• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

The controlling process: standards, measurement and comparison

Explain the five steps of the controlling process and study the first three in detail: setting quantitative and qualitative standards, measuring actual performance, and comparing it with standards.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • List the five steps of the controlling process in order.
  • Set quantitative and measurable qualitative standards.
  • Explain methods of measuring performance, including sample checking, and compare actual results with standards.

Controlling is a systematic process of five steps.

Steps in the controlling process

  1. Setting performance standards Criteria or benchmarks for measuring performance.
  2. Measurement of actual performance Objective, reliable measurement, in the same units as standards.
  3. Comparison of actual performance with standards Reveals the deviation.
  4. Analysing deviations Decide which deviations matter and find their causes.
  5. Taking corrective action Correct significant deviations, or revise standards.

Step 1: Setting performance standards

Standards are the criteria against which actual performance is measured; they are benchmarks the organisation works towards. They may be quantitative, such as cost to be incurred, revenue to be earned, units to be produced and sold, or time for a task, or qualitative, such as improving goodwill or employee motivation.

Managers should, as far as possible, set standards in precise quantitative terms, for example reducing defects from 10 per 1,000 pieces to 5 per 1,000 pieces by the end of the quarter. Where standards are qualitative, they should be defined so that they can be measured. To improve customer satisfaction in a self-service restaurant, for example, standards can be set for the time a customer waits for a table, the time to place an order and the time to collect it. Standards should also be flexible enough to be modified when the internal or external environment changes.

Examples of standards in functional areas (from the textbook's list)
ProductionMarketingHuman resource managementFinance and accounting
QuantitySales volumeLabour relationsCapital expenditure
QualitySales expenseLabour turnoverInventories
CostAdvertising expenditureLabour absenteeismFlow of capital
Individual job performanceSalesperson's performanceIndividual performanceLiquidity

Step 2: Measurement of actual performance

Performance should be measured objectively and reliably, using techniques such as personal observation, sample checking and performance reports, and preferably in the same units as the standards. Measurement need not wait until a task is complete; where possible it should happen during the work, for example checking each part before assembly or continuously monitoring gas levels in a plant for safety. An employee's performance may be measured by a superior's report; a company's by ratios such as gross profit ratio, net profit ratio and return on investment; marketing by units sold or market share; production by pieces produced and defectives. In a small firm every piece may be checked, but in a large firm pieces are checked at random: this is sample checking.

Step 3: Comparing actual performance with standards

Comparison reveals the deviation between actual and desired results. It is easiest when standards are quantitative: units a worker produced in a week can be compared directly with the weekly standard.

Deviation = actual performance − standard. Comparison is easy when standards are set in quantitative terms and measured in the same units.

Worked example 1: setting measurable standards

Turn these vague aims of a made-up pizza outlet into measurable standards: (a) 'serve customers quickly', (b) 'reduce waste', (c) 'improve quality'. Answer: (a) order taken within 3 minutes of arrival and delivered to the table within 15 minutes; (b) unsold dough not more than 2 per cent of dough prepared each day; (c) not more than 1 complaint per 200 orders. Each can now be measured and compared.

Worked example 2: measuring and comparing (illustrative figures)

A made-up garment unit's weekly standard is 1,200 shirts with not more than 12 defective per 1,000 made. Actual results: 1,140 shirts, of which 18 are defective. Working: output deviation = 1,140 − 1,200 = −60 shirts, that is (60 ÷ 1,200) × 100 = 5 per cent below standard. Defect standard for 1,140 shirts = 1,140 × 12 ÷ 1,000 = 13.68, about 14 shirts; actual defects 18 exceed it by about 4. Actual defect rate = (18 ÷ 1,140) × 1,000 ≈ 15.8 per 1,000 against the standard of 12 per 1,000. Both output and quality show adverse deviations, which go to the next step for analysis.

Worked example 3: sample checking

A made-up biscuit factory makes 50,000 packets a day. Checking every packet is impractical, so inspectors weigh 1 packet in every 500 chosen at random. Working: packets checked = 50,000 ÷ 500 = 100 a day. This is sample checking, used in large organisations.

Key takeaways: the controlling process has five steps: setting standards, measuring actual performance, comparing actual with standards, analysing deviations and taking corrective action. Standards should be precise and quantitative where possible, measurable where qualitative, and flexible. Measurement should be objective, in the same units as standards and, where possible, during the work, using observation, sample checking, reports and ratios. Comparison reveals the deviation.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is the first step in the controlling process?

    1. Setting performance standards
    2. Measuring actual performance
    3. Taking corrective action
    4. Analysing deviations
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Controlling begins by setting standards, the benchmarks against which actual performance will be measured.

  2. 2. 'Improving the goodwill of the firm' is an example of a:

    1. quantitative standard
    2. qualitative standard
    3. corrective action
    4. deviation
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Goodwill and employee motivation are qualitative standards; they should be defined in measurable ways wherever possible.

  3. 3. In a large organisation, checking certain pieces at random for quality is called:

    1. personal observation
    2. management by exception
    3. sample checking
    4. critical point control
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Since checking every piece is not possible in a large organisation, certain pieces are checked at random; this is sample checking.

  4. 4. A made-up worker's standard is 400 units a week; she produces 368. By what percentage is her output below standard?

    1. 3.2 per cent
    2. 32 per cent
    3. 9.2 per cent
    4. 8 per cent
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Deviation = 400 − 368 = 32 units. Percentage = (32 ÷ 400) × 100 = 8 per cent below standard.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Standards should be set in quantitative terms as far as possible. Reason (R): Quantitative standards make comparison with actual performance much easier.

    1. A is false, but R is true
    2. A is true, but R is false
    3. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    4. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Both are true and R explains A: when standards are precise and in numbers, actual performance can be compared with them directly.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery