Revision notes

Chapter 8 Secularism: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What is secularism? Opposing inter- and intra-religious domination

Two forms of religious domination secularism opposes

  • Inter-religious domination
    • One religious community dominates another
    • Members targeted because of their religious identity
    • Basic freedoms of citizens denied
  • Intra-religious domination
    • Domination within a religion
    • Unequal treatment of women; exclusion of dalits from temples
    • Conservative factions suppress dissent; sects persecute dissenters

Secularism is a normative doctrine that seeks a society free of both inter-religious and intra-religious domination. Positively, it promotes freedom within religions and equality between, as well as within, religions.

— The textbook's definition, in our own words

Secularism as the textbook defines it

  • Opposes
    • Inter-religious domination
    • Intra-religious domination
  • Promotes
    • Freedom within religions
    • Equality between religions
    • Equality within religions
  • Is not
    • Anti-religious: it accepts religion responds to real human suffering

Key takeaways: secularism opposes, first and foremost, inter-religious domination, in which members of a community are targeted for their religious identity. It equally opposes intra-religious domination, such as unequal treatment of women, exclusion of dalits from temples and persecution of dissenters. It is not anti-religious. The textbook defines it as a normative doctrine seeking a society free of both kinds of domination, promoting freedom within religions and equality between and within them.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

The secular state: beyond theocracy and established religion

Three kinds of state and religion

  • Theocratic state
    • Governed directly by a priestly order
    • No separation of religious and political institutions
    • Example: medieval Papal States
  • State with established religion
    • Not run by priests
    • Formal alliance with one official religion
    • Example: 16th-century England and the Anglican Church
  • Secular state
    • Not theocratic
    • No formal legal alliance with any religion
    • Pursues ends partly from non-religious sources

A secular state is neither theocratic nor allied with any religion, and it pursues ends such as peace, religious freedom and equality between and within religions. Separation from religion is necessary but not sufficient, and can take more than one form.

— Key idea, in our own words

Tests for a secular state (our summary of the textbook)

  1. Is it run by a priestly order? If yes, it is theocratic, not secular.
  2. Does it have an official religion? If yes, it has an established religion, not secular.
  3. Does it pursue secular ends? Peace, religious freedom, freedom from religious oppression, equality between and within religions.
  4. Secular state The form of separation may differ, as in the American and Indian models.

Key takeaways: education and personal goodness help but cannot by themselves end religious discrimination, so the state's role is crucial. A theocratic state is governed by a priestly order; a state with an established religion has a formal alliance with one faith; neither is secular. A secular state separates religious and state institutions, has no legal alliance with any religion, and pursues ends from non-religious sources: peace, religious freedom, freedom from religious oppression and equality between and within religions. Separation can take different forms.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

The western model of secularism and Ataturk's Turkey

Mutual exclusion in the western model

  • Religion kept out of the state
    • No policy may have an exclusively religious rationale
    • No religious classification may be the basis of public policy
  • State kept out of religion
    • No aid to any religious institution
    • No financial support to schools run by religious communities
    • No hindrance to religious communities within the law

The mainstream western model treats separation as mutual exclusion: the state stays out of religion and religion stays out of the state, freedom and equality are understood for individuals, and there is no room for state-supported religious reform.

— Summary in our own words
Measures in Ataturk's Turkey described in the chapter
AreaMeasure
NameHe changed his own name from Mustafa Kemal Pasha to Kemal Ataturk (meaning Father of the Turks)
DressThe Fez, a traditional cap worn by Muslims, was banned by the Hat Law; western clothing was encouraged for men and women
CalendarThe Western (Gregorian) calendar replaced the traditional Turkish calendar
ScriptIn 1928, a new Turkish alphabet in a modified Latin form was adopted

Two contrasting secularisms

  • Mainstream western (American-inspired)
    • Mutual exclusion of state and religion
    • State neither aids nor hinders religion
    • Religion a private matter
    • No state-supported religious reform
  • Ataturk's Turkey
    • Active intervention in and suppression of religion
    • Khalifa ended in public life
    • Dress, calendar and script changed by the state
    • Modernisation imposed from above

Key takeaways: all secular states are neither theocratic nor establish a religion. The mainstream western model treats separation as mutual exclusion: no religious rationale for policy, no state aid to religious institutions, no state interference in religious practices; religion is private. It understands freedom and equality individualistically, leaving little room for community or minority rights, because western societies were largely religiously homogeneous, and it rejects state-supported religious reform. Ataturk's Turkey, by contrast, actively intervened in and suppressed religion.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

The Indian model of secularism and principled distance

How Indian secularism differs (as the chapter explains)
FeatureMainstream western modelIndian model
Kinds of domination opposedMainly intra-religiousEqually intra-religious (e.g. oppression of dalits and women within Hinduism, discrimination against women within Indian Islam or Christianity) and inter-religious (threats a majority may pose to minorities)
Whose religious freedomIndividualsIndividuals and minority communities: right to exist and maintain their culture and educational institutions
State-supported religious reformNo place for itCompatible with it: the Constitution bans untouchability; laws abolish child marriage and lift the taboo on inter-caste marriage

Principled distance: how the Indian state may relate to religion

  • Disengage
    • Keep distance, as in the American style, where that serves peace and equality
  • Engage negatively
    • Oppose religious tyranny
    • Example: the ban on untouchability
  • Engage positively
    • Support communities
    • Example: minorities may establish and maintain educational institutions, which may receive state assistance

Principled distance: the Indian state keeps away from religion or engages with it, negatively to oppose religious tyranny or positively to support communities, always guided by the values of peace, freedom and equality.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: Nehru defined secularism as equal protection by the state to all religions, opposed communalism of every kind, and supported state-led social reform without hostility to religion. Indian secularism arose from the interaction of a diverse society's tolerance with modern ideas of equality. It differs from the western model in opposing both intra- and inter-religious domination, protecting community as well as individual freedom, and allowing state-supported reform. Principled distance lets the state disengage or engage, negatively or positively, and it allows equal disrespect for oppressive aspects of all religions.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Criticisms of Indian secularism and the textbook's responses

Six criticisms and the textbook's responses

  • Anti-religious
    • Opposes domination, not religion; protects religious identity
  • Western import
    • Has western and non-western origins; India's own variant
  • Minoritism
    • Protects fundamental interests; not special privilege (train, auditorium)
  • Interventionist
    • Principled distance allows non-interference; reform by facilitation, not coercion
  • Vote bank politics
    • Seeking votes is normal; the issue is whose welfare and at whose cost
  • Impossible project
    • Coexistence has existed; India's experiment mirrors a diverse world

Minority rights are justified when they protect fundamental interests; like a ramp for those who cannot climb stairs, they give the same respect and dignity others already enjoy, not a special privilege.

— The textbook's argument, in our own words

Key takeaways: the textbook responds to six criticisms. Secularism opposes domination, not religion, and protects religious identity. It has western and non-western origins, and India has its own variant. Minority rights protect fundamental interests and are not special privileges. Principled distance allows non-interference and favours reform by facilitating liberal voices, not coercion, though personal laws remain a dilemma. Seeking votes is normal, but pursuing one group's interest at others' cost, or treating a group as a monolith, is harmful. Peaceful coexistence is possible, and India's experiment matters to a diversifying world.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery