indian secularism arose and its three differences from the western model.
- Explain principled distance, with examples of negative and positive engagement, and why the textbook says Indian secularism is more than equal respect for all religions.
It is sometimes said that Indian secularism imitates the western model. The textbook argues that a careful reading of the Constitution shows otherwise: Indian secularism is fundamentally different. It does not focus only on church-state separation, and the idea of inter-religious equality is crucial to it.
Nehru on secularism
The textbook calls Jawaharlal Nehru the philosopher of Indian secularism. Asked by a student what secularism meant in independent India, he answered: equal protection by the State to all religions. He wanted a secular state that protects all religions, does not favour one at the expense of others, and does not itself adopt any religion as the state religion.
- Nehru did not practise any religion or believe in God, but secularism for him did not mean hostility to religion; in this he was very different from Ataturk.
- He did not favour complete separation of religion and state: a secular state can intervene in religion to bring about social reform. He played a key role in laws abolishing caste discrimination, dowry and sati, and extending legal rights and social freedom to women.
- On one point he was uncompromising: secularism meant complete opposition to communalism of all kinds, and he was particularly severe on communalism of the majority community. For him secularism was also the only guarantee of the unity and integrity of India.
How Indian secularism arose
Indian secularism arose amid deep religious diversity that predated western modern ideas and nationalism, and there was already a culture of inter-religious 'tolerance'. But the textbook cautions that tolerance is compatible with religious domination: it may give everyone some space, but usually limited freedom, and it lets you put up with people you find deeply repugnant. That is valuable for a society recovering from civil war, but not enough in peacetime when people seek equal dignity and respect.
Western modernity brought to the fore neglected notions of equality in Indian thought, sharpening the focus on equality within communities and introducing ideas of inter-community equality to replace hierarchy. Indian secularism thus took a distinct form through the interaction of an existing diverse society with ideas from the west, resulting in equal focus on intra-religious and inter-religious domination.
Three differences from the western model
| Feature | Mainstream western model | Indian model |
|---|---|---|
| Kinds of domination opposed | Mainly intra-religious | Equally intra-religious (e.g. oppression of dalits and women within Hinduism, discrimination against women within Indian Islam or Christianity) and inter-religious (threats a majority may pose to minorities) |
| Whose religious freedom | Individuals | Individuals and minority communities: right to exist and maintain their culture and educational institutions |
| State-supported religious reform | No place for it | Compatible with it: the Constitution bans untouchability; laws abolish child marriage and lift the taboo on inter-caste marriage |
Principled distance
Can a state support religious reform and still be secular? The textbook says the Indian state's secular character is established because it is neither theocratic nor has it established any one or multiple religions. Beyond that, it follows a sophisticated policy in pursuit of religious equality, allowing it either to disengage from religion in the American style or to engage with it when required. This flexible approach is called principled distance.
Principled distance: how the Indian state may relate to religion
-
Disengage
- Keep distance, as in the American style, where that serves peace and equality
-
Engage negatively
- Oppose religious tyranny
- Example: the ban on untouchability
-
Engage positively
- Support communities
- Example: minorities may establish and maintain educational institutions, which may receive state assistance
Principled distance: the Indian state keeps away from religion or engages with it, negatively to oppose religious tyranny or positively to support communities, always guided by the values of peace, freedom and equality.
More than 'equal respect for all religions'
The textbook argues that the phrase 'equal respect for all religions' cannot capture Indian secularism. If it means peaceful coexistence or tolerance, that is not enough, because secularism is much more than coexistence. If it means equal respect for all established religions and their practices, it is ambiguous, because Indian secularism allows principled state intervention in all religions, which shows disrespect for some aspects of every religion. For example, religiously sanctioned caste hierarchies are not acceptable. The secular state need not respect every aspect of every religion; it allows equal disrespect for some aspects of organised religions.
A cartoon in the chapter contrasts India with France: in France there was a heated debate when religious markers like turbans and veils were banned in educational institutions, while in India there is no prohibition on wearing or displaying such markers in public institutions. The textbook explains that the two countries' ideals of secularism differ.
Worked example 1: negative or positive engagement?
Classify these state actions in a made-up Indian district. (a) Officials ensure that dalit families can enter a village temple. (b) A minority community's school receives a state grant like other aided schools. Answers: (a) negative engagement, opposing religious tyranny (like the ban on untouchability); (b) positive engagement, supporting a minority's right to maintain educational institutions. Both fit principled distance.
Worked example 2: why tolerance is not enough
In a made-up village, a group allows a smaller community to live there but forbids it from using the common well or owning land near the temple. The dominant group says, 'We tolerate them.' Reasoning with the chapter: tolerance here coexists with domination; the smaller community has some space but limited freedom, and no equal dignity. Indian secularism aims at equality between communities, not mere tolerance, so this falls short.
Key takeaways: Nehru defined secularism as equal protection by the state to all religions, opposed communalism of every kind, and supported state-led social reform without hostility to religion. Indian secularism arose from the interaction of a diverse society's tolerance with modern ideas of equality. It differs from the western model in opposing both intra- and inter-religious domination, protecting community as well as individual freedom, and allowing state-supported reform. Principled distance lets the state disengage or engage, negatively or positively, and it allows equal disrespect for oppressive aspects of all religions.
Check your understanding
-
1. How did Nehru, as quoted in the chapter, describe secularism in independent India?
- Hostility to all religions
- Equal protection by the State to all religions
- A state religion for the majority
- Complete separation of religion and state
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says Nehru answered 'equal protection by the State to all religions', wanting a state that protects all religions, favours none and adopts no state religion.
-
2. Why does the chapter say that tolerance alone is not enough?
- Tolerance is a western idea
- Tolerance is compatible with religious domination and usually allows only limited freedom
- Tolerance always leads to war
- Tolerance requires a state religion
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says tolerance is compatible with religious domination: it may allow some space but usually limited freedom, which is not enough when people struggle for equal dignity.
-
3. The ban on untouchability is an example, in the chapter's terms, of the Indian state engaging with religion:
- positively, by funding religious schools
- by adopting a state religion
- negatively, to oppose religious tyranny
- by mutual exclusion
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says the state may engage with religion negatively to oppose religious tyranny, reflected in the ban on untouchability; positive engagement includes aid to minority educational institutions.
-
4. Which is one of the three differences between Indian and mainstream western secularism given in the chapter?
- Indian secularism deals with the religious freedom of minority communities as well as individuals
- Indian secularism forbids all state reform
- Western secularism supports minority rights more
- Indian secularism establishes several religions
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter says Indian secularism deals not only with individuals' religious freedom but also with that of minority communities, who may maintain their culture and educational institutions.
-
5. Assertion (A): The complexity of Indian secularism cannot be captured by the phrase 'equal respect for all religions'. Reason (R): Indian secularism allows principled state intervention in all religions, which means disrespect for some aspects of every religion, such as caste hierarchies.
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says the phrase is inadequate because Indian secularism permits principled intervention showing disrespect to some aspects of every religion, allowing equal disrespect for oppressive practices. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.