- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Limitations of controlling and its relationship with planning
Explain four limitations of controlling, and explain why planning and controlling are inseparable twins that are both forward-looking and backward-looking.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain four limitations of controlling with examples.
- Explain how planning and controlling depend on each other.
- Evaluate the statement 'planning is looking ahead while controlling is looking back'.
Limitations of controlling
(i) Difficulty in setting quantitative standards. Control loses some of its effectiveness when standards cannot be expressed in numbers. Employee morale, job satisfaction and human behaviour are hard to measure, so comparison with standards becomes difficult.
(ii) Little control on external factors. An enterprise generally cannot control government policies, technological changes or competition.
(iii) Resistance from employees. Employees often see control as a restriction on their freedom; for example, they may object to being watched constantly through closed-circuit television cameras.
(iv) Costly affair. Control involves expenditure, time and effort. A small enterprise may not be able to afford an expensive control system. Managers must ensure that the cost of installing and running a control system does not exceed its benefits.
Limitations of controlling
- Difficulty in setting quantitative standards Morale, satisfaction and behaviour are hard to measure.
- Little control on external factors Government policy, technology and competition are outside the firm.
- Resistance from employees Control seen as a restriction on freedom.
- Costly affair Expense, time and effort; costs must not exceed benefits.
Relationship between planning and controlling
The textbook calls planning and controlling the inseparable twins of management.
- Control presupposes standards, and these standards are provided by planning. Once a plan is in operation, control monitors progress, finds deviations and starts corrective action so that events conform to plans.
- So planning without controlling is meaningless, and controlling without planning is blind: if no standards are set in advance, there is nothing to control. Planning is a prerequisite for controlling.
- Planning is an intellectual process of thinking and analysis that prescribes a course of action; it is prescriptive. Controlling checks whether decisions have been turned into the desired action; it is evaluative.
Looking ahead and looking back
It is often said that planning looks ahead and controlling looks back. The textbook calls this only partially correct. Planning is forward-looking because plans are for the future and based on forecasts; controlling is backward-looking because it is like a post-mortem of past activities. But planning is also guided by past experience, and the corrective action started by controlling aims to improve future performance. So both are backward-looking as well as forward-looking.
Planning and controlling
-
Planning
- Sets objectives and standards
- Prescriptive; an intellectual process
- Looks ahead, but uses past experience
- Prerequisite for controlling
-
Controlling
- Measures performance against standards
- Evaluative; checks results
- Looks back, but improves future performance
- Improves the next round of planning
The two reinforce each other: planning based on facts makes controlling easier and more effective, and controlling improves future planning by providing information from past experience.
Planning and controlling are inseparable twins: planning without controlling is meaningless, and controlling without planning is blind. Both look ahead and look back.
Worked example 1: identify the limitation
(a) A made-up hotel wants to control 'guest delight' but cannot decide how to measure it. (b) A small made-up shop is offered a ₹3 lakh tracking system to prevent losses of about ₹20,000 a year. (c) A made-up exporter's costs rise because the government changes an export rule. Answer: (a) difficulty in setting quantitative standards; (b) costly affair: the cost far exceeds the benefit, since 3,00,000 ÷ 20,000 = 15 years of losses would be needed just to recover it; (c) little control on external factors.
Worked example 2: twins in a case
Case (made up): the manager of a made-up juice shop says, 'I check sales every evening,' but she has never fixed any target. Reasoning: without a standard, she can see figures but cannot judge whether they are good or bad, or by how much they fall short. Controlling without planning is blind. She should first plan a target, say 150 glasses a day, then compare actual sales with it.
Worked example 3: both directions
A made-up firm misses its sales target by 10 per cent. Its managers find that a new competitor cut prices (looking back), and they use this finding to set next year's prices and targets (looking ahead). Reasoning: controlling looked back to find causes, then improved future planning, while the new plan drew on past experience. This shows that both functions look backward and forward.
Key takeaways: controlling is limited by difficulty in setting quantitative standards, little control over external factors, employee resistance and cost. Planning and controlling are inseparable twins: planning provides standards and controlling checks them; planning without controlling is meaningless and controlling without planning is blind. Planning is prescriptive and controlling evaluative, but both look backward as well as forward and reinforce each other.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which is a limitation of controlling?
- Little control over external factors such as government policy and competition
- It helps in judging accuracy of standards
- It improves employee motivation
- It ensures order and discipline
Show answer
Answer: A. A firm generally cannot control external factors. The other options are points of importance of controlling, not limitations.
-
2. 'Controlling is blind without planning' because:
- controlling is always done before planning
- without standards set by planning, there is nothing to control against
- planning is an evaluative function
- controlling needs no information
Show answer
Answer: B. Control presupposes standards, which planning provides. Without predetermined standards, managers have no basis for comparison.
-
3. Planning is described as ______ and controlling as ______.
- evaluative; prescriptive
- backward-looking only; forward-looking only
- prescriptive; evaluative
- optional; compulsory
Show answer
Answer: C. Planning prescribes an appropriate course of action; controlling evaluates whether decisions have been translated into desired action.
-
4. Assertion (A): Planning is only forward-looking and controlling is only backward-looking. Reason (R): Planning is guided by past experience, and controlling aims to improve future performance.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: D. A is false: the textbook calls this view only partially correct. R is true, and it is exactly why both planning and controlling look backward as well as forward.
-
5. A small made-up firm considers a control system costing ₹1,20,000 a year to prevent losses of ₹30,000 a year. Which limitation does this illustrate?
- Difficulty in setting quantitative standards
- Resistance from employees
- Control can be a costly affair whose cost may exceed its benefit
- Little control on external factors
Show answer
Answer: C. The system's cost (₹1,20,000) is four times the expected benefit (₹30,000). Managers must ensure that the cost of control does not exceed its benefits.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.